Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1158 Spoilers Discussion

[EmperorKinyagi]

It's the first thing

If we saw a flashback of Joyboy and Imu clashing and they didn't sky split, Sanjikun would genuinely argue that pre-G5 Luffy might beat them.

I actually think it’s going to start out Garp vs Roger -> switch to Garp + Roger vs Xebec -> something happens and Garp either goes down or separated -> ends in Roger vs Xebec 1v1

 

[ZenZu]

It seems to me that everyone in this thread seems to unanimously agree that Harald is stronger than Roger and Whitebeard with the exception of the same 5 people who are always wrong about every other topic and have never predicted anything accurately since their reading comprehension is dogshit

No need to even go after Roger or Prime WB? Some of these dudes are arguing rooftop Luffy, Big Mom, and the rest of the Yonkou are above Harald.

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

Garp being embarrassed and not wanting to talk about God Valley means one of three things:

1. he hates that he had to team up with Roger

2. he got his ass handed to him by someone (probably Xebec)

3. he saw the atrocities of the CDs first hand and still decided to side with the government

Either way there is a huge L for Garp on the horizon @zenox

Sengoku already gave the reasons why Garp doesn't like to talk about God Valley

 

[Blackbeard]

Sanjikun just can't bear to watch the list of individuals Doflamingo twerks to growing

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

You mean the scan thousands of people on Reddit bullied Sand Man over

I actually think it’s going to start out Garp vs Roger -> switch to Garp + Roger vs Xebec -> something happens and Garp either goes down or separated -> ends in Roger vs Xebec 1v1

I seriously doubt that but we'll see

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

Sengoku already gave the reasons why Garp doesn't like to talk about God Valley

1v2 almost guaranteed then

 

[Cruxroux]

He knew that it was his last attack in G4 and that he couldn’t fight Kaido without haki. Again G4 isn’t close to being as draining as G5.

Then why did Luffy sleep for 3 days after the fight with Doflamingo?
Luffy is knocked out when the gas is taken out or pumped out ..

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

I seriously doubt that but we'll see

Garp went to God Valley for Roger, but something happened to where he had to team up with Roger instead

If not Xebec overpowering everyone there I can’t really see something else

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

I seriously doubt that but we'll see

You’re comparing 5 idiots dumb enough to believe Roger is even comparable with Xebec, with a scan that literally thousands of people propagated, lmfao

 

[sanjikun]

Sengoku already gave the reasons why Garp doesn't like to talk about God Valley

Oda might do a bait and switch here with Shakky. Both Roger and Rox are pro-Shakky, so the cause might be something else.

It might be some fucked up shit why Roger would team up with Garp to save Celestials (and this seems to be the case since he saved Shanks).

 

[Nidai_Kitetsu]

As much as I typically defend Mihawk (you know I have him equal to Roger which is insane since I think even Kaido might decisively lost to Roger extreme diff) I gotta disagree here. It's specifically worded as "But plenty already speak of them [(them = the days where Whitebeard and Roger were in their primes and reigned over the seas of the Grand Line)] as legends. Even the duel between you and Hawk-Eyes is still news to me."
It was never worded the way you think it is. Unless I saw an incorrect translation, I dunno.

He was talking about all the legendary things that happened within 22 years. That included not only Roger-Garp-Sengoku-Shiki, but also Shanks-Mihawk's days of duels. There was no "EVEN" in the translation. This is from Stephen Paul's old script =>

Spoiler

- Page 78 -

Whitebeard: We fought with Roger so often,
you learn to recognize faces in battle...
What happened to that funny guy with the red nose? He dead already?

Shanks: ...you mean Buggy!
Wow, that takes me back...
We went our separate ways in Loguetown,
on the day the captain died. Haven't seen him since...

<<Shanks: Come with me, Buggy!!

<<Buggy: I'd rather die than work for you, jerkwad!!!

Shanks: Sometimes the grapevine turns up rumors of him still being a pirate.

Whitebeard: It passed in the blink of eye, to me...
But plenty already speak of them as legends.
The days of the duels between you and Hawk-Eyes,
they are still fresh in my ears...
When you came from East Blue,
missing an arm... well, EVERYONE was shocked.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Then why did Luffy sleep for 3 days after the fight with Doflamingo?
Luffy is knocked out when the gas is taken out or pumped out ..

Because he was flying around the entire island and had to spend 30 minutes straight avoiding Doffys massive awakening attacks fighting?

No where’s near similar to his fight with Kaido where the two stayed in a small arena the whole time?

 

[Cruxroux]

Because he was flying around the entire island and had to spend 30 minutes straight avoiding Doffys massive awakening attacks fighting?

And Luffy didn't do that against Kaidou?

No where’s near similar to his fight with Kaido where the two stayed in a small arena the whole time?

Luffy was flying around the island.

More elongated battle than doflamingo. More damage taken and given.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

He was talking about all the legendary things that happened within 22 years. That included not only Roger-Garp-Sengoku-Shiki, but also Shanks-Mihawk's days of duels. There was no "EVEN" in the translation. This is from Stephen Paul's old script =>

Spoiler

- Page 78 -

Whitebeard: We fought with Roger so often,
you learn to recognize faces in battle...
What happened to that funny guy with the red nose? He dead already?

Shanks: ...you mean Buggy!
Wow, that takes me back...
We went our separate ways in Loguetown,
on the day the captain died. Haven't seen him since...

<<Shanks: Come with me, Buggy!!

<<Buggy: I'd rather die than work for you, jerkwad!!!

Shanks: Sometimes the grapevine turns up rumors of him still being a pirate.

Whitebeard: It passed in the blink of eye, to me...
But plenty already speak of them as legends.
The days of the duels between you and Hawk-Eyes,
they are still fresh in my ears...
When you came from East Blue,
missing an arm... well, EVERYONE was shocked.

I kind of see your point but I still believe he might have been talking about that as a separate thing from the whole "many people already speak of those days as legends" thing.

You’re comparing 5 idiots dumb enough to believe Roger is even comparable with Xebec, with a scan that literally thousands of people propagated, lmfao

Tons of people also believed ZKK would happen yet it didn't
I don't care how many people believe something, that doesn't determine whether or not it makes sense

 

[Sir Yasheen]

And Luffy didn't do that against Kaidou?



Luffy was flying around the island.

More elongated battle than doflamingo. More damage taken and given.

No. Onigashima is a very small battlefield in comparison to Dressrosa. Onigashima is smaller than the flower capital afterall

 

[Cruxroux]

Tons of people also believed ZKK would happen yet it didn't
I don't care how many people believe something, that doesn't determine whether or not it makes sense

Zoro fans theorised and made a "theory"
Admirals believed that shit like the bible.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Guys, can't we all agree Crydo is a fodder fish and call it a day?

 

[Midnight Delight]

No need to even go after Roger or Prime WB? Some of these dudes are arguing rooftop Luffy, Big Mom, and the rest of the Yonkou are above Harald.

You also have Yonko Commander wankers having meltdowns about their faves being pushed out of the Top 100

 

[Cruxroux]

No. Onigashima is a tiny battlefield in comparison to Dressrosa. Onigashima is smaller than the flower capital after all

Luffy was not flying around the entire Dressrosa.

The bridge cage was limiting the distance, too.

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

There was no stupidity in Kizaru's action, it was a deliberate action to withhold himself from winning
Of course it was obvious, normal people saw through it, but Admiral hating goblins needed direct confirmation

Side note, impeccable avatar. Lol