essentially im treated as magic was in last game, the difference is im hardly pushing you or your town reads
but you're treating me as if im outed all the same, without really talking through our differences first
it's bad faith
And that’s a disingenuous take.
Magic pushed us knowing we‘re Indies. He also pushed the guy scums needed dead and even tried killing him. What good faith is there to extent to a player who in the best case, is the scum team‘s biggest asset in such a scenario and worst case is just scum? He felt outed because he kept going even after knowing the guy he‘s pushing was a target for scum and went after Indies and even defended two scums who were obvious as hell.
Meanwhile I considered you could be Town even. But you’re demonstrating a very scummy mindset by hedging on your read. I told you multiple times I wouldn’t be mad if you scum read me, but just commit to anything. You keep spamming me with nonsense, too. You could be voting me and I would probably view you more favorably. But what you’re doing feels like trying to play people against each other (like Ginger and Insomnia) and you feel like you’re afraid to push anyone harder. If you have a strong scum read, push it yourself. Don’t ask people if they would be willing to vote somewhere. That’s just weak sauce. Make a case, make your stance clear and push your preferred direction instead of picking multiple dishes from a buffet and trying to eat them all.