Search results

This is Oda's storytelling these days. The only people he's fooling are the people who already fooled themselves with subversive affirmations.

Man, giga-chad Oden pissed in these guys' cheerios so hard they got PTSD against another character. Yamato is as milquetoast as it gets. Sure, I like the character, but Oda could have done so much better building the backstory and dream. Wano was just too big by the time we got to Onigashima...

Carrot becoming the new ruler of Zou is certainly out of left field, and is probably Oda quickly tying up loose ends for a popular character he had no further plans for after WCI, but it's not like Oda hasn't played that card before. Back in Udon, the prisoners knew Luffy was strong and his...

I'm not a petty man, but if Oda is setting up Yamato as the crew's lookout with that "on the rooftop as always" line, I will be laughing my ass off from here to Laugh Tale.

Correct, because her new job is Wano's Gardener Deity. Praise Goda and his subversive affirmation! :finally::finally::finally:

"bUt TaMa SeEs NaMi As A mOtHeR fIgUrE!!" If you're going to troll and accuse other people of not reading, at least try to conceal your headcanons a little bit. It's no fun for the rest of us when your arguments are easily disproven.

My issue with Brook’s character is that he’s defined entirely by his relations to other, more important characters rather than by anything about him specifically. He’s defined by his idolization of his captain's death, the fact that his shadow is stolen by Moria, his friendship with Laboon, etc...

Also depicted here: C4N relentlessly dragging Carrot back into the thread to force his own dream for her, when she's had enough adventure and would rather go back to Zou with her family and eat some grass. Except it has gotten follow up. Yamato showed true dedication to Luffy that swayed even...

Carrot's going to become Pandaman's girlfriend and be the new easter egg for people to search for in the background crowd characters. Carrot fans should rejoice because she'll actually appear more often now. Chapter 1052 was the first example of her new important background role.

Lol you know what people aren't talking about? Jinbei's "We have to wait for the captain." Jinbei made a complete 180 on Yamato's character in one chapter, just like we said last week lol. It was nothing. Yamato literally starved for seven days in hopes the simple prayer would help Luffy, and...

Carrot for nakama fans should just accept at this point they got hoodwinked by Oda's editor Naito. Dude was the main editor during the latter half of WCI (when Carrot got all her "development" and screentime), and he was replaced in the beginning of Wano (when Carrot mysteriously vanishes from...

:blush: Lol I usually just like to lurk and feast on the copious amount of salt around here, but seeing you at full power wanted me to join in on the fun.

Well well well, in the most obvious example of Occam's razor since Brook joined, we have someone who said nearly 70 chapters ago that they would join the crew finally join the crew. There was room for doubt in 985 when Yamato was just introduced, but then 1016 happened and there was no reason...

Not true. We have had some honest, well-thought arguments for new nakamas like Raizo, Caribou, and Tama. They even gave compelling evidence with actual manga panels instead of blog posts. We simply used Carrot-stans' logic with these characters and they all fit that logic better than Carrot...

Y'all remember when Kaido knocked Luffy off Onigashima the first time and Carrot fans said she was the only one around who could save Luffy from falling into the ocean? How Perospero telling her to eat grass was Oda subverting our expectations to put Carrot in the perfect place to make SH move...

I say bring it. When Oda wants to write a character, he makes them work well. Carrot’s bishouju gag and Chopper-aniki are legit funny. If Oda writes Carrot as an actual secondary protagonist, she’s fine. See WCI. It’s just not WCI anymore and Carrot has not had one gag in all of Wano. I don’t...

Lol, we’re watching in real time some people getting their headcanons squashed. Carrot got Rebecca-ed right before our eyes. Even now people are reaching back to WCI to argue Carrot’s chances rather than what’s happening right in front of us. Oh, it was never about Perospero, it was about this...

Aww, how cute! Look at dizzy roleplaying, thinking they’re a real psychologist, throwing around diagnoses like “disorder” and “misconception.” Man, it’s so reassuring knowing a random internet personality has the authority to diagnose a fictional character with real-world terminology. And doing...

Here’s the thing about the “both sides are guilty” approach. It’s bullshit. Now, I’m not going to go pointing fingers as there are good arguers for any character, but come on. The name thing. It’s one thing to roast a character once in a while. The straw hats roast each other. Look at Sanji and...

That pic is literally cherry-picking from a secondary source to argue for your head canon. Typical fallacy of someone who has no recent primary sources to draw from. Funny how people use the anime for that when it suits their purpose since the manga doesn’t support it, but where was Carrot when...