Theory Shamrock is the secret right hand man of Shanks

[Monkey D Theories]

Shanks is the child of destiny. He inherited Roger’s hat and his fighting style. Buggy even thought Shanks could be PK.

While in terms of feats, Shanks legitimately doesn’t look much different than Roger. His crew is lacking tbh.

Shanks warned Lucky Roo and some others against fighting Kid. That implies that apart from maybe Beckman, none of the RHP commanders are monsters like Rayleigh, Gaban, or Oden.

While the RHP are ultimately meant to be surpassed, given how much attention Oda is giving to them, imo he will at least make them competitive with the BBP. It wouldn’t really be fair if Kuzan could solo Shanks’s entire crew.

I think the best way for Oda to do this is by having Shamrock be a traitor and the secret RHM of Shanks. We know their mother wanted both kids to grow up right, and that Garling murdered her at the end. I wouldn’t be surprised if Shanks and Shamrock are secretly working together to undermine the WG.

Ultimately I think when the RHP have their final showdown against the BBP or the WG, Shamrock will be by Shanks’s side.

 

[Master OF Haki]

Mihawk being Shanks' secret right hand man makes much more sense then Shamrock will ever be.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

 

[Reborn]

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Mihawk being Shanks' secret right hand man makes much more sense then Shamrock will ever be.

We know little to nothing about Shamrock

Mihawk, however, is said to be above Shanks

 

[soupongo]

Making Shamrock not evil, would basically undo any reason for him to even be in the story. Why would Oda introduce a character in the government, doing evil shit, just so he can make Shanks´s crew appear stronger, when he could have just spent time hyping up Beckman instead?

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

As many others said Shanks hitting his head is a direct copy of Goku's origins in Dragon Ball
He became a kinder person due to hitting his head after falling into a ravine as a baby while his brother was still evil. Same will happen with Shanks and Shamrock

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Making Shamrock not evil, would basically undo any reason for him to even be in the story. Why would Oda introduce a character in the government, doing evil shit, just so he can make Shanks´s crew appear stronger, when he could have just spent time hyping up Beckman instead?

Every single villain org has had traitors

it’s a way for the SHs to survive otherwise impossible odds

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Every single villain org has had traitors

it’s a way for the SHs to survive otherwise impossible odds

what about this tho

As many others said Shanks hitting his head is a direct copy of Goku's origins in Dragon Ball
He became a kinder person due to hitting his head after falling into a ravine as a baby while his brother was still evil. Same will happen with Shanks and Shamrock

 

[soupongo]

Every single villain org has had traitors

it’s a way for the SHs to survive otherwise impossible odds

The implication seems to be that Gunko will end up being the traitor of the HK.

 

[moreha9685]

I have to applaud your ability to always--always!--come up with the wrongest possibilities. It's a gift. Not for theories or common sense. But it's a gift nonetheless.

 

[Master OF Haki]

We know little to nothing about Shamrock

Mihawk, however, is said to be above Shanks

So let me check the fact list.

Shamrock: we know his father, mother, his brother, where he grew up, his sword has a DF ability and he has some kind of special lineage.

Mihawk: he has a black blade.

 

[Flappy]

I have to applaud your ability to always--always!--come up with the wrongest possibilities. It's a gift. Not for theories or common sense. But it's a gift nonetheless.

Really! I came to this website for good theories. But it's stupid ones like this I start coming less and less.

 

[Rej]

I hope not. Sounds like a shitty idea lol

 

[Blax Blah]

I like the theory

Shamrock might be weaker than Ben Beckman though

 

[Monkey D Theories]

what about this tho

That makes no sense because babies aren’t born evil. Furthermore Oda has shown that even CDs can change their ways(see: Myosgard).

 

[Luffy is the mc]

You don't need Ray or Gaban level character to deal with Kidd. Cracker's level is enough.

So he doesn't need Shamrocks in his crew to be a Yonko. Assuming Shamrocks is any stronger than Beckmann.

 

[moreha9685]

Let me raise the opposite possibility.

If the HKs are supposed to mirror CP9, but on a large scale, and CP9 were undercover inside the carpenters' guild of Water 7, could it be that Shamrock used his twin's likeness to infiltrate someplace important pretending to be Shanks? Maybe Elbaf itself?

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

That makes no sense because babies aren’t born evil. Furthermore Oda has shown that even CDs can change their ways(see: Myosgard).

Sure but why make Shanks hit his head as a baby then?

 

[AL sama]

That makes no sense because babies aren’t born evil. Furthermore Oda has shown that even CDs can change their ways(see: Myosgard).

fiction ain't reality