Salem of Lies TOS II: Salem's New Threat

[Flower]

I have actually time to catch up now so i am using the time

Then why are you engaging with the Amnesiac topic when I clearly said I‘m not that.

 

[Lord Melkor]

sorry i remember last game, where alwaysmind ignored me as scum..

let see if pattern repeats!!


i think melkor town, he liked my post early game. usually sign he town.

When i am scum i try to pocket you though

 

[Lord Melkor]

Then why are you engaging with the Amnesiac topic when I clearly said I‘m not that.

Oh sorry then, i got confused.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Because he has zero reason to defend me like that as scum.

Why? Scum Fuji would totally buddy you day 1.

 

[Flower]

Why? Scum Fuji would totally buddy you day 1.

Not in that manner usually. He’d probably say stuff like *I think Flower is Town* and wouldn’t go further. While here he straight up explains why my supposed role is self resolving and goes out of his way. The scum team in a game like ToS profits from every distraction they can get as the game is very mech heavy and they’re usually quickly boxed in, so that’s just very counter productive.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Naomi seems to be strong town.

Al seems townie too, his postings seems pure.

AM gives good vibes from his entrance, needs to post more.

I actually liked Gambit's entrance as well.

Muugen can be town with his push on Flower, his tone did not seem self concious at all.

Hayumi seemed to give some vibe of being genuinely frustrated in his posts.

I did not like Ratchet's vote on me, his later posts look a bit better.

Fuji may be town but i do not want to town lock him yet. Flower i need to see more of.

Vote Lynch Kro

 

[Lord Melkor]

Not in that manner usually. He’d probably say stuff like *I think Flower is Town* and wouldn’t go further. While here he straight up explains why my supposed role is self resolving and goes out of his way. The scum team in a game like ToS profits from every distraction they can get as the game is very mech heavy and they’re usually quickly boxed in, so that’s just very counter productive.

Unless scum team can just deal with your role at night, but i see.

How many non town do we expect here? I browsred wiki a bit, there seems to usually be the coven team, one non game ending Indie and one killing indie

 

[Flower]

Unless scum team can just deal with your role at night, but i see.

How many non town do we expect here? I browsred wiki a bit, there seems to usually be the coven team, one non game ending Indie and one killing indie

Usually Town has the majority, so I‘d expect like 12-13 Towns and 7-8 hostiles.

 

[Flower]

Could even be 11 Towns and 9 non Town given Zem made this a test game and might want to try out more roles.

 

[Ratchet]

Hard to draw conclusions on Kro, whose entrance you did not like but you are voting me based on one post?

Does voting you mean I've drawn a conclusion?

 

[Ratchet]

What I whispered to Fuji was pretty vague. Same for the thread.

Anyway.

Nao is Town
Fuji is Town
Muugen is unfortunately also just dumb Town, he never fucking learns when it comes to me and as scum he usually isn’t pushing me like that
Yoho is probably Town
Kro probably isn’t Mafia

That‘s my take away from this.

Elaborate on Yoho and Kro please.

 

[Ratchet]

Melkor looks alright, maybe the Naomi tell is real
Unvote

 

[Flower]

Elaborate on Yoho and Kro please.

I agree with Fuji that Yoho probably derped. And him poking me like he has also seems good.

For Kro it’s pure gut. He feels like he doesn’t have a team with the way he told people to put him out of this game. If I had to guess he doesn’t have a Serial Killer or Arso role either. Idk it’s hard to explain a gut feeling.

 

[Czuek]

Not in that manner usually. He’d probably say stuff like *I think Flower is Town* and wouldn’t go further. While here he straight up explains why my supposed role is self resolving and goes out of his way. The scum team in a game like ToS profits from every distraction they can get as the game is very mech heavy and they’re usually quickly boxed in, so that’s just very counter productive.

I think Flower is town

 

[Ratchet]

He feels like he doesn’t have a team with the way he told people to put him out of this game

This feels like a stretch, given its his usual affair. Though I can see the logic.

 

[Ratchet]

I think Flower is town

What do we think of this guy, can't say I'm enthused so far.

 

[Flower]

This feels like a stretch, given its his usual affair. Though I can see the logic.

*shrug* it’s the best explanation I have for a gut feeling.

 

[Flower]

I think Flower is town

Bro‘s meme‘ing on me 😭

 

[Flower]

To end this 1v1, I wasn't town-leaning Ratchet simply because he made reads. He's Ratchet, he'll produce reads regardless of alignment. A small town cred doesn't mean strong town read.

To start, he was the first to actually move the thread forward. Instead of just throwing out a list of reads, he broke down his thoughts on different players individually and kept his reads separated rather than collapsing everything into a single scum pool. That felt like someone actively sorting the game state rather than forcing a narrative.

I kinda like this post tbh. I thought Gambit was a little sus at first, but the way he’s Town leaning Ratchet here feels good to me because of the way he’s doing it (as in, he judges his thought process and not the conclusion).

 

[Flower]

Yeah this site is cooked.