He reads to me like paranoid town that has gotten stuck on a detail. He did the same with me in a recent game when we were in a private chat, no matter how much I explained it to him he could not get past it. Even after I'd gotten past the issues I had with his claim which, as it turns out, was a lie on his part anyway. So I would say, don't apply strictly logical standards when evaluating him, because he can and does go to the extreme of getting hung up on minor details that he perceives as a contradiction, something which I don't believe he would bother with as scum.