Who will be the next SH?


  • Total voters
    95
Being Harjudin's vice captain seems beneath him since he's already invited to join the main crew.
The invite was situational, if he was on the crew Hajrudin would've no choice but to free him

If he is already freed Luffy has no reason to invite him
Those people will keep denying it since they don't want Loki on the crew. Their head canons and new excuse one after the other. While the main character asked Loki to join in front of his crew like zoro and sanji.
Since when did Luffy give a fake invite.. oh wait he never!! :Rofl: He even says right after Loki denied him. I can't wait to see you fight with me... Loki already part of luffy crew.


Luffy lied to protect Loki
Luffy demand Loki be saved and healed, when the others refused
Luffy trying to feed Loki, like he already consider Loki his friend.
Luffy invite to Loki, was genuine.

Luffy is never a liar.
Never said I didn't want him to join, personally I don't but realistically there isn't enough to say either way

Back in water 7 I don't want Franky but as time went on it became more and more obvious that he was the clear choice for Shipwright

Since we aren't hunting for specific crew roles Loki still doesn't have much backing him

The words "join my crew" doesn't guarantee membership, joking, serious or situation
 
The invite was situational, if he was on the crew Hajrudin would've no choice but to free him

If he is already freed Luffy has no reason to invite him
"Hey Loki, Join my crew! I think it'd be fun with you! If anyone has a problem I'll whoop em!"

"I can't wait to see him fight"

Yeah, really sounds like Luffy has no legitimate interest in Loki, it's just situational.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Loki seems far better choice for nakama than the other options we had - Yamao, Vivi, momo,.bonney and carrot.


But Loki will distrub power dynamics within SHs so I feel oda will most likely end him making him rule Elbaph
 
Sounds like headcannon to me, wheres your source.
So you have no source? You just made up Shonen Jump pulling the plug on Yamato joining. Just say that. It's absurd for you to say my reasoning and opinion is headcanon while providing no source yourself.

My source on Yamato not joining is the manga on how other Strawhats joined before. List of reasoning why Yamato is not going to join compared to other Strawhats.

Yamato parallels and connections to Momo show Yamato was likely planned/created after Momo if not at the same time.

Here is some foreshadowing from @Topi Jerami
:milaugh::gokulaugh::nikalaugh::kailaugh::luffylaugh:
 
I honestly could see Loki joining the New Giant Warrior Pirates as the VC

We got emphasis on each member and their position with no Vice Captain
And with the misunderstanding between Hajrudin and Loki I could see them reconciling and Loki joining to....

Excuse me for this but

Make Elbaf great again

Loki will join New Giant Warrior Pirates as co-captain. Harald wanted the brothers to stand shoulder to shoulder


Elbaf had at least two generations of co-captains (Dorry&Brogy and Jarul&Jorul):kata:
 
The fact that Loki is being seriously considered as a candidate and people are completely disregarding his overwhelming strength is a good testament on how desperate people are getting for new nakama.

Loki was so much of a problem that Shanks needed to deal with him. Like holy copium :suresure:
yeah, like it or not power hierarchy matters for crew members. Oda wants to keep the M3 dynamic till EOS.

Baby Loki has similar feats to 10 year old Linlin... I want people to keep that in mind. Loki as a 1 day old baby is as strong as a fucking Yonko when she was a child LMAO.

People need to be more realistic with their expectations. You can't have every "new arc side character" join the crew. Strength, role, dynamics all have to come into play

Right now Bonney remains the strongest candidate because she checks all these boxes plus she's still around, and even then she's not a guarantee
 
Oh shit, you’re back. How’s life been going?
Going great! Got a baby on the way which is exciting, and just a year left in my MRI tech program. How about you?

Also, not going to bother responding to 20 individual posts about peoples headcannon of how strong Loki is disqualifying him. Call me when he actually does something. For now, he could be below Kid. Lower bounty and got beat by the same guy.
 
Top