General & Others Did roof piece help or hurt Zoro and expectations of him

1. The Law teleportation is pure headcanon.
2. Zero ACoC usage. Another headcanon with no basis only assumptions and copium, ACoC usage right after is clearly shown visibly different from no ACoC usage. But we are happy either way because if Zoro unlocked and used ACoC before the MC who had to get hit multiple times by ACoC attacks then this just shows Zoro has more talent and affinity with haki.
3. Mostly nobody cares, you can make argument for both sides because we do have situations from this manga where physical condition and fighting capability are shown to be related. But then we also have people who say named attacks are weaker than unnamed attacks (I dont say it is a blanket rule). So the condition and context always matters.

RT Zoro was clearly above everyone else on the alliance side at that time. He took the most damage, dealt the most damage, played his part in BFR of BM and saved Luffys ass multiple times.
You can call it fan service or extreme outlier peak performance mode or whatever you want to help you sleep at night.
I am not here to debate which is right or wrong. Just that depending on how you comprehend the 3 things I mentioned, it can create a big gap in power level.
 
It hurt expectations. Especially the Blocking Hakai bit. Oda made a bit of an oopsie even drawing that, even if it was only for a second and he broke his bones in the process.
It was an okay performance. Zoro putting his life on the line should be able to produce such feats. The problem is his fans overhyped his performance way too much. He got so injured he basically had to use deux machina meds in order to fight king. It was a good bit of hype but it was what we should expect people at his level (YC1 or there about) tbh when going all out.

As an example, we have Queen putting big mom to sleep, king tossing BM and crew over a cliff, various scabbards injuring Kaido. Kid and Law pushing BM to an all out fight and pulling out a technical win and lastly Law putting in an imperious shift against BB and his commanders. Heck even Bepo went sulong and almost killed BB when he was saving Law. All these feats are in the same ball park.
 
I don’t know if it hurt Zoro but I do know that it hurts a lot of Zoro haters.
And till this day!:myman:
When someone literally gets online to make fun of you for liking a character lol. The comments about how Zoro will never be as good as his friend in particular feels like some weird projection.
Roof top was legendary. I remember how many people here were seething when zoro showed ashura, which meant all this time since timeskip zoro had been holding back :myman:


Bonus point that zoro was in the rooftop fight while sanji was stuck fighting blackteeth gifter lol :suresure:
They will turn around and praise Sanji for looking more like Zoro. bUt He HaS mOrE sPeEd

"Oh, look what he survived!"
"Wow, he wants to protect Luffy's dream now!"

I actually like Sanji a lot. The reason I laugh at him is because that's part of his design. Yes, every single Straw Hat has a comedy gag or two, though Sanji being the butt of a joke is his own distinction. These people really do want a blonde Zoro and it misses the point.


 
Rooftop give an premature idea of Zoro's power level for the fandom who scaled him too high, just to the end, he backs to fight an opponent who's Sanji's near equal opponent.

It was indeed a great Zoro spotlight, but that's all.
 
King is just underrated, I guess. Rooftop Zoro would just upscale King and people also don't want to accept the fact that King is more durable than Kaido.

I mean all those feats on the rooftop happened, nothing is going to erase them... Big Mom shitting herself at Zoro's Enma One Sword Style, for example, isn't getting rubbed away.

Ashura is also still in a weird place power wise since Zoro didn't use it against King, so all we have is Zoro's Ashura with half his bones broken scarring Kaido in a void.

Zoro vs Lucci was overblown, that fight was nothing more than moderate difficulty for a holding back Zoro who, once again, didn't use Ashura.

Zoro then goes on to clash equally with V. Nusjuro whereas Lucci is cowering in the presence of Mars.

And then Imu vs Zoro goes the way it should have done, not sure what people expected
 
King is just underrated, I guess. Rooftop Zoro would just upscale King and people also don't want to accept the fact that King is more durable than Kaido.

I mean all those feats on the rooftop happened, nothing is going to erase them... Big Mom shitting herself at Zoro's Enma One Sword Style, for example, isn't getting rubbed away.

Ashura is also still in a weird place power wise since Zoro didn't use it against King, so all we have is Zoro's Ashura with half his bones broken scarring Kaido in a void.
Rooftop Zoro being used to upscale King and his equal Queen?

:myman:
 
I would never wanna take away the Rooftop as a Zoro fan but I’d say it definitely hurt more than it helped (the fandom specifically)

Because it gave Zoro fans who already had high expectations for him even higher expectations after which Oda could/would never meet

I mean just look at Zoro fans reaction at the time when he was sent below the Rooftop and his matchup with King began. Nonstop complaining, assuming that Zoro would bully King, etc

Any Zoro fan that was there knows exactly what I’m talking about. Saying that King was “oneshot material” and that Oda was simply wasting Zoro’s time before he went back up to fight Kaido was a very common take at the time

Then look at their reaction to his performance in Egghead. Again, more complaints, claiming that he’s being misused, saying that Kizaru would’ve been a better fit for his strength, etc

And in Elbaf with Zoro getting ready to fight Super Sommers or Killingham instead of Imu I’m starting to hear similar things again. That he’s “holding Zoro back” to protect Luffy or something

Now this isn’t to say that all of these complaints are invalid. Zoro’s fight with Lucci felt extremely redundant and he didn’t grow from it at all, it was easily one of Oda’s more pointless fights

But generally speaking Zoro fans are a lot harder to please post Wano. In their minds Zoro should be putting up a performance like the Rooftop more often and they’re just not seeing it
 
Top