Salem of Lies TOS II: Salem's New Threat

[Flower]

Question out of everyone you could of whispered sweet nothings to what about Fushi's play so far made you decide that he was the one you'd whisper your role to

Because he has zero reason to defend me like that as scum.

 

[Yoho]

Because he has zero reason to defend me like that as scum.

hmm i see, I see i wouldn't call what he said a defense but its an acceptable reasoning

 

[Lord Melkor]

Oh nvm Fuji is hinting Pirate.

I‘m eepy.

Fuji is not you, why would he hint a role so early? Especially as town.

 

[Lord Melkor]

I like Al so far. Nao posting is probably a good sign, too.

Yes. I have not seem a game where Naomi could maintain such very high rate of posting as scum.

Am looks bold from his entrance. He propably would not act this way if he randed scum twice in a row, he seemed a bit frustrated last game where we were scum together

 

[Lord Melkor]

Fwiw I don’t think Fuji is Mafia with how he‘s playing, so he can stay for a few days.

Not caught up, but you very quickly changed your mind on him.

 

[Lord Melkor]

alwaysmind town lock.

More than in Game of Thrones game, right?

 

[Lord Melkor]

So does lynching vote the same way here as in majority and you’re up for trial?

It is not stated in the rules on the first page @Zemmi

 

[Lord Melkor]

From skimming the first few pages:

Naomi is probably town/not scum. Seems relatively free flowing for her, atypical to her normal scum game.

Fuji was a bit weird earlier and I dunno why he burned through his whispers on what can't have been useful. Inclination so far says possibly not town, but not scum, on that I agree with Flower.

Al seems alright, liked his response to Fuji voting him.

Kro feels like something is missing. A bit reactive... Hard to draw conclusions this early but not too convinced by his entrance.

AM is meh, Melkor is meh.

Flower I thought was a bit too unserious at the start but she did get down to brass tacks early enough, she can be fine for now. Not a town read per se but would go to a town lean. The claiming thing early on felt performative though.

Can't recall anyone else, if in doubt Vote Melkor etc

Vote: Lord Melkor

I struggle with the role technical aspect of these games a lot. I haven't had a chance to sit down and read the guide in the sign ups so I dont really get hints or anything like that, just saying this because I'm going to be somewhat nerfed in a role hunting game like this.

Oh, Rej. How could I forget my boy Rej. Not convinced so far but I did like that he said he would play it as vanilla, just feels like a strange thought to have as scum. Nothing clearing but its in my notes.

Hard to draw conclusions on Kro, whose entrance you did not like but you are voting me based on one post?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Attention duellists, unfortunately her claim is self resolving.

Ah she claimed to you in whisper?

 

[Lord Melkor]

lets get rid of towns greatest weakness.

Last few games i saw her as town she has very good reads accuracy though

 

[Lord Melkor]

Jeez! I just woke up, returned after years, and welcomed by 10 pages of troll warlords.


Ramona!!!

@Fujishiro my boy, those are some weird stuff you're posting. But I don't think this is a blatant scumplay. I'll not tunnel him for his theatrical plays unless we get more information. But then again, 79 posts without actual game solving doesn't lean town.

I am unsure on Fuji yet. Him doing a lot of fluffing early game is well within his scum range.

 

[Lord Melkor]

nah she didnt give me the role i wanted, her own husband.

Wow, you are married?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Not to shade Flower but I have to say I don't really understand why she would say she doesn't want to claim day 1 before dropping a hint that's treated as hard clearing and obvious. Like yeah I know the answer will be "it's flower" but I don't really understand why she would jump from one place to another with nothing in-between. Would appreciate her explaining that when she's back online.

Yes, it seemed a bit performative, Fuji says she is self resolving though.

 

[Flower]

What I whispered to Fuji was pretty vague. Same for the thread.

Anyway.

Nao is Town
Fuji is Town
Muugen is unfortunately also just dumb Town, he never fucking learns when it comes to me and as scum he usually isn’t pushing me like that
Yoho is probably Town
Kro probably isn’t Mafia

That‘s my take away from this.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Attention duellists, oh my bad. But yes she hard hinted at Amnesiac like Ratchet said.

How clearing it is in TOS 2 setup though?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Btw it will be announced in the thread that an amnesiac remembered a role @Hayumi.

Oh, so it is clearing

 

[Flower]

Melkor is ignoring the live thread again.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Ratchet looks better the more i read from him.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Melkor is ignoring the live thread again.

I have actually time to catch up now so i am using the time

 

[Flower]

I‘m at my job interview, c ya later.