Chapter Discussion ONE PIECE CHAPTER 1186 : Once More

Rate the chapter:


  • Total voters
    55
Thats the cycle of every arc. People complain about arc A, Arc B starts. People complain that arc B sucks and that arc A actually wasnt as bad as made out. We got to Arc C, people complain about it and that maybe Arc B wasnt that bad after all. Rinse and repeat.
You've just committed the greatest crime of all: Noticing.

Agenda followers will be at your door any day now.
 
So we went from Food fueling Luffy:




to powering him up almost 1200 chapters into the story....?
Nothing changed.
Meat given to Luffy made him ignore the gaping holes he got from Lucci and Especially Crocodile.. He has energy to ignore his fatigue.. doesn't mean he gets to pull 150% of his power or that his haki grew stronger just because he ate..
 
Lets try this.

BB getting punched by fodder Luffy in Impel down. From the front.

Whats the excuse here? He should be stronger then most YC.

Sometimes, things happen for ''cool factor'' and ''narrative''.

This was a callback to the Charlos punch.

Luffy punched a CD and now hes punchig the King of CDs.

Oda thought it was cool so he drew it.

Its like you will see Imu reacting to G5 Luffy are you going to say that its slower then this base Luffy from this chapter?
Same explation works for both Teach and Imu : They didn't expect to get jumped out of the blue and their brain "bugged"
The excuse works better in Imu's case as his focus was on Loki and he only registered Luffy presence just before getting smacked.
It's more of an issue of the villain being careless than an actual powerscaling one imo.
 
Lets try this.

BB getting punched by fodder Luffy in Impel down. From the front.

Whats the excuse here? He should be stronger then most YC.

Sometimes, things happen for ''cool factor'' and ''narrative''.

This was a callback to the Charlos punch.

Luffy punched a CD and now hes punchig the King of CDs.

Oda thought it was cool so he drew it.

Its like you will see Imu reacting to G5 Luffy are you going to say that its slower then this base Luffy from this chapter?
I am, as you know, wanting Teach as final villain. But by Shonen tropes with Oda usually follows, Imu should look good fighting Loki and Luffy 1 vs 2 next chapter.
 

CoC: Color of Clowns

If it Bleeds, it can Die
As much as I whined about it before, I guess Oda having Base Luffy get feats against Kaido and Imu is him telling us that Base Luffy is not far off from Gear 4/5.

This is where I'm at, I guess: Base Luffy = 50% power, Gear 4 = 75% power, Gear 5 = 100%. This is only in terms of speed/power/endurance, Gear 5's reality warping powers are another rabbit hole entirely.

My question is: does Luffy just... always use Gear 2 in serious fights, now? Like how he can use Gear 3 without drawbacks? Or does he only use Gear 2 when using certain moves?

But, yeah. As much as it annoys me to see Zoro and Sanji get portrayed like this compared to Base Luffy, there is historical precedent for it.

Garp. No Fruit, doesn't need it.

Garp would whallop Zoro and Sanji currently, so, I guess the answer really is that CoC Haki breaks the universe and makes EOS fights that boring if someone doesn't have it.

He said it, we didn't listen.

 
Oda gives as little exposition as possible to each of his characters while introducing as many new plot points and characters as he can. Then he leaves those plot points hanging and those characters underdeveloped for hundreds of chapters. It's frustrating because it feels like he keeps expanding the story instead of committing to what he's already introduced. Everything feels static. Everyone feels static. Interactions between characters feel shallow and predictable. The Straw Hats barely interact with each other anymore. The powers and systems have no consistency.
 

CoC: Color of Clowns

If it Bleeds, it can Die
And now Imu confirmed that he wins his battles by taking hostages since 800 years ago..
Tracks, since the only way the Marines could beat Whitebeard was by holding Ace hostage at a public execution, after hunting his mother down for being pregnant, leading to the deaths of who knows how many pregnant women and innocent children



So glad Blackbeard fucked up Marineford for these cronies
 
As much as I whined about it before, I guess Oda having Base Luffy get feats against Kaido and Imu is him telling us that Base Luffy is not far off from Gear 4/5.

This is where I'm at, I guess: Base Luffy = 50% power, Gear 4 = 75% power, Gear 5 = 100%. This is only in terms of speed/power/endurance, Gear 5's reality warping powers are another rabbit hole entirely.

My question is: does Luffy just... always use Gear 2 in serious fights, now? Like how he can use Gear 3 without drawbacks? Or does he only use Gear 2 when using certain moves?

But, yeah. As much as it annoys me to see Zoro and Sanji get portrayed like this compared to Base Luffy, there is historical precedent for it.

Garp. No Fruit, doesn't need it.

Garp would whallop Zoro and Sanji currently, so, I guess the answer really is that CoC Haki breaks the universe and makes EOS fights that boring if someone doesn't have it.

He said it, we didn't listen.

I mean He is a 3 Billion yonkou
Would be weird if he isnt a threat now
 
Top