Character Discussion A thread for characters ruined by Oda

[moreha9685]

Like kidd

Kid can still play some role. Jack is completely useless.

 

[Warine]

Come post the characters you think Oda ruined his design or his characterisation or powers.

I'll start with Gol D Roger being turned into Clown D Roger :

*the image is from https://x.com/DailyOPMemes/status/1854470763421790308?t=BWCjR-moGlBuo6Z10ieXFg&s=19

@Sentinel @Tyki_Mikk @Buusatan94 @Topi Jerami @RayanOO

Roger got yassified for the female audience, it is known

 

[moreha9685]

Roger got yassified for the female audience, it is known

Brother's a gay fashion icon, what female audience is he pullin'?

 

[Warine]

Brother's a gay fashion icon, what female audience is he pullin'?

The fujos obviously

 

[moreha9685]

The fujos obviously

Sometimes Im glad I dont know certain fandoms

 

[Warine]

Sometimes Im glad I dont know certain fandoms

Essentially 50% of the female fans are fujos, it is known

 

[Ven437]

Like kidd

Post automatically merged: Nov 8, 2024

Nami had some moments in wci and wano

Brook had far far better moments than Nami. He also did something useful which was to get Road Poneglyph copy. Nami is just a walking pile of fanservice whose power is derived from a Yonko and not her own brain or genius

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

Logias post time skip.

They’re STILL supposed to be the strongest fruits, but outside of literally just Kizaru (who’s fruit is just broken and needs plot to counter him) they’ve looked completely useless.

Even Kuzan practically went “fuck my ice let’s throw hands” the moment he encountered someone that was actually relative to him

 

[Warine]

Logias post time skip.

They’re STILL supposed to be the strongest fruits, but outside of just Kizaru they’ve looked completely useless.

Even Kuzan practically went “fuck my ice let’s throw hands” the moment he encountered someone that was actually relative to him

Kuzan is quite literally one of the only character with a guaranteed one shot ability against everyone

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

Logias post time skip.

They’re STILL supposed to be the strongest fruits, but outside of literally just Kizaru (who’s fruit is just broken and needs plot to counter him) they’ve looked completely useless.

Even Kuzan practically went “fuck my ice let’s throw hands” the moment he encountered someone that was actually relative to him

Imma say it, if logias don’t have awakenings all statements about them being the strongest fruit class have been retconned to be non-canon.

@Elder Lee Hung @Kurozumi Wiwi

 

[Warine]

I do think few characters actually got ruined, it's just that Lolda is unable to give the spotlight to anyone but goofy, goofy g5 is a downgrade tho

 

[Juanpiz]

Kuzan is quite literally one of the only character with a guaranteed one shot ability against everyone

Magellan?

Post automatically merged: Nov 8, 2024

Brook had far far better moments than Nami. He also did something useful which was to get Road Poneglyph copy. Nami is just a walking pile of fanservice whose power is derived from a Yonko and not her own brain or genius

She helped against cracker and ulti

 

[Warine]

Magellan?

Not really considering his track record

 

[Buusatan94]

Regarding big mom..pudding,cracker and brûlée. Weren’t so bad

Cracker started good, but the way his defeat was written wasn't too impressive. As for Brûlée I can't say that I was happy or impressed how often she was kidnapped and used as a tool by the Straw Hats and allies.

 

[Juanpiz]

Cracker started good, but the way his defeat was written wasn't too impressive. As for Brûlée I can't say that I was happy or impressed how often she was kidnapped and used as a tool by the Straw Hats and allies.

But she has nice personality and flashback

 

[Yakyu]

I still can't process how silhouetted Greenbull went from looking a funny and wild guy who ignores his boss to wano Aramaki who is absolute garbage actually sucking the Celestial Dragon's balls and being Sakazuki fanboy when Sakazuki himself gives no fucks about CD/Gorosei authority.

 

[BigAmmi]

Don't forget one of the leaders of the group

 

[Veku]

Sanji
Luffy
Chopper

These 3 had the biggest fall offs bar none.

Eclipse is childsplay compared to Sanji fans witnessing Sanji's downfall - especially WCI arc

 

[JoNdule]

he completely destroyed Imu's mystery and prestige with a single chapter

I still can't process how silhouetted Greenbull went from looking a funny and wild guy who ignores his boss to wano Aramaki who is absolute garbage actually sucking the Celestial Dragon's balls and being Sakazuki fanboy when Sakazuki himself gives no fucks about CD/Gorosei authority.

Thanks for reminding this

Oda ruined GB and Kizaru
Greenbukl was a lot more interesting in his intro
Then all of a sudden this dude is a scumbag who idolises Akainu and wants recognition so badly

 

[Buusatan94]

But she has nice personality and flashback

Which is sadly overshadowed by how poorly she's portrayed and treated, much like her mother.