The situation went like this. I royally fucked up but uh.
I asked Robin if they were a convert role, they answered no.
Kvothe didn't mention that they were immune to poison
So I asked Robin if they could convert they said no. The purpose is if they lied to me they would be role crushed for a cycle, I really focused too much on the convert thing. So I'm not sure where I stand with Robin atm. They seem like they want to be helpful.
I lean townish for Kvothe now since I know townies might have a few immunities of their own.