Status
Not open for further replies.

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
Bois, where are we scaling DR Dorry/Brogy? :bamathink:
If they are worth 1.8bil without DR buff, it implies they are in the YC1 ballpark.
Where are they with DR buff?

Size-wise they have probably grown bigger than even Ancient Giant Loki.
However, Loki has a DF that further enables him to grow even bigger in Hybrid and even bigger in Zoan form.
They do not have the power of handful of strongest but they do have the regen ability from Domi Reversi.

Is it fair to say they are equal to base Loki who isnt using aCoC? Are they top tier in the same ballpark as the Admirals?
 
Bois, where are we scaling DR Dorry/Brogy? :bamathink:
If they are worth 1.8bil without DR buff, it implies they are in the YC1 ballpark.
Where are they with DR buff?

Size-wise they have probably grown bigger than even Ancient Giant Loki.
However, Loki has a DF that further enables him to grow even bigger in Hybrid and even bigger in Zoan form.
They do not have the power of handful of strongest but they do have the regen ability from Domi Reversi.

Is it fair to say they are equal to base Loki who isnt using aCoC? Are they top tier in the same ballpark as the Admirals?
~ Crocodile and Hancock each. Even pre-TS Oda gave them similar "frozen" bounties.

That is before DR.
 
Bois, where are we scaling DR Dorry/Brogy? :bamathink:
If they are worth 1.8bil without DR buff, it implies they are in the YC1 ballpark.
Where are they with DR buff?

Size-wise they have probably grown bigger than even Ancient Giant Loki.
However, Loki has a DF that further enables him to grow even bigger in Hybrid and even bigger in Zoan form.
They do not have the power of handful of strongest but they do have the regen ability from Domi Reversi.

Is it fair to say they are equal to base Loki who isnt using aCoC? Are they top tier in the same ballpark as the Admirals?
Inbetweener tier without the buff (basically equal to characters like Hancock, Zoro, Sanji, Law, Ace, etc.)
With the buff they're at least old legend level if not slightly above
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
Yeah this is not the part where we retcon GV Garling into being anywhere near top-tier in response to Zoro's feat lool.

GV Garling was ass, he'd be lucky to be YC1 — GV Garling vs Regular Dorry would be a decent matchup, let alone vs DR Dorry. DR Dorry and Brogy vs GV Garling is a shitstomp outside of regen. Comparing GV Garling to Shamrock is insane.

Zoro doing well against a much stronger crowd would be a fantastic feat, if that's what happened (panels pending). We need to see how this battle pans out.
Retcon? You got it completely twisted. Garling was a top tier in everyones eyes, only when he got bodied by Xebec (the feat we are discussing), is when the first claims of him not being a top tier came out.

Let me reword it, Xebec's feat was so impressive that we as a community agreed that Garling couldn't be a top tier 😂

There's your answer for why that feat was being gassed. We have no idea how strong Shamrock is...but he is perceived as a top tier same as Garling used to be, so if Zoro defeated what we perceived as a top tier along with immortal backup, yes the feat would be gassed to the moon, even if Shamrock would have to be moved down a tier.

Beating on some no name fodder DRs is not even remotely impressive, and it wouldn't be impressive if Xebec did it either. It was because he basically did it with one hand taking on Garling (the biggest name in the entire faction) while also protecting his family.
 

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
Retcon? You got it completely twisted. Garling was a top tier in everyones eyes, only when he got bodied by Xebec (the feat we are discussing), is when the first claims of him not being a top tier came out.

Let me reword it, Xebec's feat was so impressive that we as a community agreed that Garling couldn't be a top tier 😂

There's your answer for why that feat was being gassed. We have no idea how strong Shamrock is...but he is perceived as a top tier same as Garling used to be, so if Zoro defeated what we perceived as a top tier along with immortal backup, yes the feat would be gassed to the moon, even if Shamrock would have to be moved down a tier.

Beating on some no name fodder DRs is not even remotely impressive, and it wouldn't be impressive if Xebec did it either. It was because he basically did it with one hand taking on Garling (the biggest name in the entire faction) while also protecting his family.
Beating aCOC-less Garling is the same as beating aCoC-less Oden - of no consequences to Garling/Oden with aCoC.
 
I don’t see the Zoro hype he supposedly beats giant fodder but then Plays tom and Jerry with dorry and broggy Leakers made it seem like he pulled a jiren lol.

And sommers is 100% dying this arc ggs
 
Retcon? You got it completely twisted. Garling was a top tier in everyones eyes, only when he got bodied by Xebec (the feat we are discussing), is when the first claims of him not being a top tier came out.

Let me reword it, Xebec's feat was so impressive that we as a community agreed that Garling couldn't be a top tier 😂

There's your answer for why that feat was being gassed. We have no idea how strong Shamrock is...but he is perceived as a top tier same as Garling used to be, so if Zoro defeated what we perceived as a top tier along with immortal backup, yes the feat would be gassed to the moon, even if Shamrock would have to be moved down a tier.

Beating on some no name fodder DRs is not even remotely impressive, and it wouldn't be impressive if Xebec did it either. It was because he basically did it with one hand taking on Garling (the biggest name in the entire faction) while also protecting his family.
Yes, which is when he was revealed to be a fraud, a notion believed by 99% of the OP fandom lmao, you can't have it both ways — you can't hype Xebec for beating Garling and revealing GV Garling to be a bum, and in the same vein hype Xebec for beating GV Garling, as if GV Garling has any remotely impressive feat or even the slightest lick of ACoC.

Your argument is contradictory lol do you believe that Garling was a top-tier on GV, yes or no? If yes, I have no idea why and you're on your own with that one. If no, then I don't get your point — minus regen, GV Garling is obviously weaker than DR Dorry and Brogy combined and arguably weaker than them individually. DR Dorry and Brogy couldn't hit Zoro with much stronger backup.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top