I honestly can't take people who think Iran is winning the war seriously

At least Russia loving Tankies had Some Points before Putin got trolled by Wagner, these guys are just pathetic Leftist College Students and anti Masonic conspiracy theorist christcucks teaming up together to vent out about their abusive Alcohol Dads using Trump and Bibi as a scapegoat

Just go to therapy
This war has a good chance of ending with America being kicked out of the middle east since the initial plan failed though.
Trump has two options now that regime change is not longer on the table :
-Making an actual deal with Iran, which would be conceding defeat.
-Full scale mobilization, a force of at least one million to invade and occupy Iran (a mountainous country 3 times the size of texas with a population of 90 million) with uge amount of casualties among american soldiers and trillion spent. But I'm not sure americans would be willing to accept this.

People are on mistaken on Iran, it's not a mere tinpot dictatorship where everything can be fixed through assassination or air campaign. Neither America nor Israel can win a pain tolerance contest with Shia, twelver Shia of all people. Self-flagellation, penance and martyr sainthood are things they embrace. You add an extremely strong nationalism component to it and you will even get liberal iranians from Tehran that were part of the protest figthing for the motherland if invaded.
Old planes and tanks can be destroyed that it wouldn't change much to what would happen on the ground, Iran is a master of low cost warfare and mass produce drones that massively changed the meta of the modern warfare. (One should take a look at the Ukrainian war).
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
That's sort of the problem though. If Trump doesn't actually want regime change, then what's the endgame? You can't dismantle the Islamic Republic by simply removing a leader. Iran doesn't have democratic institutions like Venezuela did. There's no way to change the regime from the air. You need a ground element. And if troop mobilization isn't at that level like you said, then what's actually being accomplished here?

If this phase lasts longer than a few weeks, the strategy has failed. If the Islamic Republic still exists after all of this, it didn't work. So the benefits are almost nothing unless something fundamentally changes on the ground.
Regime change was never USA goal.

People and media assumed USA is trying to overthrow regime to save Iranian people but they were being naive.

US sees Iran's nuclear programme as a massive threat.

I mean Iran is a country which frequently chanted "Death to America" in speeches and in rallies and they are doing so from past 40 years.

A nuclear Iran would be a nightmare for USA and with Trump in power, his goal has been clear - a nuclear deal which restricts Iran's capabilities.

And, it's not just US which fears it - Nato, Middle East and West Asian nations fear this as well.


The war was not about regime change but to pressure Iran to get the deal as US wants.

However, US made two strategic miscalculations.

1) Didn't anticipate impact of Shahed drones to this extent and Iran to unite with firm resolve after Khamenei's death.

2) Didn't expect Iran to leverage Hormuz and thus US didn't try to take over the route - this is evident from how lack of planning and resources in the first week of the war


Now, goal isn't just to get the deal.

It's also to cripple Iran's conventional military capabilities and the damages you are seeing in Iran can push Iran decades back if continues.

And, US is achieving this goal.

I mean if you look at past one week events - then Iran is being defensive and desperate to end the war by leveraging Hormuz and attack on Gulf oil infrastructure to pressure World and US to ceasefire without losing it's own face.

Iran has done nothing much to US in return. It's naive to think Iran even has upper hand here.

US is war economy. It fuckn thrives in such situations.

And, people are overlooking one key fact here - USA hasn't even got serious enough. Hasn't even started flexing itself.


Another 2 months
Doubt so

Can Iran sustain for 2 months with food shortages and no money flowing? Doubt so


World won't drag it either as 2 months of disruption of Hormuz might push global economy into recession which most likely even US doesn't want to see.
 
Neither America nor Israel can win a pain tolerance contest with Shia, twelver Shia of all people. Self-flagellation, penance and martyr sainthood are things they embrace. You add an extremely strong nationalism component to it and you will even get liberal iranians from Tehran that were part of the protest figthing for the motherland if invaded.
Trust me I know what you mean with this, hence why I said America shouldn't have targeted Ali Khameni

But don't use the Spider Web Theory of Hassan Nasrallah, you know that it ended up being a self own once his own Community became more and more urbanised and less willing to die for Kharastein
 
Iran's conventional military has never been much of a threat, missiles and drones are. And they are mostly produced underground, which is why you need either regime change or boots on the ground to actually put an end to that.

Trust me I know what you mean with this, hence why I said America shouldn't have targeted Ali Khameni

But don't use the Spider Web Theory of Hassan Nasrallah, you know that it ended up being a self own once his own Community became more and more urbanised and less willing to die for Kharastein
Ay sure, but Lebanon is its own thing tbh
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Iran's conventional military has never been much of a threat, missiles and drones are. And they are mostly produced underground, which is why you need either regime change or boots on the ground to actually put an end to that.


Ay sure, but Lebanon is its own thing tbh
I think you are talking about "missile cities"

Obviously, air strikes aren't enough but US doesn't want troops on ground to destroy these cities completely or do regime change.

Too costly.

By destroying launches, production units, storage units and increasing economic costs due to war and sanctions, US can cripple Iran.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
2500 US Marines would be in the region in next one week or so.


Total build up of US troops - around 5k


It's too low in number to have any sort of ground invasion.

Infact, these troops seem more like rapid response forces
 
Top