[FNZ] Role Madness Alabasta Arc (Smoker and Mafia victory)

[Dr_Professor83]

This is why you're a lieutenant and not Cap

But I believe in you to carry us so I forgive you

Lol glad one of us does.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

The only character who makes sense as vig is Zoro imo.

So Zoro, if you aren’t T-Pein, we have a problem.

Not that you can or should say if you are out there.

 

[Ultra]

You know I'm really not sure why scum chooses Enryu to dehydrate, here.

Also wasn't there an earlier mention of a 10 word post restriction that came with that or no

 

[Dr_Professor83]

You know I'm really not sure why scum chooses Enryu to dehydrate, here.

Also wasn't there an earlier mention of a 10 word post restriction that came with that or no

Ekko got hit by a PR. Wasn’t the dehydrate though. That was D1 and the dehydrate has been a night ability.

I’m starting to think that mafia may have dehydrated Enryu because we had considered one of Conq/Enryu to be possible mafia RB. Maybe they want us to think it’s Conq? Not sure because that’s pretty sloppy if so but it’s my only guess. Unless it’s to reverse psychology what I just said. Idk could think like that all day.

If Enryu is lying he’ll self solve.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I doubt he’s faking though. Would mean that they would have to abstain on the dehydration unless someone else comes forward, which makes no sense if they had any idea they were killing the water boy.

 

[Ultra]

Ekko got hit by a PR. Wasn’t the dehydrate though. That was D1 and the dehydrate has been a night ability.

I’m starting to think that mafia may have dehydrated Enryu because we had considered one of Conq/Enryu to be possible mafia RB. Maybe they want us to think it’s Conq? Not sure because that’s pretty sloppy if so but it’s my only guess. Unless it’s to reverse psychology what I just said. Idk could think like that all day.

If Enryu is lying he’ll self solve.

If you have a mafia RB out of those two players then you probably don't wanna touch the one who's town in order not to basically confirm the other as scum though.

My point was more that not only was Enryu in the PoE but there are much more obvious targets that would benefit them, like Baba if his implication is to be believed.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

If you have a mafia RB out of those two players then you probably don't wanna touch the one who's town in order not to basically confirm the other as scum though.

I’m saying they might both be Town and Mafia wanted to make Conq look bad. But that’s probably not a great idea because of course we’d start wondering if it’s a set up.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

My point was more that not only was Enryu in the PoE but there are much more obvious targets that would benefit them, like Baba if his implication is to be believed.

If he’s lying we’ll find out. And if he’s lying it means they didn’t dehydrate anyone if there is no counter claim. Which would be a huge win.

 

[Flower]

Let's wait for Fuji tbh.

 

[Midnight Delight]

Let's wait for Fuji tbh.

He's busy

 

[T-Pein™]

Tho it never did make sense for mafia to kill Ratchet.

He was an outed indie.
I killed him.
I was gonna kill all the indies.
But ekko started playing terribad so I killed him instead.
I assumed he would flip mafia.
Kagura > ekko

 

[Flower]

Possibilities:

1) Failed kills don't show or Fuji forgot.
2) Scum killed Ratchet (unlikely).
3) Pein just slipped.

 

[T-Pein™]

3) Pein just slipped.

slip?
I literally said it straight up.

 

[Flower]

He was an outed indie.
I killed him.
I was gonna kill all the indies.
But ekko started playing terribad so I killed him instead.
I assumed he would flip mafia.
Kagura > ekko

He didn't play bad at all...hell, I even trusted him this game.

 

[Flower]

slip?
I literally said it straight up.

Yeah, but there was no failed kill, so...unless it's a hosting thing like failed kills not showing or Fuji forgetting, you're outed. Mafia don't abstain.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Possibilities:

1) Failed kills don't show or Fuji forgot.
2) Scum killed Ratchet (unlikely).
3) Pein just slipped.

2 and 3 are the same thing lol.

 

[Flower]

2 and 3 are the same thing lol.

Not really. If a Vig and a scum kill the same player, there's only one kill in the WU, too. That was just a double kill, then.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

He was an outed indie.
I killed him.
I was gonna kill all the indies.
But ekko started playing terribad so I killed him instead.
I assumed he would flip mafia.
Kagura > ekko

Hope you’re Scum and not Town lol. Ekko is a huge reason we still have a chance.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Not really. If a Vig and a scum kill the same player, there's only one kill in the WU, too. That was just a double kill, then.

Oh I wasn’t thinking of it like that. Yeah that’s unlikely.

 

[Flower]

Oh I wasn’t thinking of it like that. Yeah that’s unlikely.

Though given the target choice I just assume it was a hosting error. Because if Lanji was commuted and a bus driver, his action would have failed, too.

I just don't know why scum would have killed Ratchet. Unless they didn't pay attention or something.