Controversial Are you on team Yamato is a daughter.

[Mr. Reloaded]

She's gone. Why do people still care about this?

 

[SakazOuki]

Assuming Yamato is male is a very sexist thing to, because that way you're saying women can only do what men do (in this case Yamahoe idolizing Oden) only when they are men

 

[zzShinichi]

I would lay with Yamato

 

[RoronoaZorro]

Assuming Yamato is male is a very sexist thing to, because that way you're saying women can only do what men do (in this case Yamahoe idolizing Oden) only when they are men

It has that kind of tendency tho, sadly.

"Wow, finally a real strong female character! Oh wait, she's a male?"

 

[Logiko]

translation necessary

Transition, not translation

Being trans is not a mental issue.

I said someone was killed and I know the person who was accused of doing it, it's quite simple for anyone with even relatively common sense which you obviously lack.

You are not very clear on that, really strange.

Gender is not social construction if I don't accept it as different from sex. Just like calling people as "they" is not correct if I don't accept.

Gender IS a social construction weither you accept it or not its a scientific consensus.

Okay so we agreed that she identifies as Oden and not a man. Therefore nothing indicates gender fluid.

She is Oden not a man. She is trying to be someone else not another gender.

Oden being a man, they identify therefore to all the gender construction of Oden, which are those of a man.
And yes, they are most likely gender fluid because they also idenfify as a woman when then say "Yamato".
But again, its unclear, hence why the debate here. Both option (trans and gender fluid) arelegitimate in that instance.

No it is not.

Yes this is exactly what identification is
Now, go check some scientist,you need to learn some stuff.

Uhm, yeah it actually does.

Woman can only produce eggs to be fertilised in their womb. Men can't.

Trans men can and trans men ARE men.
Let's not be transphobe here or this will be a report.

Yeah teaching impressionable children that that is somehow normal or ok is horrible and letting or often urging them go through any kind of hormone treatments before they are even developed enough to comprehend their decisions is child abuse.

Do you really want me to jump on this argument ?

 

[Longleg Larry]

Yamato is female, only because I reject her reasoning

I have 0 respect for a character like Oden

So I refuse to pay any respect to him by acknowledging a character who only wants to be male to further idolize (wank) him

That being said, I wish Kaido had a son

 

[Cross_Marian]

I just have to say two things:
- Yamato is 100% a female
- Avatar 2 sucked

 

[Logiko]

I just have to say two things:
- Yamato is 100% a female
- Avatar 2 sucked

One of those sentences is wrong

 

[Peroroncino]

I just have to say two things:
- Yamato is 100% a female
- Avatar 2 sucked

can't say anything about avatar since i havent watched it but the yamato part is correct

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

Ahh some people are too bored

 

[Reborn]

Wasn't manga stated she is female? Then she is.


She sees herself as oden because she idolize him and only him and not because she wants to a man.

If oden was a woman then her crazy behaviour would still hold true because it's nothing to do with gender but with how a person was.

She is a woman

 

[Hiragaro]

The poll gives me hope that most people are sane and haven’t lost their common sense yet.

 

[Logiko]

She sees herself as oden because she idolize him and only him and not because she wants to a man.

She identify both as a woman and a man so she is both (fluid), end of story.

 

[Reborn]

She identify both as a woman and a man so she is both (fluid), end of story.

In two piece yes

 

[NAMELESS]

boobs means daughter.
[automerge]1676119578[/automerge]

If Yamato is not a girl/daughter, I won't unzip my pants and wanked her 24/7 on the computer.

Jesus.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

boobs means daughter.

When grown naturally. Some dudes have boobs now, surgery is easy, they still dudes though

 

[NAMELESS]

When grown naturally. Some dudes have boobs now, surgery is easy, they still dudes though

Yamato had no surgery.She was born a girl.That is visible on her flashback.
[automerge]1676120325[/automerge]

When grown naturally. Some dudes have boobs now, surgery is easy, they still dudes though

Grown naturally>Fake boobs.Small natural tits>Fake big tits imo

 

[Seatonnes]

Team yamato is a they

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Yamato had no surgery.She was born a girl.That is visible on her flashback.

Yeah I know that, just wanted to say that not everybody with boobs are women in this crazy world. Gotta be careful they're not hiding some dicks under their pants now

 

[NAMELESS]

Yeah I know that, just wanted to say that not everybody with boobs are women in this crazy world. Gotta be careful they're not hiding some dicks under their pants now

yeah lol
[automerge]1676120557[/automerge]

She identify both as a woman and a man so she is both (fluid), end of story.