General & Others Rate Every One Piece Arc Post Timeskip so far

[Sir Yasheen]

Only 3 out of the 10 Strawhats got sidelined , Which is Pretty low for Post Timeskip standards….

Nico Robin NEVER moves like this ever in the series this was her first fight in 18 Years when and it’s Her Most In depth fight in the series.

And Sanji? That’s Sanjis First Real Conclusive fight 1v1 since 2006 15 Years.
This was also The first time Sanji Acknowledged his weakness for Women and how it effects the crew. First time we get internal dialogue like this for Sanji.

Law and Kid Vs Big Mom Is The Best fight without Strawhats in the One Piece Series

And Zoro
this was the most Zoro has struggled in 20 Years……

Three chapters of fights that felt rushed and unfinished don’t excuse over 150 chapters of straw hats being put on the backseat for random samurai…

 

[NicoRobinIsQueen]

Fishman: absolute shit, only thing I liked was the Robin showcase 2/10
Punk hazard: actually kinda good, good mini arc and fun villain and great buildup arc, 7.4/10
Dressrosa: the build up for doffy was amazing, too bad it was fumbled 4/10
Wholecake: hated the switching back and forth from kat fight to something else, cracker fight was peak tho 6/10
Zou 1/10, awful
Wano act 1, liked Tama, not much else, 5/10
Wano act 2, cool prison break, hated big mom 6/10
Wano act 3, peak, Robin fight, kidd and law vs big mom, etc etc 9/10
Reverie, best arc of all time 10/10
Egghead, mid besides Blackbeard stuff, kidd vs shanks, and cross guild but still good 8/10
Elbaf, loving it 8/10

 

[Logiko]

Three chapters of fights that felt rushed and unfinished don’t excuse over 150 chapters of straw hats being put on the backseat for random samurai…

Damn the hate remained strong here.

Wano was never about the strawhats, but Luffy and the Samourais and it's ok! This story is made to be able to focus on things others than the main cast, it's created specifically in that intent. We need to accept that and understand that projecting what we know of others stories on One Piece will only lead us to deception as One Piece is not like others stories.

You will never appreciate any story if you keep pushing your expectations on them.

----

EVERY SINGLE narrative trashtalking arguments that I have heard in the fanbase in the last 15 years aside from a few valid points rely on a biased vision of One Piece.

It's actually insane, they are so repetitive that I could predict them in whole cake for Wano 3 years in advance.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Damn the hate remained strong here.

Wano was never about the strawhats, but Luffy and the Samourais and it's ok! This story is made to be able to focus on things others than the main cast, it's created specifically in that intent. We need to accept that and understand that projecting what we know of others stories on One Piece will only lead us to deception as One Piece is not like others stories.

You will never appreciate any story if you keep pushing your expectations on them.

----

EVERY SINGLE narrative trashtalking arguments that I have heard in the fanbase in the last 15 years aside from a few valid points rely on a biased vision of One Piece.

It's actually insane, they are so repetitive that I could predict them in whole cake for Wano 3 years in advance.

I think expecting the protagonists to be you know… important is a very valid criticism lmao

Hey if you wanna read stories where the straw hats are useless barring a small fight at the end, that’s on you. But it’s not my cup of tea at all

 

[Etemenanki]

Fishman Island Arc - 6/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 7.5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 7/10
Zou- 7.5/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 7.5/10
Wano Arc - 7/10
Egghead Island Arc - 7.5/10

For comparison,
Alabasta, Skypea and Water Seven/Enies Lobby are >= 9
Marineford 8
Thriller Bark 8.5
etc.

 

[Logiko]

I think expecting the protagonists to be you know… important is a very valid criticism lmao

Hey if you wanna read stories where the straw hats are useless barring a small fight at the end, that’s on you. But it’s not my cup of tea at all

In the entire story yes. Not in in all the arcs of said story. In One Piece, the main cast evolves with times, it's not stuck in place. It has always been the case from the start.

The argument that I always hear "Oda is not focused on the important character" is not only wrong, it's fallacious. Because the Strawhat are only a PART of the important characters.

None of the strawhats are useless in One Piece. Absolutely none. They all shines differentely thorough the entire story. We must put an end to this bogus argument.

Now, I can understand that you would prefer something else. I'm not talking to you specifically, I only use your comment to coutner something that I've seen repeted again and again. But I think it's important that you understand that a lot of those arguments are not relatives to the actual narrative quality of the story.

One Piece has its narrative flaws (there are a few in Wano) but they are never really brought up

 

[Topi Jerami]

LMAO, Sorry mods but man f*ck our government, u saw the vid where one of DPR can't even do basic math for House allowances? Mayne we are so f*cked, the ratio about our payment in average than them is astonishing like holy moly, they are basically as good as OP Government with their Heavenly Tribute as in tax for ours lol

Hidup Jokowi, Hidup ibu Puan

"Bung Karno's granddaughter" as campaign slogan

People here memeing Sanji got called as Judge's son, while Puan requested herself to be called as Bung Karno's granddaughter.

 

[GrandmasterChef Zonji]

"Bung Karno's granddaughter" as campaign slogan

People here memeing Sanji got called as Judge's son, while Puan requested herself to be called as Bung Karno's granddaughter.

OMG lol, Thank god i've never seen this
She gonna use this again as her President Campaign huh

 

[Topi Jerami]

OMG lol, Thank god i've never seen this
She gonna use this again as her President Campaign huh

2029 candidates are most likely Gibran the Fufufafa bro
Do you follow the case of Fufufafa? Our current Vice President was former internet troll with anonymous Kaskus account, who used to keep trolling the... current Presiden And now both got along and pretend Fufufafa never existed

 

[GrandmasterChef Zonji]

2029 candidates are most likely Gibran the Fufufafa bro
Do you follow the case of Fufufafa? Our current Vice President was former internet troll with anonymous Kaskus account, who used to keep trolling the... current Presiden And now both got along and pretend Fufufafa never existed

Yes i do lol, It was funny as hell, Blud really went dumbfounded too.
He isn't Competent either just like our Government Officials
Our country never cease to make us stop laughing bro

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

0=Trash/Worst Arc in The Series
5=Mid/Mediocre/Avg
10=Perfect/Peak/Best Arc in The Series

Fishman Island Arc - 4/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 4.5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 7/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 6.7/10
Wano Arc - 7.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 8/10

Elbaf - TBD but so far 8.1/10


Drop Your Ratings Below

Fishman Island - 4/10
Punk Hazard - 4.9/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6.8/10

Dressrosa is hard carried by the flashbacks, Law & Doflamingo. It'd drop by an easy 2 points without Doffy's charisma

Zou - 10/10
Tottoland - 4/10

This arc built up and tore down Linlin, gave us the power rangers, gave us Charlotte fucking Cracker and the Donut Muncher. Filler of an arc since Luffy barely uses future sight in any distinguishable way.

Wano Arc - 3/10

Didn't like most of the side-protagonist characters, didn't like Oden or his flashback. The Beast Pirates really got zero development and were used as villains of the week and kaido is like a poor man's Loki.

Lot of cool shit in here too but I'll never forgive Oda for giving Kawamatsu more panel time than Jack the Drought. When Wano Arc ended, I had a loathing for over half the arc's cast whenever they'd appear.

Egghead Island Arc - 5.5/10

Not great but some cool moments and potential. The world feels like it's moving and progressing, even if I didn't like Vegapunk much at all and thought Kizaru's arc was half assed.

Elbaph so far - 5/10

Not a fan of the Giants, the world building of the island itself feels light. This flashback is cool, Loki is cool, I really like the Holy Knights but I haven't been sold by Imunko.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Three chapters of fights that felt rushed and unfinished don’t excuse over 150 chapters of straw hats being put on the backseat for random samurai…

I always have to remind myself that Onigashima is essentially the Marineford of Post-Timeskip, Oda spent 403 chapters on this saga and the Straw Hats barely got acceptable fights. Hell, Brook and Chopper didn't even have proper opponents.

 

[Logiko]

Fishman Island - 4/10
Punk Hazard - 4.9/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6.8/10

Dressrosa is hard carried by the flashbacks, Law & Doflamingo. It'd drop by an easy 2 points without Doffy's charisma

Zou - 10/10
Tottoland - 4/10

This arc built up and tore down Linlin, gave us the power rangers, gave us Charlotte fucking Cracker and the Donut Muncher. Filler of an arc since Luffy barely uses future sight in any distinguishable way.

Wano Arc - 3/10

Didn't like most of the side-protagonist characters, didn't like Oden or his flashback. The Beast Pirates really got zero development and were used as villains of the week and kaido is like a poor man's Loki.

Lot of cool shit in here too but I'll never forgive Oda for giving Kawamatsu more panel time than Jack the Drought. When Wano Arc ended, I had a loathing for over half the arc's cast whenever they'd appear.

Egghead Island Arc - 5.5/10

Not great but some cool moments and potential. The world feels like it's moving and progressing, even if I didn't like Vegapunk much at all and thought Kizaru's arc was half assed.

Elbaph so far - 5/10

Not a fan of the Giants, the world building of the island itself feels light. This flashback is cool, Loki is cool, I really like the Holy Knights but I haven't been sold by Imunko.

With the release of Superman, I think I'm starting to understand how so many people can hate certain arcs despite their objective narrative qualities.

If I can give you a little prediction, there are very little to no chances at all that you adore the end of the story.

 

[Topi Jerami]

Yes i do lol, It was funny as hell, Blud really went dumbfounded too.
He isn't Competent either just like our Government Officials
Our country never cease to make us stop laughing bro

It is sad bro....

Have you seen the recent videos of:
1. Gibran showing not happy face while DPR were dancing around
And many people automatically believe "oh wow Gibran is turning good again, Gibran's alter ego Fufufafa is coming back to battle the corrupt DPR!!"

2. Prabowo smiling while DPR were dancing around
People: "oh look Prabowo the former Kopasus is smiling, the DPR is doomed!!"

The people in our country are so easily to get deceived. Either that or buzzers termul infiltrating the social media with the "wow Prabowo / Gibran is turning good again"

People really quickly forget how government opposed us the villagers for years
And then H-1 week before election, government gave people bansos / serangan fajar, and they all automatically choosing Jokowi's dinasty again.
And the history repeats itself..

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

With the release of Superman, I think I'm starting to understand how so many people can hate certain arcs despite their objective narrative qualities.

If I can give you a little prediction, there are very little to no chances at all that you adore the end of the story.

I'm not even sure what characters i cheer for, besides Loki and Sommers. So that's expected

 

[GrandmasterChef Zonji]

It is sad bro....

Have you seen the recent videos of:
1. Gibran showing not happy face while DPR were dancing around
And many people automatically believe "oh wow Gibran is turning good again, Gibran's alter ego Fufufafa is coming back to battle the corrupt DPR!!"

2. Prabowo smiling while DPR were dancing around
People: "oh look Prabowo the former Kopasus is smiling, the DPR is doomed!!"

The people in our country are so easily to get deceived. Either that or buzzers termul infiltrating the social media with the "wow Prabowo / Gibran is turning good again"

People really quickly forget how government opposed us the villagers for years
And then H-1 week before election, government gave people bansos / serangan fajar, and they all automatically choosing Jokowi's dinasty again.
And the history repeats itself..

Welp "SDM Rendah" for a reason lol

Its not a secret between Military fam, but if you didn't know Our current President is a War Criminal lol

 

[Logiko]

I'm not even sure what characters i cheer for, besides Loki and Sommers. So that's expected

I'm sorry for you.

 

[Topi Jerami]

Welp "SDM Rendah" for a reason lol

Its not a secret between Military fam, but if you didn't know Our current President is a War Criminal lol

Lmao as a minority race here, already heard about this everywhere.
My whole big family, my aunt, cousin, parents etc used to say about his. My old boss at work used to say this too

If I may know, who did you pick last year?
01 was famous (at least famous in my circle) as anti Chinese / gerakan 212 / FPI's alliance
02 was War Criminal and abusing age requirement
03 got Megawati and Puan behind them
Majority around me picked 03, I picked 01... It was like each choice had big flaws on them.

 

[GrandmasterChef Zonji]

Lmao as a minority race here, already heard about this everywhere.
My whole big family, my aunt, cousin, parents etc used to say about his. My old boss at work used to say this too

If I may know, who did you pick last year?
01 was famous (at least famous in my circle) as anti Chinese / gerakan 212 / FPI's alliance
02 was War Criminal and abusing age requirement
03 got Megawati and Puan behind them
Majority around me picked 03, I picked 01... It was like each choice had big flaws on them.

GOLPUT lol
Each candidate doesn't bring any good for us, hence why i choose all them to make it Golput. If i would've to choose a president and vice president, its gotta be Ahok and bu Risma Tri Rismaharini. Especially Bu Risma, she singlehandedly bring Surabaya back to their glory again.

 

[moreha9685]

WTF has this thread degenerated into?