[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

[Jan]

Marimo feels too wolfy to be a wolf. It looks like they got signed up by accident. But literally I really don’t see how he intends to win as wolf if his strategy is to say “nah I’m just not gonna read” or to show up only at EOD to say “who are we killing?”. It just looks like 0 attempt to blend in and look town and it also looks like he’s making 0 moves to push ppl so I literally just believe he’s a checked-out town who didn’t even want to be here more than I believe he’s the world’s most obvious scum

Orca and Rej I need to look into again but so far I remember liking the fact that Orca brought up how at EOD1 it looked like the wagons weren’t moving and started drawing attention to how weird it looks, and I don’t think scum would want to draw that much attention to that fact in a time where it benefits mafia to not bring it up. And Rej I thought it was towny to put in an effort to play somewhat despite not really wanting to play. It’s day 2 so I know I need stronger reasons than this if I want to town them, so yeah I’ll take another look there honestly.

And Ratchet I know they’re a really good player and I also know that they’re gonna be difficult to read via activity or posting bc they’re good as both alignments. I’m not even gonna consider looking there unless it’s day 3 or day 4 and they’re still alive and haven’t cooked

do you have any ideas on who scum is? Cuz it looks like you’re just questioning ppl. Not that it’s scummy to ask questions but I just wanna make sure you’re not just asking questions to look like youre solving

Someone said Marino basically ghosting is his scum play.
I think best case it is nai.
The fact that nobody has pushed the slot even after tepig mentioned it earlier today is a bad look.

I didn't ask you for those slots because I have them all as town.
I think your Poe combined with those slots (and maybe hayumi if reloaded flips town) hits most of the team.

I asked you for reads on them because you implied a strong enough reason to townread any but but your Poe.
I was hoping for a strong enough read worth sheeping for a while.

Never lucky.

 

[York]

Vote Lynch Shuijing

Well, I think we still have something like 23 hours until EoD so I’ll return after work and at least give a legacy, and claim if necessaryl

Theres like 3 hours now so feel free to do this at any time

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Upon reread of Rej it still looks like they’re busy and trying their best to keep up with the game

I don’t think wolves do this in game states where it benefits them to just chill and let ppl move along and kill each other for them

 

[Jan]

Idk

it’s the same reasoning I give for ppl who are wagons the entire day and don’t get defended at any point and those usually end up being town.

speaking of, shui has been a wagon for at least 20-30 hours now and there hasn’t been that big of a change. Does that not worry anyone? Cuz that’s usually a huge red flag for me

It feels more like a dead leftover wagon than a threat to me.
Ofc it means that scum did not bother to push away for him either.

If I was scum I would not bother in this state and tell my team to keep calm and carry on.
But a more reactionary scum team could easily handle it differently and in that world shuijing is town for the lack of help.

 

[Polar Bear]

Me, Polar and TAG have been wagoning Juliet for 24 hours. You didn't mention anything about it, you didn't join with a vote. I can say you put a hand in it "dying out".

Polar has been putting Juliet as his most red read since d1 now and sitting with vote whole phase. You think it could be unpairing play?


@Polar Bear I need your opinion on this.

Just woke up, haven't read yet but just looking at your 2 posts inna vacuum....

Either he's scum with Juliet and wants to make an attempt at distancing

Or

He's scum and wants to direct the attention to Juliet instead of a top wagon that is scum

Either way his post doesn't feel genuine or natural in the timing of things

 

[Polar Bear]

How long until eod?

 

[Luka]

Upon reread of Rej it still looks like they’re busy and trying their best to keep up with the game

I don’t think wolves do this in game states where it benefits them to just chill and let ppl move along and kill each other for them

I rescind my town here lol
idk how this is a real thought when they have 2 reads and have very clearly not given this game any thought

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

It feels more like a dead leftover wagon than a threat to me.
Ofc it means that scum did not bother to push away for him either.

If I was scum I would not bother in this state and tell my team to keep calm and carry on.
But a more reactionary scum team could easily handle it differently and in that world shuijing is town for the lack of help.

I’m just saying historically wagons where there’s no movement from start of day til EOD is a huge red flag and almost always flips town

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I rescind my town here lol
idk how this is a real thought when they have 2 reads and have very clearly not given this game any thought

Cuz they’re trying to read up and play the game too

 

[Jan]

I don’t town read Ginger or Hayumi
Ginger I feel as though I wouldnt be suprised if they were top posting wolf & Hayumi is like whayever

The way Tepig approached flower is just not how he wolves I dont think

You kind of dodged my hime question there.

Fine to not townread the other 2, but that does not make home town.

 

[Luka]

Cuz they’re trying to read up and play the game too

No they arent

 

[Luka]

You kind of dodged my hime question there.

Fine to not townread the other 2, but that does not make home town.

I didnt dodge it I just forgot you asked that
I just think her posting around ratchet on sub in was towny

 

[Luka]

No they arent

Like what even causes you to think this

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Marimo feels too wolfy to be a wolf. It looks like they got signed up by accident. But literally I really don’t see how he intends to win as wolf if his strategy is to say “nah I’m just not gonna read” or to show up only at EOD to say “who are we killing?”. It just looks like 0 attempt to blend in and look town and it also looks like he’s making 0 moves to push ppl so I literally just believe he’s a checked-out town who didn’t even want to be here more than I believe he’s the world’s most obvious scum

His terrible enterance aside, I do kind of agree with the "too scummy to be scum" argument. It's why Mafia just won't be a bunch of inactives.

 

[Charlie]

So like, Rej takes a lead of like 3 votes Rn

@Rej you're probably going to get lynched soon

Can you like, claim your role/actions?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

My trs as of rn are probably
Reloaded (was a wagon all of D1)
Shui (was a wagon all of D2)
Marimo (too wolfy to be a wolf)
Flower (seems more solving than ATE this game and that’s a good sign)
GB (has spent a huge amount of time and effort solving and trying to move thread forward)
Average (same as GB)
Hayumi (feels too isolated to be a wolf)
Rej (is trying to put in effort despite being busy irl and despite being in a thread state that benefits coasting)
Cal (way too aggressive and abrasive to be wolf, but is also putting in effort to solve)

oh also @ThatAverageGuy if you wanna add to my confident unpairings, Cal and LM are never partners after Cal insulted Naomi like that

 

[Charlie]

His terrible enterance aside, I do kind of agree with the "too scummy to be scum" argument. It's why Mafia just won't be a bunch of inactives.

I mean, look at Naruto game. 80% of mafia team was too scummy to be scum

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

I mean, look at Naruto game. 80% of mafia team was too scummy to be scum

I remember nothing from that game, so maybe you're right lol

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

No they arent

Yeah they are. Have u ever been so busy that you barely have time for mafia, but then you read up 20 pages? That’s hard to do and takes effort, especially with the other parts of irl looming and stressing. That kind of effort in that kind of situation is not something I expect from scum

 

[Charlie]

I'm not against rej Lynch at all. I just don't want to get AM 2.0 situation. I mean inactive town whose flip gets us nowhere