Character Discussion Are there any good-faith arguments for Nami being the left hand/unofficial general instead of Sanji?

#25
Panel time should tell you what Oda says about the crews hierarchy, I mean Luffy, Zoro and Nami have way more panel time than any other crew members, Nami is currently in 3re place and has more than double of Sanji's screen time, heck Usopp is only now behind Sanji because of WCI but he will reclaim his 4th place again by end of next arc.

So yeah Oda clearly thinks Luffy, Zoro and Nami are more important than any other crew member just by how much panel time is dedicated to them, you can clearly tell by the way he works every plot point to have either Luffy, Zoro or Nami is the driving factors of it.
 
#26
It's really apples to oranges. Zoro and Nami were the first two because their goals align with Luffy best and being the best in regards to their goals is vital. They are the two most likely to be found at his side.

Sanji however has the greatest variety of high level skills. Well, up til now at least. Jinbe is a game changer and it's clear because Oda made a point to show Sanji being jealous. But it's not like Sanji is actually "replaced" because his skills are unique. This isn't DBZ where the supporting cast becomes irrelevant.
 
#27
Panel time should tell you what Oda says about the crews hierarchy, I mean Luffy, Zoro and Nami have way more panel time than any other crew members, Nami is currently in 3re place and has more than double of Sanji's screen time, heck Usopp is only now behind Sanji because of WCI but he will reclaim his 4th place again by end of next arc.

So yeah Oda clearly thinks Luffy, Zoro and Nami are more important than any other crew member just by how much panel time is dedicated to them, you can clearly tell by the way he works every plot point to have either Luffy, Zoro or Nami is the driving factors of it.
Pretty sure last time people counted Sanji has more panel time than Zoro
 
#28
Panel time should tell you what Oda says about the crews hierarchy, I mean Luffy, Zoro and Nami have way more panel time than any other crew members, Nami is currently in 3re place and has more than double of Sanji's screen time, heck Usopp is only now behind Sanji because of WCI but he will reclaim his 4th place again by end of next arc.

So yeah Oda clearly thinks Luffy, Zoro and Nami are more important than any other crew member just by how much panel time is dedicated to them, you can clearly tell by the way he works every plot point to have either Luffy, Zoro or Nami is the driving factors of it.
But...in terms of panel time Luffy>Nami>Sanji
Post automatically merged:

Not in a fighting or leadership sense. Sanji’s very clearly the number three guy there. The split at Saobody and the Swirlyhats, as the two off the top of my head, make that certain, but there will be more,

But you can certainly make an argument that Nami is closer to Luffy than Sanji is, and vice-versa. And that, I suppose, could be considered a left hand role in it’s own right.

Nami’s the main heroine of One Piece, that’s a different dynamic to what Sanji has. Her role in the series is not about leadership or strength, but more about emotional bonds. Just like Usopp’s as important as Sanji is, but his role is not to be one of the cool fighting badasses, but as an ordinary man travelling with extraordinary people in order to better himself.
This is an excellent way to put it.
 
#29
Panel time should tell you what Oda says about the crews hierarchy, I mean Luffy, Zoro and Nami have way more panel time than any other crew members, Nami is currently in 3re place and has more than double of Sanji's screen time, heck Usopp is only now behind Sanji because of WCI but he will reclaim his 4th place again by end of next arc.

So yeah Oda clearly thinks Luffy, Zoro and Nami are more important than any other crew member just by how much panel time is dedicated to them, you can clearly tell by the way he works every plot point to have either Luffy, Zoro or Nami is the driving factors of it.
You on crack. Before Wano Sanji was no2 behind Luffy in panel time. Pretty sure Nami hasn't overtaken him. Maybe Zoro.
 
#30
Pretty sure last time people counted Sanji has more panel time than Zoro
Nope my friend, Nami and Zoro have more than double what Sanji has in reality.
Post automatically merged:

But...in terms of panel time Luffy>Nami>Sanji
I don't count flashbacks, maybe that's why Sanji is fighting for 4th place with Usopp on my list.
Majority of Sanji's panel time I guess is thanks to his flashbacks but not in the stories current timeline.
 
Last edited:
#31
Nope my friend, Nami and Zoro have more than double what Sanji has in reality.
Post automatically merged:



I don't count flashbacks, maybe that's why Sanji is fighting for 4th place with Usopp on my list.
Majority of Sanji's panel time I guess is thanks to his flashbacks but not in the stories current timeline.
What’s your source on this?
 
#32
What’s your source on this?
Counted it myself last year when that guy on reddit did the count till act2, I didnt believe him so I counted myself and at that time "act2" without flashbacks Sanji was 4th and leading only because Usopp wasn't in WCI since from beginning Sanji and Usopp have been fighting for 4th place
 
#34
Counted it myself last year when that guy on reddit did the count till act2, I didnt believe him so I counted myself and at that time "act2" without flashbacks Sanji was 4th and leading only because Usopp wasn't in WCI since from beginning Sanji and Usopp have been fighting for 4th place
So source: Trust me
Post automatically merged:

Where he called military advisor, serious question that's the first time Don Le Fishe heard about this
It was in his first vivre card same pack Zoro was called has “Vice captain like role”
 
#38
Nami does have narrative importance to the story. She fixed Luffy's hat (his treasure) after his fight with Buggy.

Luffy also gave her his hat to wear during Arlong Park.

When Nami was sick and needed a doctor on Drum Island, Luffy bowed his head and showed humility. (I can't remember if this was anime only)

Nami and Zoro with Luffy when Blackbeard declared that "men's dreams never die"

She helped Luffy reach Enel.

She helped Luffy defeat Cracker.

However, it is Sanji, not Nami that has lead the crew.

Both characters are important to the narrative of the story.
 
#39
Nami maybe was left hand, or whatever important role she possesed, but only before time skip. Like idk how you could talk about her character, when she was just turned into fanservice doll, nothing more.
People already showed few examples:
1. Dress Rosa - she listened commands from Sanji;
2. WCI - we all saw how Nami slapped Sanji's face, but for what was that happening? Some people said that Sanji should bring appologize to Nami and Luffy and that never happened. No conclusions at all;

You know how recognize important character from filler one? Events that happened with filler character was never important to story, and that's Nami for ya, after time skip. Her fight with Cracker wasn't explaned, case she was not important. When she made Zeus and homies listen to her, it wasn't explaned, case she is not important. Also her fight with Ulti was skipped, interrupted and over in most stupid way case Nami right now is Filler Character.
 
#40
Counted it myself last year when that guy on reddit did the count till act2, I didnt believe him so I counted myself and at that time "act2" without flashbacks Sanji was 4th and leading only because Usopp wasn't in WCI since from beginning Sanji and Usopp have been fighting for 4th place
Sanji was not in Dressrosa or Zou, Ussop joined before Sanji
 
Top