Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1167 Spoilers Discussion

[park_min young]

This is basically impossible

Harald dies 14 years ago, the same year Ginny is captured. I could see it being the reason he quits and is killed, but theres zero reason for him to kidnap her. How could a man his size even do it lol

The reason is that Shamrock or Garlic fancied Ginny then ordered Harald to kidnap her. Either that or Harald at least witnessed everything from the side.

There’s nobody else who could have done it, you think rando WG agents can forcefully take away Ginny? This reeks of HK involvement, they’re the only ones competent enough to do so, and Oda hid the actual culprit so that he can reveal it later.

 

[Paperchampion23]

Your sarcasm detector needs work.

More that i clearly didnt read the whole conversation. Thats on me lol

Post automatically merged: Wednesday at 9:28 PM

The reason is that Shamrock or Garlic fancied Ginny then ordered Harald to kidnap her. Either that or Harald at least witnessed everything from the side.

There’s nobody else who could have done it, you think rando WG agents can forcefully take away Ginny? This reeks of HK involvement, they’re the only ones competent enough to do so, and Oda hid the actual culprit so that he can reveal it later.

Bro, Cipher Pol exists for this reason.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Btw God Valley suggests that the Knights of God by themselves should reach the number of 13.

Spoiler

Consider these 7, then add Gunko and the 2 we only saw in the God Valley introduction and we're already at 10...

Spoiler

some of these clowns could be god's blades like gunko

 

[Fujishiro]

Lee loses all semblance of sanity or logic when it comes to shitting on Shanks, he just starts foaming at the mouth lol.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

The spoilers literally say its Shanks who freed him lmao

So what do you think did BB scar saint shanks or pre MJ hobo Shanks?

 

[Ricassian]

some of these clowns could be god's blades like gunko

It's possible

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

Ok? Didn’t you guys use to complain about him being a Gary Stu?

Absolutely, I love this development. I always said the only thing Oda could do with Saint Shanks is to completely assassinate his character, so this chapter is beautiful for me. Lol

 

[MonochromeYoru]

The reason is that Shamrock or Garlic fancied Ginny then ordered Harald to kidnap her. Either that or Harald at least witnessed everything from the side.

There’s nobody else who could have done it, you think rando WG agents can forcefully take away Ginny? This reeks of HK involvement, they’re the only ones competent enough to do so, and Oda hid the actual culprit so that he can reveal it later.

Gotta be Garlic no?

I feel like oda making shamcock and the gary stu rat be friends means oda gonna try to tone down shamcock

 

[Paperchampion23]

So what do you think did BB scar saint shanks or pre MJ hobo Shanks?

Seemed very recent so probably Saint Shanks? Lol

 

[MonochromeYoru]

So what do you think did BB scar saint shanks or pre MJ hobo Shanks?

hobo shank thought he was hot stuff

Got humbled by BB

Ran crying to imu and got the regen

But BB haki was too powerful and left scar

 

[Paperchampion23]

Gotta be Garlic no?

I feel like oda making shamcock and the gary stu rat be friends means oda gonna try to tone down shamcock

Honestly it doesnt sound like they are friends. Shanks is just infiltrating and they have a relationship

Hopefully its actually Shamrock because that would make him 10x more fucked as a villain lol

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Honestly it doesnt sound like they a friends. Shanks is just infiltrating and they have a relationship

Hopefully its actually Shamrock because that would make him 10x more fucked as a villain lol

@SDfear said they kinda seem like friends

 

[Shiroyru]

Gotta be Garlic no?

I feel like oda making shamcock and the gary stu rat be friends means oda gonna try to tone down shamcock

Ginny was “only” that CD’s 8th wife. A 60 year old Garling would have way more wives than that

 

[Fujishiro]

Absolutely, I love this development. I always said the only thing Oda could do with Saint Shanks is to completely assassinate his character, so this chapter is beautiful for me. Lol

His character is more interesting now though, he lived a pirate. Joined the WG to spy on them, and gather intel imo to help take them down down the line.

Amassed influence and power in the outside world as well. Is now moving for the end game now that Luffys fruit awakened.

Its all coming together.

This chapter actually moves him towards being a good guy who will help Luffy against Imu.

 

[Lor D. Coast]

Saint Seiya > saint shanks

Shanks' one of those steel saints.

 

[park_min young]

More that i clearly didnt read the whole conversation. Thats on me lol

Post automatically merged: Wednesday at 9:28 PM

Bro, Cipher Pol exists for this reason.

Bro really said Cipher Pol
If they ain’t a part of Lucci’s gang or CP0, they ain’t shit. Ginny was the East commander of the revos at the time, random fodders aren’t beating her lol.

The 14 years connection is at least suspicious, and the fact that gender-reversed Bonney looks like a Figarland. HKs were personally involved.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Ginny was “only” that CD’s 8th wife. A 60 year old Garling would have way more wives than that

Maybe she caught garlic's eye at the beginning of a cycle of new "wives"

 

[Paperchampion23]

@SDfear said they kinda seem like friends

Based on what? I know hes not a provider lol, i can tell you that much

From their current relationship in this spoiler text its clear Shamrock just thinks his brother is trying to advance. Whatever relationship they have doesnt really matter, we know Shamrock is garbage like his father given it was his idea to kidnap Elbaf children and make a game out of it

 

[Unlimited Rulebook]

until we see him do it, it didn't happen

oda ain't gonna make his fav into someone like that

he shall remain a gary stu

...IS BOUND to DRAW
CURIOSITY...
....STAND
ON OPPOSING SIDES OF WORLD POWER...
HUFF...
...A GREAT PIRATE AND A CELESTIAL DRAGON...
TRUE, IT AIN'T MY BUSINESS, HUFF... BUT...
THE FACT THAT YOU HAVE THE SAME FACE...
HE RETURNED TO THE HOLY LAND ONCE, BUT HE SEEMS TO PREFER THE FILTH OF THE LOWER WORLD...
THAT
PIRATE IS MY ESTRANGED
YOUNGER TWIN BROTHER...
YOU'LL
RUE THIS DAY...
HUFF...
HUFF !!
RETURNED...?
HUFF... I SEE...
THEN YOUR BLOODLINE HAS EARNED MY IRE TWICE OVER!!
ONCE I GET THESE
CHAINS OFF...
HOW
FASCINATING, THAT TWO SEPARATED BROTHERS SHOULD EACH BE TARGETS OF MY WRATH...


Yep, Shanks is pirate that went inside for recon.

 

[Bogard]

Shamrock: "It's wiser to wait till you're all healed up, Shanks..."

I wonder which injury Shamrock is referring to here ? Is it his eye scars injuries, meaning they are fresh ? Or is it an injury contracted when he allowed Fisher Tiger to escape ? If it's the former, it'd mean that Blackbeard scarred him shortly before his arrival in MJ(so when Shanks was 24). If it's the latter, it might be a self inflected injury that Shanks caused to himself to make it seem like he got it during Fisher Tiger's escape

In either case, the bandages certainly suggest Blackbeard scarred him around that time(15years ago), which is presumably around the same time of his duels with Mihawk.

Base Teach upscale