General & Others Semi famous actor wants to be One Piece live action
- Thread starter Adeer Ruckus
- Start date
That's exactly the same.
The reason why we do not race swap black actors is because :
- We don't want to strip them from an identity that has an importance in the story
- Black people are still underepresented in medias and there are no reason to put less of them
Its the same for straight/Bi/homosexual AND Non binary people (also, "non binary" is not a sexual preference)
In One Piece, the non binarity of Bon Clay is FOUNDAMENTAL to the character's story. So if you make a Cis actor play a non binary character you create the same offense to non binary people that you would create to black people if you were giving the role of a black man to a white man. It would be literally a spit in the face to those people AND the story itself.
Straight men don't need more representation, Gay men do. Bi people do. Black people do. Asian people do. Native people do. Trans do and non binary people in general DO.
So let them have the floor when the story literally shows that its THEIR place to play the role.
The reason why we do not race swap black actors is because :
- We don't want to strip them from an identity that has an importance in the story
- Black people are still underepresented in medias and there are no reason to put less of them
Its the same for straight/Bi/homosexual AND Non binary people (also, "non binary" is not a sexual preference)
In One Piece, the non binarity of Bon Clay is FOUNDAMENTAL to the character's story. So if you make a Cis actor play a non binary character you create the same offense to non binary people that you would create to black people if you were giving the role of a black man to a white man. It would be literally a spit in the face to those people AND the story itself.
Straight men don't need more representation, Gay men do. Bi people do. Black people do. Asian people do. Native people do. Trans do and non binary people in general DO.
So let them have the floor when the story literally shows that its THEIR place to play the role.
I have no issues with lgbqt playing thier respective roles in filim, but it's flat out wrong to say they HAVE to.
Nick and Murray did an amazing job portaying a gay couple in the Last of Us, and only one of them is actually gay. Are you saying that wasn't a great representation because one was straight?
Nick and Murray did an amazing job portaying a gay couple in the Last of Us, and only one of them is actually gay. Are you saying that wasn't a great representation because one was straight?
its not them who have to do it, its producers who needs to make everything possible for them to have those roles. There are a lot of talented Queer actor and actresses so there is absolutely no need to search for straight or cis people.
It was, because they actually cared to include a gay character in it. Also, there is this :
https://www.wearequeeraf.com/the-is...co-star-murray-bartlett-in-the-shadows-again/
--
Actor should be able to play anything. But we MUST redistribute the inequality of treatment against minorities in medias by representing them correctly. And in the case where the non binary identity is invisibilized (even more so than homosexuality) we must be careful in double and give the role to actors of the queer community. I've talked about good choices if you want in the Live action thread:
It was, because they actually cared to include a gay character in it. Also, there is this :
https://www.wearequeeraf.com/the-is...co-star-murray-bartlett-in-the-shadows-again/
--
Actor should be able to play anything. But we MUST redistribute the inequality of treatment against minorities in medias by representing them correctly. And in the case where the non binary identity is invisibilized (even more so than homosexuality) we must be careful in double and give the role to actors of the queer community. I've talked about good choices if you want in the Live action thread:
Fun fact: I never talk about Furries, I'm not one and I don't like that (not even Carrot). I usually never talk about homosexuals but rather trans people and I almost never talk about sex. You got all three wrong lol
Its not the first time that you are making weird fantasy about me which seems to be an obsession you have for either me, carrot or sexual stuff. That is really creepy, please stop. I won't ask it anymore. Next time its a report.
I did a thread asking 3 questions about One Piece ONLY for WOMEN. And the result is that the majority of Women can't speak because of guys like you who rot and spam toxicity in threads. You are being a creep, stop being a creep. The thread is still active for those who want to answer the questions.
Its not the first time that you are making weird fantasy about me which seems to be an obsession you have for either me, carrot or sexual stuff. That is really creepy, please stop. I won't ask it anymore. Next time its a report.
I did a thread asking 3 questions about One Piece ONLY for WOMEN. And the result is that the majority of Women can't speak because of guys like you who rot and spam toxicity in threads. You are being a creep, stop being a creep. The thread is still active for those who want to answer the questions.
Last edited:
1. Question, do you know what doxxing mean ? (Check anyway)
2. I asked WOMEN questions. If you are confusing girls or little girls with WOMEN, I think I might have to ask you a few more questions...
Again, stop being a creep, last warning.
Which is a pejorative term that was reappropriated by non binary people and Queers overall. And since Bon Chan is neither a man or a woman, they are non binary (meaning not 2, meaning not one of the gender, meaning not woman and not man, meaning non static on the gender scale, meaning NON Binary - got it ?)
You want black people to be played by white people ?
2. I asked WOMEN questions. If you are confusing girls or little girls with WOMEN, I think I might have to ask you a few more questions...
Again, stop being a creep, last warning.
Which is a pejorative term that was reappropriated by non binary people and Queers overall. And since Bon Chan is neither a man or a woman, they are non binary (meaning not 2, meaning not one of the gender, meaning not woman and not man, meaning non static on the gender scale, meaning NON Binary - got it ?)
You want black people to be played by white people ?
