Controversial Are you on team Yamato is a daughter.

[Hiragaro]

Then.. why are you saying that I'm forcing you to do something when I'm not even in the room with you ?

Wait.. is there someone in the room with you that is forcing you to learn something ?

Forcing your opinion on others doesn't mean physicaly force them you doofus.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Denying the existence of biological women is wild

 

[Reborn]

Denying the existence of biological women is wild

Why are you laughing?

That means he also deny existence of biological man - of you as well.


YOU DON'T EXIST

 

[Emmazrine]

can we lock this now

 

[Reborn]

can we lock this now

No

 

[ShiShiShi]

Why are you laughing?

That means he also deny existence of biological man - of you as well.


YOU DON'T EXIST

 

[Logiko]

I like how this went from being "Are you on team Yamato is a daughter?" To everyone vs CarrotForNakama.

Nothing really surprising as the forum is mostly conservative/confusionnist and with a poor knowledge of social struggle. So I'm doomed here to face constant reactance when I talk about notion like "gender as a social construct", this is normal.

biological women don't exist but trans women want to become them, go figure

They don't want to become them, trans women ARE women.

Lol! Nobody has any problem with Kiku being trans but if Yamato is one, everybody loses their mind.

Oda's the one who came up with these weirdos. He is trad and woke at the same time. Y'all aren't ready for when Oda reveals Luffy is aromantic, Zoro is gay, Nami's a lesbian and Sanji's bi. Couple that with Yamato and we will get all the alphabets in the SHP and Netflix will reboot them with "coming of age story about searching for love and identity".

Learned my lesson with Dumbledore.

The reason is pretty simple: Kiku's passing is quite perfect while Yamato still has boobs and "feminine" identified characteristics.
So, people are far lesss accepting.

I've never made any of these points, and what do they have to do with the fact you deny biological men and women?

Because if gender (man or woman) is a social construct, it can't be biological. Simple enough.

Forcing your opinion on others doesn't mean physicaly force them you doofus.

Look at the thread we are.. let's see.. 8ish and ALL of you are going against ME for saying that gender is a social construct (making fun/irony/insult etc.)

So tell me.. who is in position of domination here ? Who is forcing what on who ?

You see.. you are eiger to say that I'm a "woke" that I'm forcing people to learn something they don't but look at that thread and poll.. where is the hegemony in term of thoughts concerning Yamato ? That she is a woman or that he is a man ?

Now.. who is forcing who ?

can we lock this now

I'm ok with that.

 

[Monkey D. Luffy]

Because if gender (man or woman) is a social construct, it can't be biological. Simple enough.

Man and woman isn't a social construct. If it defines your genitalia (and a assortment of other things like milkers), it is 100% biological.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Why are you laughing?

That means he also deny existence of biological man - of you as well.


YOU DON'T EXIST

That is true

 

[Infitima]

Even ignoring politics and sides.

The fact Yamato only wants to be a man because her idol and 'character' she's playing is a man, makes her reasoning invalid and disqualifies her from the trans thing.

If Oden was an amorphous tentacle monster, Yamato would be an amorphous tentacle monster to herself.

Just because a female otherkin IRL says they're Hitler doesn't suddenly make them a man.

 

[Peroroncino]

Nothing really surprising as the forum is mostly conservative/confusionnist and with a poor knowledge of social struggle. So I'm doomed here to face constant reactance when I talk about notion like "gender as a social construct", this is normal.


They don't want to become them, trans women ARE women.



The reason is pretty simple: Kiku's passing is quite perfect while Yamato still has boobs and "feminine" identified characteristics.
So, people are far lesss accepting.



Because if gender (man or woman) is a social construct, it can't be biological. Simple enough.



Look at the thread we are.. let's see.. 8ish and ALL of you are going against ME for saying that gender is a social construct (making fun/irony/insult etc.)

So tell me.. who is in position of domination here ? Who is forcing what on who ?

You see.. you are eiger to say that I'm a "woke" that I'm forcing people to learn something they don't but look at that thread and poll.. where is the hegemony in term of thoughts concerning Yamato ? That she is a woman or that he is a man ?

Now.. who is forcing who ?



I'm ok with that.

if there's no need to become, then no need to dress like them or for surgery

 

[Reborn]

That is true

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Thanks

 

[Hiragaro]

Look at the thread we are.. let's see.. 8ish and ALL of you are going against ME for saying that gender is a social construct (making fun/irony/insult etc.)

So tell me.. who is in position of domination here ? Who is forcing what on who ?

You see.. you are eiger to say that I'm a "woke" that I'm forcing people to learn something they don't but look at that thread and poll.. where is the hegemony in term of thoughts concerning Yamato ? That she is a woman or that she is a man ?

Now.. who is forcing who ?

The majority of people here disagreeing with you - is not called forcing their opinion on you.
I didn't see a single comment that threatend you with report if you don't agree with them.
But you do exactly that. You threaten people with reports if they don't agree with you - that is forcing your opinion on others.

 

[NikaInParis]

So that's why the politics thread has been calm and civil these last few days?! This guy is threadbanned

Mods...good?

 

[Emmazrine]

Nothing really surprising as the forum is mostly conservative/confusionnist and with a poor knowledge of social struggle. So I'm doomed here to face constant reactance when I talk about notion like "gender as a social construct", this is normal.


They don't want to become them, trans women ARE women.



The reason is pretty simple: Kiku's passing is quite perfect while Yamato still has boobs and "feminine" identified characteristics.
So, people are far lesss accepting.



Because if gender (man or woman) is a social construct, it can't be biological. Simple enough.



Look at the thread we are.. let's see.. 8ish and ALL of you are going against ME for saying that gender is a social construct (making fun/irony/insult etc.)

So tell me.. who is in position of domination here ? Who is forcing what on who ?

You see.. you are eiger to say that I'm a "woke" that I'm forcing people to learn something they don't but look at that thread and poll.. where is the hegemony in term of thoughts concerning Yamato ? That she is a woman or that he is a man ?

Now.. who is forcing who ?



I'm ok with that.

honestly i can see your intention is good which is acknowledging trans people but i disagree with some of your take regarding the whole issue.however i don't want to see you getting mob ganged here so you should leave imo. peace

 

[NikaInParis]

honestly i can see your intention is good which is acknowledging trans people but i disagree with some of your take regarding the whole issue.however i don't want to see you getting mob ganged here so you should leave imo. peace

Your intentions are good but it's in vain, he considers himself a warrior of truth so he won't stop until people are exhausted from replying to his cyclic no-answer answers

 

[Hiragaro]

Me having brown hair is also not biological, it's just a social construct.
I guess i have to ask my hair what color they identify as

 

[DarkWitch]

Nothing really surprising as the forum is mostly conservative/confusionnist and with a poor knowledge of social struggle. So I'm doomed here to face constant reactance when I talk about notion like "gender as a social construct", this is normal.


They don't want to become them, trans women ARE women.

The users on this forum is not the problem, the problem is you.

No offense but you are nothing more than a joke.

 

[ShiShiShi]

@Doggo can we lock the thread and finally be free from this never ending debate?