Chapter Discussion King Reuvan was killed because he was Davy clan member

[Jesse Pinkman]

He looks like Blackbeard and looks bit like Xebec’s father . He might be descendant of Davy Jones as well .

Maybe thats why Imu had sight on this kingdom and Candelle who was sent as undercover used her daughter to kill her father after she finds he was Davy clan member .

Of course there was native hunting competition but i have distinct feeling Imu had these event to kill any remaining Davy clan members.

 

[D. Plant]

He might be a Davy.

Candel is not a God's Knight, why would she live in the lower realm? and I think Gunko inherits the blue hair from her. It's a rare trait which Imu will absolutely make her his own special servant like Gunko.

 

[Salah WG]

King Reuven will most probably die because of a Song or Musical Instrument.

 

[Fn Lucci]

I guess I see why people are forcing relevance into the flashback, but this theory is all over YouTube and it's not warranted yet

 

[D. Plant]

Oda might be implying Buggy is a Davy. Gunko being a blue hair and her dad is a similar looking guy to Teach. For sure Davy and blue hair have some connection.

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

Oda is just recycling design

I don't see how you saying Gunko is related to Nami

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Would make sense. Imu likes weaponizing his former foes. He DR’d Rocks and turned Harald into a HK. If Gunko was a Davy, making her his slave would similarly be in line for him.

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

He might be a Davy.

Candel is not a God's Knight, why would she live in the lower realm? and I think Gunko inherits the blue hair from her. It's a rare trait which Imu will absolutely make her his own special servant like Gunko.

I think that she could be. We already know about two cases of Celestial Dragons abandoning Mary Geoise and going to the lower world (Homing and Shanks), and one of them was a HK. Afterwards, for some reason the WG could've killed Candel and her former family (the Manmayers) took Gunko back to MG.

On a side note, some CD families probably have more influence (higher status) than others. DoFlamingo actively tried to get his status back but failed, while Garling could easily reinstate Shanks into the CD ranks (and he even became a HK!), despite his stint in the Roger Pirates.

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Where we saw Xebec father?

 

[D. Plant]

I think that she could be. We already know about two cases of Celestial Dragons abandoning Mary Geoise and going to the lower world (Homing and Shanks), and one of them was a HK. Afterwards, for some reason the WG could've killed Candel and her former family (the Manmayers) took Gunko back to MG.

On a side note, some CD families probably have more influence (higher status) than others. DoFlamingo actively tried to get his status back but failed, while Garling could easily reinstate Shanks into the CD ranks (and he even became a HK!), despite his stint in the Roger Pirates.

Interesting, being former member of God's Knight may actually makes sense, or God's Blade will be more appropriate as it makes them tracking her more difficult.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

I think that she could be. We already know about two cases of Celestial Dragons abandoning Mary Geoise and going to the lower world (Homing and Shanks), and one of them was a HK. Afterwards, for some reason the WG could've killed Candel and her former family (the Manmayers) took Gunko back to MG.

On a side note, some CD families probably have more influence (higher status) than others. DoFlamingo actively tried to get his status back but failed, while Garling could easily reinstate Shanks into the CD ranks (and he even became a HK!), despite his stint in the Roger Pirates.

Doflamingo was the son of a "traitor" and Shanks was kidnapped as a baby their situation was nothing alike

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

Doflamingo was the son of a "traitor" and Shanks was kidnapped as a baby their situation was nothing alike

Shanks wasn't kidnapped, he was lost (Dragon couldn't make off with him). In the end, he ended up with the "worst pirate crew" at the time, it's still an impressive thing that the CDs not only accepted him back but he also became a HK.

Doffy wasn't his father and did something incredible to live again in Mary Geoise (he cut off his own father's head)... even so, they never accepted him (and IMO he had potential to be a great servant, probably even among the top HKs).

We also don't know nothing about Candel's past, not even if she was really a HK or even a CD.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Shanks wasn't kidnapped, he was lost (Dragon couldn't make off with him). In the end, he ended up with the "worst pirate crew" at the time, it's still an impressive thing that the CDs not only accepted him back but he also became a HK.

Doffy wasn't his father and did something incredible to live again in Mary Geoise (he cut off his own father's head)... even so, they never accepted him (and IMO he had potential to be a great servant, probably even among the top HKs).

We also don't know nothing about Candel's past, not even if she was really a HK or even a CD.

Shanks was kidnapped before he was lost

Doflamingo is blamed for the actions of his father

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

Shanks was kidnapped before he was lost

Doflamingo is blamed for the actions of his father

This is pure bs IMO. They did nothing to the Donquixotes still in Mary Geoise and Doffy was still a child when he left, he had no choice much like Shanks. In addition, if they've paid any attention to the Roger Pirates (and they should), they would see that Shanks was fully aligned with Roger, their greatest threat since the Void Century. Doffy on the other hand was a CD in the manner desired by the WG.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

This is pure bs IMO. They did nothing to the Donquixotes still in Mary Geoise and Doffy was still a child when he left, he had no choice much like Shanks. In addition, if they've paid any attention to the Roger Pirates (and they should), they would see that Shanks was fully aligned with Roger, their greatest threat since the Void Century. Doffy on the other hand was a CD in the manner desired by the WG.

The Donquixotes in Mary Geoise aren't from the "line of traitors" (Homing)
Shanks was a 15 when Roger died and done nothing of note

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Shanks case is different than doffy. Shanks was taken as a hostage from WG's perspective. Doffy's family was casted out of Marijoa.

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

Where we saw Xebec father?

The big guy with straw hat who was domi reversed was his dad .
Both his dad and grandmom were captured in God Valley event.

 

[Kung-Fu Dugong]

The Donquixotes in Mary Geoise aren't from the "line of traitors" (Homing)
Shanks was a 15 when Roger died and done nothing of note

He was beating marine officials and fighting the Whitebeard Pirates at ~13 years old. Shanks was considered a prodigy already, even among the Roger Pirates, and was clearly aligned to Roger. It was something of note, especially when the Roger Pirates didn't kill that particular group of marines (therefore, they had the opportunity to report it to the higher-ups).

 

[HerreraIsBack]

The big guy with straw hat who was domi reversed was his dad .
Both his dad and grandmom were captured in God Valley event.

Oh right

 

[Monkey D Theories]

This is pure bs IMO. They did nothing to the Donquixotes still in Mary Geoise and Doffy was still a child when he left, he had no choice much like Shanks. In addition, if they've paid any attention to the Roger Pirates (and they should), they would see that Shanks was fully aligned with Roger, their greatest threat since the Void Century. Doffy on the other hand was a CD in the manner desired by the WG.

The most logical answer is that whereas Garling, commander of the HKs, still claimed Shanks, nobody in mariejois wanted Doffy because of what Homing did.