Powers & Abilities What is Roger´s greatest individual fighting feat ?

Sometimes. Not generally.

Sometimes it's not new at all.

Rayleigh is a famous, historical figure. We didn't know the most of the Strawhats knew about him until it was relevant.



This isn't in contention.


.
My argument is pretty simple, the world as a whole does not know how strong Harald and Loki are, they don't know the facts entirely. This is different from Rayleigh being on the most famous crew and dominating newspapers, meanwhile Harald was cucking himself to the WG and being a waterboy for weaker characters like Sommers and the like, which is the main thing people likely noticed about him,not necessarily his power. Loki beating him did not make global headlines likely, and his piracy career never lasted long enough to be the biggest name on the seas. I think there power is a different story though, imo it seems like Harald was truly on par with the likes of Rocks,who was the strongest pirate at the time of GV.

By his own admission, Gaban gets around. He likely understood what the Devil Fruit was.

Do you sincerely think Harald showed a level of power - immortality aside - he hadn't seen from Roger and Whitebeard?
Gaban seems uninformed on the fruit tbh.

he asks Ja rul if he knew about it, and the fact that he mentions Harald leaving the castle "in that state" seems to imply his worry was about the man who he faced, not a hypothetical where he gets the fruit or something.

Now if Harald showed something above Roger and Primebeard... well it depends on how close you think they were to Gaban, and how important the HK boost is. Imo, as some people have pointed out, it doesn't necessarily make sense for the boost for the Gods Knights to be much worse then DR, and it wasn't emphasized

I would say Oda bringing in a legitimate top tier in Gaban, having him worry for the state of the entire world(beyond even his own fate or his friends, but beyond even Elbaf) implies HK Harald was stronger then any character Gaban had seen in action previously(iirc, Gaban personally never really saw Imu or DR Rocks, so that seems to add up). I mean, it's portrayed as an already very powerful character getting a boost from the final villain through his evil magic powers, I don't really think Roger or WB have any business stopping him in a 1v1. Did you not see how shocked Imu was at what Loki achieved? As far as we saw in the flashback, Imu hasn't reacted like that to any pirate on GV.

Loki led a crew of giants. He had 8 years of piracy and a bounty of 2.6 billion.

I don't know what you insist in pretending this can be achieved without EVERYONE being in the know.


.
It's pretty simple, the OP world is a big place, and he did not go out of his way to clash with the likes of Kaido or Whitebeard. Loki was interested in revenge against Imu for trying to destroy Elbaf, so he likely didn't go out of his way to do many side quests. Though we can't know for sure until we see his time as a pirate, but let's not forget that we see Rocks at the start of his career was capable of killing an admiral. What was he doing before that, and did anyone know how strong he was? Probably not, the OP world is all about word of mouth.

As for Big Mom, yeah she didn't literally say that Loki would in particular, allow her to kill the emperor's, she said the Giants of Elbaf. But imo, it's clear that Loki was the most important part of the plan, let's not forget that he himself is allegedly too much for all of the giants of Elbaf to control anyway.
Oda does not care about powerscaling. He never has.

Characters are as strong as the plot requires them to be. That's the only thing that matters. Emperors ruled the New World because that's the story he wanted to tell. It involved them being the strongest pirates in the world.
.
No dispute on this part, PL is linked to plot.

Mihawk is explicitly identified as one of the rare few pirates on their level and linked to Shanks. Harald is another. Loki is no different, but he is clearly linked to Luffy.

All of them are likely stronger than past her prime Big Mom and sickly old Whitebeard, but that's about it.
He's linked to Luffy for sure but imo it's also notable that he's linked to:
Rocks D Xebec, as someone who became the version of Harald that Rocks wanted to partner up with, becoming an anti government pirate and eating the legendary Elbaf fruit that Rocks saw as one of the 2 devil fruits needed to beat Imu
Imu: Loki is likely one of the only characters who can harm them, and Loki got in the way of Imu's plan to take over Elbaf, and Imu pointed out, it was the actions of Loki, that proved his government is incompatible with the giants of Elbaf, fundamentally. Pretty big setup imo.
 
@soupongo streamline that shit, bruh. I'm not keep indulging you in these long ass back and forth exchanges. :kobeha:
Not all of us are burning with the passion of youth and talking about cartoon character power levels huh?

:CoolPeace:
It's okay, I got you:
1. Imu was not shook at any point by the GV pirates, which is clearly an intentional choice by Oda. Not Rocks, Roger, Garp, Wb etc. He felt completely in control and unphazed. Loki's actions were genuinely able to shock him, and left him affected more then anything aside from Soyboys haki(his rival). Seems pretty intentional on Oda's part to show Loki's strength had surpassed the GV pirates(individually, not as a group obviously)
2. Harald in base seems to be the number 2 by the GV era, just under Xebec. Regardless if you feel he falls behind in the later years of that generation, he gets a major magic bs powerup from the final villain, leaving Gaban worried and hopeless, not for himself, but for the world at large.
3. Loki likely kept a relatively low profile in his 8 years on Sea, since he wanted to get revenge on the government and was probably planning something like that, instead of fighting the emperors. Think Shiki after he got out of jail or whatever.
4. Big Mom didn't directly say Loki alone is the main reason she could finally become PK, but Loki is portrayed as a threat that all of Elbaf can't really contain anyway, he's clearly the giant that's getting focus here.
5. Loki is ultimately tied to Imu more then anyone except Luffy and Teach, he fucked up his goal to take Elbaf, and Imu believed history deemd them to be enemies.
 
I mean yonkos don't have regen like harald so it does checks out. Oda made woki too strong. Oda mirrored both harald and xebec throughout as equals where DR xebec was dominating roger and garp in 2v1 and 16 year old loki (in human terms) dominated HK amped harald. This was loki who has just eaten the DF and harald outlived xebec by 25 years so he should be stronger than xebec by some amount.
WSC despite Loki roaming the seas, no awakening. You can stan Loki I think he's pretty strong too easily stronger than Admirals but Kaido downplay not gonna age well. Don't be on that side buy these Kaido stocks while they beaten down before he comes back and gets massive powercreep
 
WSC despite Loki roaming the seas, no awakening. You can stan Loki I think he's pretty strong too easily stronger than Admirals but Kaido downplay not gonna age well. Don't be on that side buy these Kaido stocks while they beaten down before he comes back and gets massive powercreep
Kaido is a fodder to loki no offense. Empty hype means nothing at the end. Loki dominated a character who is 2x as strong as Kaido bare minimum.
 
Sometimes I feel bad for Roger. The guy to appear in the first panel of this long series got treated like any other average top tier and has barely any unique plot significance

Just a run of the mill top tier who found a treasure his greatest rival wasn't even looking for (and got helped by his greatest rival)

And now it looks more and more likely that all the treasure told him was that he's a bum and not that guy

Even his supposedly failed version Shanks looks 10x more impressive than this guy

Oda really hoed him. Pre-TS GOAT to the biggest fraud Post-TS barring certain Yoncucks
 
Top