Character Discussion Mihawk is criminally underrated

Is Mihawk a Top Tier?


  • Total voters
    115
We know only what oda told us.

And that is, in the OP world its common knowledge in the swordmen circles that Mihawk *IS* the strongest swordmaster currently alive, soo anyone that can be considered a swordsman either didnt duel Mihawk, or didnt manage to win against him, wich is the case regarding Shanks, a yonko. The rest is pure headcannon, because there is no information what-so-ever about anything else.
 
Last edited:

Doggo

Talent is something you make bloom.
A top tier that couldnt one shot marineford luffy, got blocked by jozu, crocodile, vista.
I dont think he could even solo an Admiral. Maybe, MAYBE a 80-20 scenario.
He is powerful, very powerful, he constantly have duels with shanks, but as far as we know, shanks is not as powerful as the other yonkos alone. The special thing is that he got The most balanced crew. So probably multiple people above YC1 tier. At least him and Beckmann, but, so far, that's it. What I dont like about databooks, is because i consider that "if it wasn't in The original source, anything can change".
Mihawk is cool AF, but severely overrated. So far, he is just another shichibukai. It can change, Oda can show better feats for him later. I believe he will join shanks to survive the shichibukai hunt, and will have more screen time with the following events, since Oda said "shanks will make his move"
 
We don't even know how Roger defined himself. Or how Shanks defines himself. What we know that they are introduced as pirates first. What will they say? I am a swordsman or a pirate? Daz literally said he doesn't care about being a swordsman despite using a power that turns him into a human sword. If Daz can say I am an assassin not a swordsman then they can always say we are not swordsman but only pirates.
Daz Bones is swordsman-like but isn't a proper swordsman because he doesn't use a sword, rather, his body turns into blades. All swords are blades but not all blades are swords. Irregardless if they have other fighting abilities, Shanks, Rayleigh, Fujitora, and Roger are swordsmen.
 
Daz: ''By the way, you shouldn't mistakenly think me as a swordsman. I've got plenty of other weapons to cut your body to shreds''
- Chapter 195


I will leave the quote. If they uses more than regular sword cutting techniques then they can always say ''we are not swordsman''. Plain and simple.
 
The question that zoro fans can't answer: what if Shanks isn't a swordsman and if Shanks says the same thing with Daz? :steef:
Daz: ''By the way, you shouldn't mistakenly think me as a swordsman. I've got plenty of other weapons to cut your body to shreds''
- Chapter 195
 

Finalbeta

Hero of Albion
The question that zoro fans can't answer: what if Shanks isn't a swordsman and if Shanks says the same thing with Daz? :steef:
Daz: ''By the way, you shouldn't mistakenly think me as a swordsman. I've got plenty of other weapons to cut your body to shreds''
- Chapter 195
Stop making fanfictions Erkan. It's a hassle.

You should be considering to start putting effort into comprehending what we are telling to you instead of being so redundant and sterile.
 
Top