Best OP Panel/Doublespread Tournment Round 3

[GUI VI]

Already voted. But I say the Wyper/Zoro one shouldn't be there. It only had 12 votes last round, yet you gave it the second chance because it's Zoro obviously, when there were other panels that were closer to tie.

Your post just doesn't make any sense lol.

It's unsportsmanlike for the host to give a chance because of favoritism, but also.....

Yes, Zoro/Wiper panel had 12 votes in the round and other panels had more, but the decision was made based on the sum of the Round's Votes 2+Brackets. Let me show you:
- Zoro/Wiper panel got 12+25=37
- Law/Chopper panel got 12+23=35
- Merry panel got 13+16=29
- The Admirals panel got 12+21=33
- Akainu panel got 11+21= 32
- Blackbeard panel got 16+19=35

The panel with the HIGHEST VOTE NUMBER(ROUND 2+BRACKETS) is:

Zoro/Wiper panel :)

 

[Moegara]

Your post just doesn't make any sense lol.

It's unsportsmanlike for the host to give a chance because of favoritism, but also.....

Yes, Zoro/Wiper panel had 12 votes in the round and other panels had more, but the decision was made based on the sum of the Round's Votes 2+Brackets. Let me show you:
- Zoro/Wiper panel got 12+25=37
- Law/Chopper panel got 12+23=35
- Merry panel got 13+16=29
- The Admirals panel got 12+21=33
- Akainu panel got 11+21= 32
- Blackbeard panel got 16+19=35

The panel with the HIGHEST VOTE NUMBER(ROUND 2+BRACKETS) is:

Zoro/Wiper panel :)

 

[GUI VI]

What??

 

[Moegara]

What??

Nothing. I didn't get what's being added but that's on me.

 

[Goodman Grey]

What??

We want the Kokoro double page spread back.

 

[Infitima]

Nothing. I didn't get what's being added but that's on me.

He's adding up how many votes it got its first turn, with its second turn.

The issue here, is that no matter how you do it it's going to be bias. Because its votes depended on its opponent.

In its first round, it was up against a more boring panel so most figured they had no other choice, and being Zoro, so it got a lot and moved on.
In its second it was against a better panel that even being Zoro didn't save it, so it didn't move on.

This time it's a more even match, but because it's Zoro it's getting more.

But that's the whole tournament so far, and you can't get away from bias.

The only way he could have made it true fairness is if he had had the Zoro panel 1 go against Zoro panel 2, so 'favorite character' boost wouldn't have applied.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Your post just doesn't make any sense lol.

It's unsportsmanlike for the host to give a chance because of favoritism, but also.....

Yes, Zoro/Wiper panel had 12 votes in the round and other panels had more, but the decision was made based on the sum of the Round's Votes 2+Brackets. Let me show you:
- Zoro/Wiper panel got 12+25=37
- Law/Chopper panel got 12+23=35
- Merry panel got 13+16=29
- The Admirals panel got 12+21=33
- Akainu panel got 11+21= 32
- Blackbeard panel got 16+19=35

The panel with the HIGHEST VOTE NUMBER(ROUND 2+BRACKETS) is:

Zoro/Wiper panel :)

BB or Merry panel should have advanced
You're a Zorotard

 

[GUI VI]

BB or Merry panel should have advanced
You're a Zorotard

 

[Infitima]

Honestly, because of that bias (why didn't you just have the two Zoro panels against each other if you gave it a second chance?)

If that panel passes again, I'm done voting and dropping the next rounds.

 

[straightforward]

If that panel passes again, I'm done voting and dropping the next rounds.

suit yourself.

i will be voting for the puppy on a mossy rock

 

[Infitima]

suit yourself.

i will be voting for the puppy on a mossy rock

I like tournaments to be fair, instead of rigged for bias.

 

[straightforward]

I like tournaments to be fair, instead of rigged for bias.

i think the solution was absolutely fair and transparent.

then again, i'm a zoro hater who voted for almost every zoro spread in this tournament because i can separate my hatred of a particular character from the objective drawing skill, sense of style, sense of composition and color matching that any given spread is showcasing

 

[Infitima]

i think the solution was absolutely fair and transparent.

then again, i'm a zoro hater who voted for almost every zoro spread in this tournament because i can separate my hatred of a particular character from the objective drawing skill, sense of style, sense of composition and color matching that any given spread is showcasing

I voted for every panel that I thought looked epic, and had good composition and emotion.

But I'm not going to vote for a panel that was already out that's only winning now because it gets a 'favorite character' boost, when it should have been against the same character to avoid such boost. Zoro has nothing to do with it, avoiding a character popularity contest instead of actually judging the panel is the complaint.

 

[straightforward]

I voted for every panel that I thought looked epic, and had good composition and emotion.

But I'm not going to vote for a panel that was already out that's only winning now because it gets a 'favorite character' boost, when it should have been against the same character to avoid such boost. Zoro has nothing to do with it, avoiding a character popularity contest instead of actually judging the panel is the complaint.

you are free to host your own tournament where you follow the principles listed above.

 

[NikaInParis]

This should've ended 30 mins ago, right?

 

[GUI VI]

This should've ended 30 mins ago, right?

I extended the time because there was a tie in R2 and R3, there is still a tie in R2.