[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Ratchet]

We can theorise around Cooler all day. We don't know whether scum knew Walder was Cooler by then or not.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

We can theorise around Cooler all day. We don't know whether scum knew Walder was Cooler by then or not.

If mafia leader knew Cooler was Walder and then sent him to do the faction kill then it checks out with what Yo Tan is saying.

If not, then its TMI.

This is probably the biggest claim which checked out Yo Tan’s role. But we can just theorise.

 

[Underworld Broker]

At page 37

--
Why do ppl rn think neeko is fake claiming purple as red? Thats so weird considering how much he was asking ppl to put votes on arp

 

[T-Pein™]

I read that mafia leader can send him the msgs <.<

I was just wondering about the mechanism of how that worked like they only knew that Walder is part of their gang but didn’t know Cooler is this Walder.

Actually it says he would join the mafia team if something happened.
Maybe one of their members dying was this trigger.

Mafia Traitor (owing to your reluctance to leave your seat, you are something of a lone wolf. You will operate as part of the Lannister Alliance, but you will not join their chat unless certain events come to pass. The leadership of the Lannister Alliance is permitted to write to you once per night phase, but be mindful that ravens can be intercepted. Also bear in mind, they do not know your identity)


Anyways he was seen visiting SK so what are you trying to prove?

 

[Kagu Nyan]

If mafia leader knew Cooler was Walder and then sent him to do the faction kill then it checks out with what Yo Tan is saying.

If not, then its TMI.

This is probably the biggest claim which checked out Yo Tan’s role. But we can just theorise.

@T-Pein™

 

[T-Pein™]

At page 37

--
Why do ppl rn think neeko is fake claiming purple as red? Thats so weird considering how much he was asking ppl to put votes on arp

Because once he got the claim he never went back to Arp.
He was also "arguing" with me that the claim could be fake but regardless he instead wanted to lynch ekko instead of arp or pero.

 

[T-Pein™]

@T-Pein™

*rolls eyes.
His role literally says he will join the main mafia at some point for some reasons.
And he obviously did since he killed SK.
I still do not understand what you are on about

 

[Underworld Broker]

Because once he got the claim he never went back to Arp.
He was also "arguing" with me that the claim could be fake but regardless he instead wanted to lynch ekko instead of arp or pero.

Is this smth neeko usually does given the circumstances?

Gotta keep reading i guess

 

[Kagu Nyan]

At page 37

--
Why do ppl rn think neeko is fake claiming purple as red? Thats so weird considering how much he was asking ppl to put votes on arp

I don’t think he’s a red who’s faking purple. He was one of the first ones to come out. There’s something about people coming out first which gives them some extra points.

 

[T-Pein™]

Is this smth neeko usually does given the circumstances?

Gotta keep reading i guess

Idk
Just one of them theories people can have.
Regardless he is scum...purple or red.
Both are scum

 

[Kagu Nyan]

*rolls eyes.
His role literally says he will join the main mafia at some point for some reasons.
And he obviously did since he killed SK.
I still do not understand what you are on about

I don’t know why are you so against a simple discussion.

 

[T-Pein™]

I don’t know why are you so against a simple discussion.

What is your goal?
Why are you concerned about cooler?
He is dead.
Are you implying ytw is lying that he saw cooler kill SK?
Why?

@Yo Tan Wa get in here

 

[RippedCal]

Ripped one is here

 

[RippedCal]

Did lethal show his face yet

 

[Kagu Nyan]

What is your goal?
Why are you concerned about cooler?
He is dead.
Are you implying ytw is lying that he saw cooler kill SK?
Why?

@Yo Tan Wa get in here

I’m not concerned about cooler but I’m concerned that we can’t check out Yo Tan’s claim for this. Previously this idea didn’t occur to me but now that I have realised it’s just making me paranoid.

 

[T-Pein™]

I’m not concerned about cooler but I’m concerned that we can’t check out Yo Tan’s claim for this. Previously this idea didn’t occur to me but now that I have realised it’s just making me paranoid.

He claims jon Snow
This game not having the main dude would be weird...
Also charlie has the revive ability that revived jon snow back with his abilities and everyone else as vanilla or something

 

[Charlie]

He could be scum even if not Red. Other than Dany faction, we propably have Littlefiner or Lysa Arryn (as Knights of the Vale day killed Tyrion - Worst), Victartion Greyjoy (mentioned in Euron's role) and maybe Night King (hinted in Gramma's portents writeups).

Though Ekko hinted Oberyn Martell which kind of fits with his duel ability. Does anyone think it could be fake claim?

I mean, Arryns could have duel ability (trial by combat), but I'll just go with Oberyn. Whether he's indie or town, he hates Lannisters so he's good.

Subbed back in for Salah. I’m head of the Red mafia now.

Instant flashback to FMA game and Hohenheim-gate.

Lol he saw it in the fire as Mel.

LoL as for Lord of Light? He's almighty indeed. I don't test his strength.

This was a serious question btw. Bc Zolo claims a character that needed Pero dead.

Only character other than Oberyn (Ekko) and Hound (UB) could be High Sparrow I think.

Pero's just salty I caught him right away, his word can't be trusted.

What? You haven't caught anything. You came in and voted him without any input.

@Underworld Broker under ur approval, we can get lethal claiming in under 6 hours, or your money refunded. guranteed.

Worked out perfectly last time .-. I'd be cautious with pushing for claims only.

Am I at least Tyrion?

Lancel. Take it or leave it.

, it likely were Jeffrey ability to end the day with a lynch of his choice.

Why Jeffrey and not Tywin?

Who would have poison in this theme, though? Tyrells?

Ollena, Cersei, Littlefinger, Varys. So only Ollena if we're talking about town. Or Varys. He could be town, purple, red or indie, really.

The old hag that poisoned Joffrey in the show probably

Watch your mouth. She's the best girl.

Nana- Mace Tarly

That's the most random town role I can think of. But ok.

ytw and ratchet masoned obviously
sam john duo

That would just make Lady Shark (doo doo doo doo doo doo) weaker version of it.

There is Ekko, Charlie and Pot Goblin etc…. Ar

Between the two if YTW says he needs Robb to die to unlock an ability then I think only Jon Snow could be the fake claim unless host is really trolling.

But his claim tracks with his Cooler vote/call out.

Tbh, I have no idea for what kind of sign from LoL other than death of JS would I have to wait to get that special revive.

Wakanda is prolly some indie, why does he have so many abilities

I thought I was basically indie. Then I looked at SK's role.

The type that when two protect types visit the same dude he losses the healing.

To make it clear. I won't lose it, no matter what. Lord of Light is just that great. Other guy's protective role will be burned. Role aka abilitiy. So if we both healed Ekko for example, you would lose BG part of your role, but you'd still be miller with sword.

Also if we heal same person, that person isn't protected that night.

@WakandaForever where you at?

 

[Charlie]

I should have just posted it on 5 separate posts, shouldn't I?

 

[T-Pein™]

Ytw did say that he visited me n3 and saw no one visit me.
Then when I said I was not able to use my abilities so I was locked out from them somehow he said his ability actually failed and host hadn't mentioned it.

 

[Underworld Broker]

yeah i know

exactly my point dear pero

someone more familiar with those two, especially cooler, told you this

cooler has barely played here

Q.E.D you were told this by someone who is familiar with nf and plays there

Interesting d1 post, so far no one other than cooler flipped from nf. Cooler wasnt in their group (yet) from what we know so hmm

What does QED mean btw?