Powers & Abilities Adv CoC is a requirement for Admiral rank

Which is it?

  • Admirals have CoC

  • Admirals have no CoC <--- 2 digit IQ people vote here


Results are only viewable after voting.
#22
Geee, it's almost as if author is doing that thing where he's hiding character's power until they get their true 1v1 of the series
And who will that be against?

Fuji is a good guy
Kizaru is a good guy

The only bad admirals are Akainu and GB. Akainu probably has ACoC, but nothing suggests GB does.
Post automatically merged:

Realistically the admirals are a fight for the revolutionaries and the good marines.
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#24
We will see i seen every type of haki expert downfall people are not good at predicit oda with this stuff
What do you make of this? Chinjao says you have to stand atop those supreme kings to be PK, and then literally lists the supreme kings by name as Naval Admirals and Four Emperors.


You think Oda changed his mind? That would be the only explanation to Chinjao's statement being a lie. I would say there's a slight chance he had, up until the latest chapter.

Now, let's ignore the above. Do you think Fujitora won't end up with CoC, I think he is the key in all of this. Akainu is a far more obvious choice, which gives Kuzan the nod, so then we can kinda subcategorize the Admirals. But it all hinges on Fujitora. If you don't think he will get it, then that's the only argument I can see against the OP.
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#28
And who will that be against?

Fuji is a good guy
Kizaru is a good guy
I kind of agree with this, (not that Kizaru is a good guy) I don't necessary believe all Admirals will ever get to go all out or even be defeated. They are a combination of too morally ambiguous and too strong, which puts them in a tough spot. Akainu doesn't gap them hard enough for everyone to neatly get their Admiral 1v1s, and I'm only confident Akainu will be allowed to show out because Oda can just use him to represent the Admirals, it's easier to do than go through each Admiral one by one. I'm not so confident Oda is the right author for this, he doesn't care to draw battles.

We might just get an sbs, vc drop, or even a statement in the manga which will just say btw Admirals have CoC.
 
#32
And who will that be against?
Goofy, Zoro Sanji and whoerever is left (Probably someone like Loki, Yamato, Sabo, or law)
Fuji is a good guy
Kizaru is a good guy
Stop with this cringe "good guys" shit.

Garp the goodest of the good guys was fighting Roger to near death over nothing. He priortized capturing Roger over Rocks.
Sengoku the good guy was slaughtering WB pirates and executing ace

Fujitora's whole business is being "blind justice" and fighting for his side.
He was fully ready to kill Goofy even after he saved Dressrosa.




Kizaru is not even close to being a good guy. Him seeing Goofy as a tool that maybe might save his friends from him does not mean good guy.
Kizaru would slit child's throat if it will be his job.
but nothing suggests GB does
You want to look at the top of the post's panels again?
 
#33
What do you make of this? Chinjao says you have to stand atop those supreme kings to be PK, and then literally lists the supreme kings by name as Naval Admirals and Four Emperors.


You think Oda changed his mind? That would be the only explanation to Chinjao's statement being a lie. I would say there's a slight chance he had, up until the latest chapter.

Now, let's ignore the above. Do you think Fujitora won't end up with CoC, I think he is the key in all of this. Akainu is a far more obvious choice, which gives Kuzan the nod, so then we can kinda subcategorize the Admirals. But it all hinges on Fujitora. If you don't think he will get it, then that's the only argument I can see against the OP.
Here are my thoughts on CoC:

Early on, CoC clearly seemed like some "chosen one" shit. The ones confirmed were:

Luffy - The MC
Rayleigh - Roger Pirate with a King epithet
Shanks - MC's father figure and arguably the biggest catalyst in OP
Boa - A queen
Whitebeard - Roger's Rival/Equal
Roger - The Pirate King
(I know some people think Oda planned everything or some shit; I'm not drinking that Kool-Aid, no one in marineford was even hinted to have it beside Dragon, which is the MC father.)

Now, post-TS, you bring up that Don Chinjao stuff, and you are right. Narratively—and I know you value this too, even if we don't always agree, versus most of the "feat guys" that plague the powerscaling community—this clearly says that by the time we're past Dressrosa, Conqueror's isn't a big deal. Chinjao's statement pretty much says tons of people have CoC. That's Part 2.

Now, Part 3 is Wano. In Wano, Oda made the decision that CoC is a power-up that is not only relevant but seems vital. Basically, if you don't have this or some other equivalent power, you're kinda locked out of the EoS top 5.

(I'm not addressing all the headcanons from people who created arbitrary CoC signifiers through poor reading comprehension.)

This tells me two things: A) Oda will change this as he sees fit, and B) over time, Oda made this more of a power-level issue.


My conclusion is this: At this point, it will depend on when and how the Admirals are fought. I'm of the opinion that Logia Awakenings are going to be some real, busted shit. We saw Kizaru already clowning Luffy without using it and while restricting himself, too. This means an Admiral could still pose an endgame-level threat to most characters, even in the final arc. However, if they're going to fight against the true top dogs at the end, that won't be enough, and they will need ACoC and other shit, too.
 
#35
Kizaru literally self-identifies as a “cog in the machine.” Which part of that screams Conqueror to you?
Read a history book, an empire is built on conquers submitting to greater conquers. The world government is the greatest empire of all time, with 20 kingdoms all submitting to the greatest conquer of all time, Imu. Ironically, Saturn himself was a cog in the machine replaced by the government for his rebellion, paralleling Kizaru and Vegapunk, and yet he had supreme kings Haki
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#36
Here are my thoughts on CoC:

Early on, CoC clearly seemed like some "chosen one" shit. The ones confirmed were:

Luffy - The MC
Rayleigh - Roger Pirate with a King epithet
Shanks - MC's father figure and arguably the biggest catalyst in OP
Boa - A queen
Whitebeard - Roger's Rival/Equal
Roger - The Pirate King
(I know some people think Oda planned everything or some shit; I'm not drinking that Kool-Aid, no one in marineford was even hinted to have it beside Dragon, which is the MC father.)

Now, post-TS, you bring up that Don Chinjao stuff, and you are right. Narratively—and I know you value this too, even if we don't always agree, versus most of the "feat guys" that plague the powerscaling community—this clearly says that by the time we're past Dressrosa, Conqueror's isn't a big deal. Chinjao's statement pretty much says tons of people have CoC. That's Part 2.

Now, Part 3 is Wano. In Wano, Oda made the decision that CoC is a power-up that is not only relevant but seems vital. Basically, if you don't have this or some other equivalent power, you're kinda locked out of the EoS top 5.

(I'm not addressing all the headcanons from people who created arbitrary CoC signifiers through poor reading comprehension.)

This tells me two things: A) Oda will change this as he sees fit, and B) over time, Oda made this more of a power-level issue.


My conclusion is this: At this point, it will depend on when and how the Admirals are fought. I'm of the opinion that Logia Awakenings are going to be some real, busted shit. We saw Kizaru already clowning Luffy without using it and while restricting himself, too. This means an Admiral could still pose an endgame-level threat to most characters, even in the final arc. However, if they're going to fight against the true top dogs at the end, that won't be enough, and they will need ACoC and other shit, too.
Logia awakening is a good counterpoint. It might be verse breaking. To that I would say perhaps the Admirals will all have CoC, but not necessarily AdCoC. Just like all Yonkou had AdCoC but not Awakening. This seems like the balance beween top tiers, where Oda might slightly favour Admiral fruits, while slightly favouring Yonkou haki, but both still being well rounded in all departments. Heck even top tiers that have Conq coating like Kaidou/Big Mom and Shanks, don't seem to operate at the same level when it comes to Haki (Shanks is a notch above).

This also wouldn't contradict Chinjao's words, Admirals not getting CoC would make Chinjao out to be a liar.
 
#37
Spot on. Obviously they have CoC.


Admirals sign a contract that legally binds them to suck the CoC of any CD that orders them to do so.

That's hardly a conqueror feat.
Yeah, so much that one wanted to nuclearize Marijoa (Fujitora), another betrayed the highest rank of the CDs (Kizaru) and so on.
Compared to that, Ray, just to say one, seemed infinitely more passive to his captain.

Not to mention the CDs are literally salves to Imu and still have CoC.
 
#38
Advance coc for fleet admiral rank is more make sense. I believe sakazuki beat kuzan with advance coc. He got haki bloom in that fight, from basic coc to advance.
 
Top