Is this not shitty writing???
I never get people who act like you just can't criticize Oda whatsoever. There's nothing special to this- The man just got old and lost his touch completely. It happens, get over it.
@Doggo is saying that you need to form your opinion after seeing raws and reading the chapter. Pew often to makes mistakes in his summaries or generalizes and we go like 2-3 days thinking its something Oda is doing direclty.
Like for example (im guessing) it is possible DR and being knocked out of it depends on the strength of the person being controlled.
For someone like Rocks, he becomes so strong that Garp and Roger needed to work together undo DR and kill Rocks (temporarily) but that leaves them all in powerless state in the end.
For Dorry and Broggy, they are clearly weaker than Rocks, and are of equal footing. We know they basically can kill each other equally, so when it happens it makes sense.
Now as to how they recover and continue fighting idk, but im going to wait for the chapter before I judge it personally