Search results

  1. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    Again, to validate the presence of a plot hole, you need to find something that contradicts the logic of the story in an unexplainable way. As long as it is explainable, even subtly like this situation (which is often the case in One Piece) there are no plot holes. It's basic storytelling. This...
  2. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    What problems? Did you felt Imu had a problem in God Valley? :choppawhat:
  3. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    It means go beyond the surface layer of your own reflections. Exactly. Please show me the panel showing the dead Davies
  4. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    Why do you want characters to function like machines and think about every single possibilities and potentialities at every single moments, why can't characters make mistakes or not think about obvious solutions or simply choose to be non-optimal? I think you are reading the wrong manga if you...
  5. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    I don't need to. 1. It's implicited by the power. It's literally a form of control of the will and body and we know the will can outlast death itself 2. We still don't know if these people are really dead. 3. There are a thousand of reason why they could be on the floor other than domi reversi...
  6. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    Again, you need to understand that a plothole is only a plothole if it breaks the logic of the story in an unexplainable way. The answer here is not only very simple, but can also be explained through the logic of the story, and by the logic I mean "the function of control". You guys needs to...
  7. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    None of this is true mate and as I said. Not a retcon. Damaged done before the domi reversi are not magically healed. These people were already dead.
  8. Logiko

    General & Others Are We Currently in The Golden Age of One Piece?

    Nah, it's about having a good time and I'm always having a good time with One Piece :)
  9. Logiko

    General & Others Are We Currently in The Golden Age of One Piece?

    I remember behind there mate. I lived that period, I watched Ace dies and Robin live. And yes, it was amazing. But the intensity that I feel now is on a completely different level. You could say that it is based on the addition of time and emotional bagage. Yes, but this is part of the...
  10. Logiko

    General & Others Are We Currently in The Golden Age of One Piece?

    Not in term of manga and anime. France was. (and trust me, I don't like to brag about this country) :ohreally:
  11. Logiko

    I MIGHT take people seriously in their hatred of One Piece's story once they will be able to go...

    I MIGHT take people seriously in their hatred of One Piece's story once they will be able to go at the very least 3 years without reading it. Have fun.
  12. Logiko

    General & Others Are We Currently in The Golden Age of One Piece?

    The golden age in term of quality is subjective. People like different things - even if the quality is objectively amazing. If you asked me, I would say that there have been multiple golden ages and we are in one. As for the golden age of One Piece as a series, I would say that the real golden...
  13. Logiko

    General & Others Are We Currently in The Golden Age of One Piece?

    Yes the hype has never been so strong, but it will get even bigger (unless the hatred you see here spreads too far). Just like we knew it would get bigger 10 years ago, One Piece will be a world wide phenomena by the end and people will try to catch up and probably live the experience with other...
  14. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    Read better, in everycase, everything is explainable. Which means that in every cases, it's not Oda who is writing badly, but you guyz who are reading backward. A plot hole is an unexplanable destruction of the lore. As long as an element can be explained it is at worst "unexplained", not a plot...
  15. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    1. We actually don't see anyone dead. You made that asumption on your own 2. It's possible Xebec simply killed them after the fact not knowin what to do 3. The domi reversi doesn't restore the damages taken before, they were probably already dead In reality, you invented a plot hole, what there...
  16. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    No. Most of One Piece's current problems are fans inventions.
  17. Logiko

    Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

    Sounds like someone who wanted to craft a manga but is bitter that he never managed to do it.
Top