General & Others Was Oden a Roger Pirate

[Albino 👑]

I don’t need to.

Okay so you can’t

Fair as long as you ignore it you don’t have to talk about it

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Okay so you can’t

Fair as long as you ignore it you don’t have to talk about it

If odens not a Roger Pirate why’s he called one? He’s never called the fake term “interim Roger Pirate” or anything like that?

 

[Rurushu]

Yes, Dogshitman is weaker than Rayleigh and Gaban.

Whatever cope you use is irrelevant.

You can ask it directly next time.

 

[Albino 👑]

If odens not a Roger Pirate why’s he called one? He’s never called the fake term “interim Roger Pirate” or anything like that?

He was with the Roger Pirates for 1 year and the time he was with them is his least focused

Again answer why didn’t Oda himself add Oden when drawing all the Roger Pirates? Why didn’t he add him to the most important Roger?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

He was with the Roger Pirates for 1 year and the time he was with them is his least focused

Again answer why didn’t Oda himself add Oden when drawing all the Roger Pirates? Why didn’t he add him to the most important Roger?

He didn’t put all the Roger pirates in those drafts. And oden was canonically a Roger Pirate for their final journey and oden, his retainers, the Roger pirates, Sengoku all say that.

You’re just resting to cope about this because odens weaker than ray and Gaban.

 

[Albino 👑]

He didn’t put all the Roger pirates in those drafts. And oden was canonically a Roger Pirate for their final journey and oden, his retainers, the Roger pirates, Sengoku all say that.

You’re just resting to cope about this because odens weaker than ray and Gaban.

Okay who was not included please tell me

Again idk how many times I have to say yes Oden was with them for his final year as a pirate. That doesn’t change the fact he’s more remembered as a whitebeard pirate and 2 ODA DID NOT DRAW HIM WHEN DRAWING ALL THE ROGER PIRATES. The giants and strawhats didn’t even think of him

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Okay who was not included please tell me

Again idk how many times I have to say yes Oden was with them for his final year as a pirate. That doesn’t change the fact he’s more remembered as a whitebeard pirate and 2 ODA DID NOT DRAW HIM WHEN DRAWING ALL THE ROGER PIRATES. The giants and strawhats didn’t even think of him

He’s remembered as a Roger Pirate by those who were active during the Roger pirates era.

Why would they think of oden? They just know oden isn’t as strong as Ray and Gaban.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

He calls Roger his captain and multiple characters say he's a member, therefore he is a member. This discussion shouldn't be a thing, it should end at this message alone. If they call Oden a member then he is one. No ifs, ands or buts.

 

[Albino 👑]

He’s remembered as a Roger Pirate by those who were active during the Roger pirates era.

Why would they think of oden? They just know oden isn’t as strong as Ray and Gaban.

Funny how even when you do try to “answer” a question you keep having to move your own goalposts
Besides Oden which Roger Pirates weren’t included. Was oden not active when they were active?

Why would Usopp know how to power scale Oden and the Roger Pirates. The crew knew he was strong that’s it

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Funny how even when you do try to “answer” a question you keep having to move your own goalposts
Besides Oden which Roger Pirates weren’t included. Was oden not active when they were active?

Why would Usopp know how to power scale Oden and the Roger Pirates. The crew knew he was strong that’s it

Usopp may not but the giants who were active during Roger’s era would.

 

[Albino 👑]

Usopp may not but the giants who were active during Roger’s era would.

Hey

Funny how even when you do try to “answer” a question you keep having to move your own goalposts
Besides Oden which Roger Pirates weren’t included. Was oden not active when they were active?

So was Sakazuki
Usopp not bringing up Oden at all doesn’t help your point

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Hey

So was Sakazuki
Usopp not bringing up Oden at all doesn’t help your point

Sakazuki was a new marine in Roger’s era. That’s why Sengoku the one who was active talked about it.

 

[Albino 👑]

Sakazuki was a new marine in Roger’s era. That’s why Sengoku the one who was active talked about it.

Hey x2

Funny how even when you do try to “answer” a question you keep having to move your own goalposts
Besides Oden which Roger Pirates weren’t included. Was oden not active when they were active?

Sakazuki knowing of his time as the second division commander of the Whitebeard Pirates but not with Roger also doesn’t help you

Usopp not bringing up Oden at all doesn’t help your point

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Hey x2

Sakazuki knowing of his time as the second division commander of the Whitebeard Pirates but not with Roger also doesn’t help you

The Whitebeard pirates were active during his career as an admiral. No shit he’d care about the previous members.

Whitebeard already tells us only those active during Roger’s era talks about it. That’s why Roger’s literal first mate can run a ship costing business and no one give a shit.


All this cope just cause odens weaker than ray and Gaban

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

The Whitebeard pirates were active during his career as an admiral. No shit he’d care about the previous members.

Whitebeard already tells us only those active during Roger’s era talks about it. That’s why Roger’s literal first mate can run a ship costing business and no one give a shit.


All this cope just cause odens weaker than ray and Gaban

Why do they even care that he's weaker than them?

 

[Owl Ki]

"What if I prioritised the SBS, over the actual story?"

 

[Albino 👑]

The Whitebeard pirates were active during his career as an admiral. No shit he’d care about the previous members.

Whitebeard already tells us only those active during Roger’s era talks about it. That’s why Roger’s literal first mate can run a ship costing business and no one give a shit.


All this cope just cause odens weaker than ray and Gaban

Hey x3

Funny how even when you do try to “answer” a question you keep having to move your own goalposts
Besides Oden which Roger Pirates weren’t included. Was oden not active when they were active?

You do realize that highlighting how big a deal both the Whitebeard and Roger Pirates does the opposite of helping you right?

If Sakazuki knew about Oden and his time with Whitebeard why wouldn’t he know of Odens time with Roger? There being a person that traveled with both would be an even bigger deal

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Hey x3


You do realize that highlighting how big a deal both the Whitebeard and Roger Pirates does the opposite of helping you right?

If Sakazuki knew about Oden and his time with Whitebeard why wouldn’t he know of Odens time with Roger? There being a person that traveled with both would be an even bigger deal

It’s not that he doesn’t know it’s that it’s irrelevant. Sakazuki knows he was a Roger Pirate.

 

[Owl Ki]

It’s not that he doesn’t know it’s that it’s irrelevant. Sakazuki knows he was a Roger Pirate.

I had this very discussion with Albino last year. He pretends he can't read. He claims Akainu legitimately doesn't know even though Akainu immediately says Oden when Sengoku talks about a samurai beloved by Roger. You can't possibly get through to him when he unironically spams panels that prove himself wrong. Lol.

So you concede that your entire point about Oden only being a pirate for 5 years is completely moot then?

Good to know that we both agree that this argument is dumb.

Blackbeard deliberately hid his strength, even going so far as to refuse a promotion to Division Commander. Oden flat out was a Division Commander. This example makes zero sense.

Akainu literally knows Oden was a Roger Pirate.

Sengoku: "Wano Pirate beloved by Whitebeard, Roger and Shanks."

Akainu: "Oden"

You think Akainu just randomly instantly picked the only Wano Pirate that sailed with both Whitebeard and Roger?

If Akainu didn't know, he either would have said so or guessed wrong. Instead, he got it immediately cause he freaking knows. Lol.

He feckin knows in that panel. How can you be this obtuse?

Sengoku: "Wano pirate beloved by Whitebeard, Roger and Shanks."

Does Akainu:
I) Say he doesn't know who that could be?
II) Makes an incorrect guess on who the pirate from Wano could be such as Izo, Inurashi or Nekomamushi?
III) Cop on immediately and go "Oden"?

It is the third one Albino. He flat out knows. Your entire argument rests on spamming a panel that immediately proves you wrong. You cannot possibly be this stupid.

 

[Albino 👑]

It’s not that he doesn’t know it’s that it’s irrelevant. Sakazuki knows he was a Roger Pirate.

Hey x4

Funny how even when you do try to “answer” a question you keep having to move your own goalposts
Besides Oden which Roger Pirates weren’t included. Was oden not active when they were active?

1. When Sakazuki thinks of Oden he thinks of him as a Whitebeard pirate
2. When thinking of strong Roger Pirates Usopp doesn’t think of Oden at all despite knowing he’s strong
3. When drawing ALL the Roger Pirates he doesn’t include Oden post his introduction
4. When naming the roles for all the important members of the Roger Pirates Oden isn’t included
5. Crocus while also being a temporary member was included in both despite not being more important than Oden
6. Random bum Roger Pirates were highlighted as the most important members of the crew but oden wasn’t