Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1158 Spoilers Discussion

Is Harald above the OG Yonkou's?

  • Total voters
    186
Status
Not open for further replies.
Topi Jerami

Topi Jerami

‎
#2,381
#2,381
Sentinel said:
Sure but MF included so many characters, many peak moments, Akainu, Whitebeard and Blackbeard. Ace' death, WB's declaration of One Piece existence.

Drum Island doesn't come close to that. However, if it is Enies Lobby or Skypiea, it's a different story. I also like Drum Island - all pre ts arcs - but MF was still a class of its own.
Click to expand...
Marineford was important, Impel Down was cool too
Amazon Lily though

Amazon Lily arc vs Drum Kingdom arc?
Post automatically merged:

Sir Yasheen said:
1. Alabasta
2. Skypeia
3. Arlong Park
4. Impel Down
5. Water 7/EL
Click to expand...
Swap W7 with Skypeia and you got the perfect Top 3
 
Cross_Marian

Cross_Marian

‎
#2,386
#2,386
Cruxroux said:
Each arc has its charm.

Those who say pre-time arc, most are living in nostalgia.

Post skip arcs were most hyped, from Wano to Elbaf since pre-time skip. Oda just took too long to deliver, making the reader fatigued over it and complaining.

There wasn't much to flashback to back then in pre-time skip, only mysterious.
Click to expand...
No it’s not nostalgia, at least not for me
I reread the pre ts arcs because I wanted to know if nostalgia blinded me
Pre ts OP is sooooo much better, I enjoyed it a lot
The SHC members have a better dynamic, are better characters, each of them has importance and they feel alive
The comedy is peak
The art is way cleaner and the panelling too
The side characters are actually important
and there’s a feeling of adventure
 
Kizaruber Eats

Kizaruber Eats

MORIA STONKS, MORIA CHADS WE FEAST
‎
#2,387
#2,387
Cross_Marian said:
No it’s not nostalgia, at least not for me
I reread the pre ts arcs because I wanted to know if nostalgia blinded me
Pre ts OP is sooooo much better, I enjoyed it a lot
The SHC members have better dynamic, are better characters, each of them has importance and they feel alive
The comedy is peak
The art is way cleaner and the panelling too
The side characters are actually important
and there’s a feeling of adventure
Click to expand...
Exactly man. Nostalgia is such a dismissive, reductionist argument.
 
Sir Yasheen

Sir Yasheen

‎
#2,388
#2,388
Cruxroux said:
Each arc has its charm.

Those who say pre-time arc, most are living in nostalgia.

Post skip arcs were most hyped, from Wano to Elbaf since pre-time skip. Oda just took too long to deliver, making the reader fatigued over it and complaining.

There wasn't much to flashback to back then in pre-time skip, only mysterious.
Click to expand...
Nah pre timeskip arcs are rated higher because of straw hat focus, adventure, solid pacing and the best art in the manga. Things heavily missing from most post timeskip arcs and things people actually like.
 
Sir Yasheen

Sir Yasheen

‎
#2,392
#2,392
Topi Jerami said:
Marineford was important, Impel Down was cool too
Amazon Lily though

Amazon Lily arc vs Drum Kingdom arc?
Post automatically merged:


Swap W7 with Skypeia and you got the perfect Top 3
Click to expand...
Only thing that pulls W7/EL down for me is that it was the first time where I thought “at least one side character should’ve died this arc” like invading a government island and fighting a buster call and every single member of the franky family and galley la crew surviving kinda dropped it for me
 
Cross_Marian

Cross_Marian

‎
#2,394
#2,394
Sir Yasheen said:
Only thing that pulls W7/EL down for me is that it was the first time where I thought “at least one side character should’ve died this arc” like invading a government island and fighting a buster call and every single member of the franky family and galley la crew surviving kinda dropped it for me
Click to expand...
I think Sogeking died
His wounds were too severe
 
Cruxroux

Cruxroux

‎
#2,396
#2,396
Cross_Marian said:
No it’s not nostalgia, at least not for me
I reread the pre ts arcs because I wanted to know if nostalgia blinded me
Pre ts OP is sooooo much better, I enjoyed it a lot
The SHC members have a better dynamic, are better characters, each of them has importance and they feel alive
The comedy is peak
The art is way cleaner and the panelling too
The side characters are actually important
and there’s a feeling of adventure
Click to expand...
Sir Yasheen said:
Nah pre timeskip arcs are rated higher because of straw hat focus, adventure, solid pacing and the best art in the manga. Things heavily missing from most post-timeskip arcs and things people actually like.
Click to expand...
Doesn't apply to everyone.
Again, it will be a matter of different people having different opinions.

Pre time skip left us with more mysteries instead of explaining them.
Post time skip is solving it one by one.
I understand the crew dynamics have changed, but nothing we didn't already see coming. That's an average Shounen plot right there, to start focusing on the MC more than his side characters.

The amount of lore we are getting in post-time skip is much higher than pre-time skip.
The amount of adventure has decreased, yes.

For me, Wano would still stand as the best arc overall. I know the majority won't agree, but that's when I started manga.

I binged-watched the entire show before that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top