Versus Battle Best Mangaka Battle

[Light D Lamperouge]

HxH comes on top if the list was for most overrated series/ mangaka ever, but unfortunately that's not the case here.

Say it ain't so Larry. Why are people gassing it up so much then?

 

[ShinmenTakezo]

Say it ain't so Larry. Why are people gassing it up so much then?

Because edgy.

 

[Monster Luffy]

JJK is overrated. There is nothing original about it. It is a mix of Naruto and Bleach. You can feel neither good nor bad about it. Watch it for timepass.

 

[Marimo_420]

Say it ain't so Larry. Why are people gassing it up so much then?

It's got a pre established proper power structure not usually shown in Shounen and some high stakes, and that's about it. I don't know how people were brain washed into thinking HxH was top tier just because it was slightly more realistic than the big three.

This turd of a manga got carried by It's anime adaptation in 2011 which was animated via Madhouse. And let's be real here. Even Udon arc would look god tier if Mad House was on One piece.

The actual source- the manga, has drawings that can be surpassed by people's farts, and the author is often sat there treating his fanbase as children.

He reiterates everything, even the pre established power structure every 5 chapters, (don't know if it's to refresh himself, or he thinks his readers are retards) and he has more text per page than most best sellers.

It's mediocrecy at It's finest.

 

[PerfectHie]

Man, this is really tough since I love literally every mangaka up there lol but if I had to choose, I'd pick:

• Tatsuki Fujimoto - I loved CSM, like I absolutely loved it to the point that I immediately read Fire Punch and also really enjoyed that series. Hands down one of my all time favs.
• Tite Kubo - Bleach. Nuff said.
• Yoshihiro Togashi (how tf is he not on the list @Light D Lamperouge ) but him too. HxH and YYH will go down as some of the best series of all time.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

how tf is he not on the list @Light D Lamperouge )

He's 9th on the list.

 

[PerfectHie]

He's 9th on the list.

Apologies, I couldn't find him

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Apologies, I couldn't find him

No worries.

Post automatically merged: Oct 9, 2021

Tatsuki Fujimoto - I loved CSM, like I absolutely loved it to the point that I immediately read Fire Punch and also really enjoyed that series. Hands down one of my all time favs.

Also if you liked CSM, I'd recommend checking out Dandadan, made by Fujimoto's assistant, and Jigokuraku, again made by one of Fujimoto's assistants.

 

[Dark Admiral]

Black Clover and MHA getting crushed.... lol

 

[dizzy2341]

Too hard to pick a definitive favourite so I just voted for everyone worthy of the title GOAT for one reason or another. Some of my favourties would be:

Miura
Kishimoto
Fujimoto
Gotouge
Hara

Black Clover and MHA getting crushed.... lol

Ain't no one got time for trash Tabata especially just lucky that his series still running. In another time, mid clover would've seen that axe long ago.

 

[Formerly Seth]

Black Clover and MHA getting crushed.... lol

Well. I like BC but Tabata doesn't hold the candle to likes of Hara, Togashi.

Still better than Horikoshi and Gotouge.

 

[Steven]

@Seth
Oda has the second highest score in the poll

 

[Formerly Seth]

@Seth
Oda has the second highest score in the poll

I said it above. Not surprising since we are on the one piece oriented. But yeah it's so fucking funny.

Dude doesn't hold a candle to Togashi, Hara and Miura.

Gege Akutami is killing it too.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Black Clover and MHA getting crushed.... lol

Honestly it's not surprising lol. I like BC and MHA somewhat as well, but they are nothing special, extraordinary or great. They are popular and have characters that are beloved though.

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Miura, Inoue and Hara are the best choices imo.

Berserk had top notch art, fights, story-telling and character development.

Vagabond is a masterpiece, and I've heard good things about Slam Dunk too.

Hara has been dropping nothing but fire for almost 700 chapters since 2006, Kingdom's art quality is absolutely insane for a weekly manga.

Araki also has been drawing Jojo since the eighties, and his fights are among the most creative in manga.

Pre Time Skip Oda is one of the better shonen mangakas, but Post Time Skip Oda doesn't deserve half that many votes lol.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Saw a lot of people claiming One Piece is down bad recently so I was wondering if they still think Oda is one of the best if not the best mangaka out there.




@Monkey D Theories @lee33 your thoughts?

 

[RayanOO]

Saw a lot of people claiming One Piece is down bad recently so I was wondering if they still think Oda is one of the best if not the best mangaka out there.




@Monkey D Theories @lee33 your thoughts?

Haha you’re mean

 

[Lhulu]

Saw a lot of people claiming One Piece is down bad recently so I was wondering if they still think Oda is one of the best if not the best mangaka out there.




@Monkey D Theories @lee33 your thoughts?

Oh, you're bringing an interesting stuff Light

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Haha you’re mean

Never Rayan chan.

Oh, you're bringing an interesting stuff Light

Has your opinion changed Thururu?

 

[Kagumon]

Out of the list, I think Togashi has a big chance of winning. Whatever he has written in HxH so far is still top notch.

But he isn't active so a few points lost here.