Speculations Blackbeard Top 3 commanders

who is in the top 3?

  • Avalo pizaro

    Votes: 57 52.3%

  • shiryuu

    Votes: 101 92.7%

  • laffite

    Votes: 42 38.5%

  • burgess

    Votes: 45 41.3%

  • van augur

    Votes: 15 13.8%

  • doc Q

    Votes: 3 2.8%

  • devon

    Votes: 7 6.4%

  • sanjuan wolf

    Votes: 4 3.7%

  • vasco shot

    Votes: 17 15.6%

  • the mysterious tenth titanic commander

    Votes: 18 16.5%
  • Total voters
    109
Garp the Fist

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
‎
#61
#61
Jew D. Boy said:
Who do you put above him, then? I saw your thoughts about this earlier in the thread and you seem to be on board with Burgess and Shiryu taking the top two spots; I could see any of the Level 6 recruits staking a claim, even Devon (since we know little about her DF powers), but Augur’s been around a lot longer and, by your own admission, would be powerful enough to kill another presumptive high ranking YC, so why would that preclude him from being one of Teach’s top 3?
Click to expand...
I don't really think snipers fit into tier systems.

Auger could be the YC3 from one perspective- sniping- but in a more regular fight be significantly weaker than the other YC's. Much like Usopp.

The problem is this "YC3" designation. Yasopp is Shanks' YC3. I think this then makes people think he can go toe to toe with Jack or Cracker. I don't think that's the case at all. Yasopp and Auger, much like Usopp, will have one area they completely excel in, but aren't really "real" fighters. If anything, they should try and be as far away from their opponent as possible.

So, I can see in series Auger being considered Blackbeard's third. Much like I can see Usopp being considered Luffy's third, as much as it pains me because of what it would mean for Jinbei- no offence to Usopp, who I also love, but Jinbei is my man.

But if we were then to put these characters in the arena, they'd lose most fights unless we're to give them a massive advantage of being like an island away from their opponent, who is unaware of them. Because that's simply how a sniper really excels.
 
Lunaria

Lunaria

‎
#64
#64
Jew D. Boy said:
Hard to believe, and also not what I’m saying. Augur being the third strongest in Teach’s crew and Usopp being the weakest in Luffy’s are not mutually exclusive; they’re likely to be matched up because of the sniper aspect, and at some point or another, all the SHP are gonna need to be strong enough to fight people like the Ten Titanic Captains If we’re to take them seriously as a PK-level crew. Whether or not Usopp is a top tier among the Straw Hats is not what we’re discussing here.
Click to expand...
I don’t see that happen, to be honest. I think EoS Usopp’s strength has to be taken into account to properly gage one of his last opponents’ strength. I have a hard time believing he will be strong enough to defeat one of BB’s top 3. So I’d say Van Augur will be top 4 in best case scenario, most likely top5/6.

We should also take their bounties into consideration. I know they’re not the be-all and end-all when it comes to gage characters’ strength but they’re generally a good way to rank the antagonists in terms of strength. Van Augur had only a bounty of 64 million before the timeskip, which is nothing compared to former level 6 prisoners’ bounties. Even Doc Q had a higher bounty.
 
Lunaria

Lunaria

‎
#66
#66
Garp the Fist said:
I don't really think snipers fit into tier systems.

Auger could be the YC3 from one perspective- sniping- but in a more regular fight be significantly weaker than the other YC's. Much like Usopp.

The problem is this "YC3" designation. Yasopp is Shanks' YC3. I think this then makes people think he can go toe to toe with Jack or Cracker. I don't think that's the case at all. Yasopp and Auger, much like Usopp, will have one area they completely excel in, but aren't really "real" fighters. If anything, they should try and be as far away from their opponent as possible.

So, I can see in series Auger being considered Blackbeard's third. Much like I can see Usopp being considered Luffy's third, as much as it pains me because of what it would mean for Jinbei- no offence to Usopp, who I also love, but Jinbei is my man.

But if we were then to put these characters in the arena, they'd lose most fights unless we're to give them a massive advantage of being like an island away from their opponent, who is unaware of them. Because that's simply how a sniper really excels.
Click to expand...
Hum, I’ve never seen it that way but that actually makes sense.
 
J

JoNdule

‎
#78
#78
Shiryu
Lafitte
Burgess

Just look at Shiryu and Lafitte furst introduction post Ts when they talk to Burgess
It is basically another King / Queen screen with Jack or Macro/Jozu intro
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top