Role Madness A Certain Magical Mafia II - Game Thread
If we roll scum together I may tell you Charlie bb.
I haven't really thought about MVP. Would probably say @Fujishiro - I think he was the only townie driving anything early, and the Flower lynch really set the ball in motion for a town win. I think if a townie got mislynched there, this game could have gone very differently.
@MangoSenpai Picked up slack later in the game, and deserves props for accurately picking out the targets in the PoE. But I thought he made some calculation errors early in the game. Claiming to be a Level 5 was one of them. That put a serious target on his back, and I'm surprised that scum didn't kill him with Flower's role (which bypassed Iron). Flower had correctly identified that he was Dark Matter. Also, the forensic cop had more utility early game, because there were less nights in which a player could have targeted someone who was then dead. So a positive result would be more incriminating early than late. Think the vig was probably the weakest role he could make from that perspective. But, Mango deserves props for stepping up as a town leader, and I think quietly Mango has become a much improved player over recent months.
@York deserves props for using her role well. Catching two scum was undoubtedly a big part as to why the town won. I felt however, that she was rather too apathetic towards the day phases. She's clearly capable of making some good reads, and can use reason and deduction well,,which makes her a pretty good Mafia player in my book. I'd like to see her be a bit more engaged in the days themselves, which is where the bread and butter of town is. I don't mean post more, but to demonstrate her ability more. In fairness, there was reason to coast here due to her role, but after catching Charlie, I was hoping she would really take over the game and control the thread too.
@MangoSenpai Picked up slack later in the game, and deserves props for accurately picking out the targets in the PoE. But I thought he made some calculation errors early in the game. Claiming to be a Level 5 was one of them. That put a serious target on his back, and I'm surprised that scum didn't kill him with Flower's role (which bypassed Iron). Flower had correctly identified that he was Dark Matter. Also, the forensic cop had more utility early game, because there were less nights in which a player could have targeted someone who was then dead. So a positive result would be more incriminating early than late. Think the vig was probably the weakest role he could make from that perspective. But, Mango deserves props for stepping up as a town leader, and I think quietly Mango has become a much improved player over recent months.
@York deserves props for using her role well. Catching two scum was undoubtedly a big part as to why the town won. I felt however, that she was rather too apathetic towards the day phases. She's clearly capable of making some good reads, and can use reason and deduction well,,which makes her a pretty good Mafia player in my book. I'd like to see her be a bit more engaged in the days themselves, which is where the bread and butter of town is. I don't mean post more, but to demonstrate her ability more. In fairness, there was reason to coast here due to her role, but after catching Charlie, I was hoping she would really take over the game and control the thread too.
