Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1162 Spoilers Discussion

Is Garling done this war ?


  • Total voters
    143
Status
Not open for further replies.
Or oda simply doesn't remember everything or retconned it.

World building in one piece is massive so it's likely not to remember every minor detail. And, it's not possible to map every plot in detial in advance as well. Blue print yes...but all the details? Nope

So, oda will retcon things as he will map story in details with each chapter
Yeah, it could be that he just forgets things, but doesn't he also have his editors to remind him of these things? Or, are they afraid to correct Oda?



Was this true after all?
:sus:

But I'll go with your retcon / forgot example for now. Sounds plausible.
 
Anways Garling fraud-allegations aside, it's interesting to know that the Rocks Pirates actually fought Imu on God Valley.
Wonder if that's why Newgate told Oden that it was impossible to challenge the WG or something along those lines in Oden's flashback. Would be mad Imu hype if he solos Rocks, Newagate and Kaido with his newly acquired DF all at once. Also think we could potentially see all of the Gorosei make an appearance on God Valley as well kinda like Egghead which could be interesting ^^ but these events make it even more mind boggling why Roger and Garp would've chosen to fight Rocks on God Valley. If anything you'd think it'd be a team effort against Imu and his forces who are clearly the antagonists of the arc. Also this is out of left field but I wonder if Roger's illness might have something to do with the events on God Valley:Think:
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Anways Garling fraud-allegations aside, it's interesting to know that the Rocks Pirates actually fought Imu on God Valley.
Wonder if that's why Newgate told Oden that it was impossible to challenge the WG or something along those lines in Oden's flashback. Would be mad Imu hype if he solos Rocks, Newagate and Kaido with his newly acquired DF all at once. Also think we could potentially see all of the Gorosei make an appearance on God Valley as well kinda like Egghead which could be interesting ^^ but these events make it even more mind boggling why Roger and Garp would've chosen to fight Rocks on God Valley. If anything you'd think it'd be a team effort against Imu and his forces who are clearly the antagonists of the arc. Also this out of left field but I wonder if Roger's illness might have something to do with the events on God Valley:Think:
I don't think IMU soloed them.

We still haven't seen Roger and Garp fighting Xebec as WG proclaimed.

If IMU was the one who did it then WG had no reason to give glory and credits to Roger.
 
I don't think IMU soloed them.

We still haven't seen Roger and Garp fighting Xebec as WG proclaimed.

If IMU was the one who did it then WG had no reason to give glory and credits to Roger.
Hmmn...
In which case did Xebec get demonified-then? coz that is the only logical reason I can think of for those two fighting him but honestly not sure I like that flow of events. Feels a bit too contrived.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Hmmn...
In which case did Xebec get demonified-then? coz that is the only logical reason I can think of for those two fighting him but honestly not sure I like that flow of events. Feels a bit too contrived.
If he got demonified then why IMU will make him fight Roger and Garp?

Either something happened which made Roger and Garp fight Xebec


Or

Xebec is the one who fought IMU

WB and Kaido fought Roger and Garp

This way Roger and Garp defeated Rocks pirates and Xebec along with the island was wiped out from the history by IMU
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top