Do you want this phase and those onward to be majority lynch?

  • Yes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • We want Plurality with hammer option.

    Votes: 8 100.0%

  • Total voters
    8
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Who do you believe we should be cross examining?
I've just told you? I'm asking what the basis is for each clear, because if every other slot is solved and it really is just Tyki and I left, then the game is as good as solved and no further thinking needed. If, however, some of the clears are tenuous, then that's worth due consideration before locking into "it's one of Ratchet or Tyki".

To be more specific - what clears Alexis? What clears Hayumi? I'm not even sure exactly who is alive because the majority says 9 but I can only count 8.

Tepig - cleared
Red Night - Known
Destroya - well you know your role, but what specifically clears you?
Hayumi - listed above
Alexis - listed above
Ratchet - PoE
Tyki - PoE

That's it? Who is missing? Ultra I guess but he's game removed.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Because from my perspective I'm not exactly convinced Tyki is scum. Purely on read I would lean otherwise actually, but that's probably not worth much at this point. Nevertheless, I'm not going to pretend like he must be scum if I don't even know why the PoE is what it is. With at least 2 scum alive and possibly only 7 votes in play (though majority says 9) we really only have about 2 safe lynches (potentially a third but not a guarantee).
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Ah Orca replaced Ultra, probably a good thing they stay removed. Does mean if whomever removed them dies then they come back with 3 Mafia which is basically gg. Meh.
 
Some interesting posts from Ratchet.

I don't have one. I saw what you said about him thinking yiure town for scun reading Ultra despite him replacing Ultra, so I can see your angle. Also think his vote on me was pretty weak but in his defence he didn't really try to defend it. If you're confident he's scum then he's in that pile where I would be happy to support the wagon but I have no pressing conviction within it.
This is a post about Orca.

Melkor I think at the time was not batting things down that I'd expect him too, he looked happy to just let whatever fly. Not so strong on it now as I kind of like him tagging me asking about you, and at least seems consistent.

Michelle in the small sample I had seemed fine when I engaged with her. I can reconcile her as just being busy.

Tykki because in my experience with them, which isn't much prior unless I'm mixing them up, they were low activity coasters. In this case, a few posts I saw looked like they were trying.

Muugen because as scum I think he would have an obligation to try a bit more, I remember him doing so recently. So him shutting down entirely because of your presence I think is sort of townie for him.

Naomi I think generally has come across as townie and her focus on scum hunting through activity is standard fare for her as town. Also she says you vouch for her now so I'm even more confident.

AM is hard to explain, just felt like his posts are geared towards an outcome rather than the usual trolling he does as town.
A reads list where he has favorable and progressive reads on Melkor and Michelle.

I don't think it really makes sense for either to lie. Maybe Alexis would though.

Unvote
He unvotes Orca after listening to Crowned.

I don't really think Crowned is the way to go but haven't been keeping up. Maybe I should just use all my shots, I'm never going to be able to even keep current at this rate.

If anyone can tag me with a quick rundown of the wagons and why that would be grand.
Ratchet saying Crowned isn't the way to go.
 
Now, if Ratchet flips Haschwaltch, we got to decide who to vote first, Orca or Red Night. I am hoping that Red Night just dies when Orca dies. Considering The Miracle, the ability keeping Red Night alive, was given to Gerard by Yhwach, it should die when Yhwach does, and since he's already dead, he should just die. So I'd say lynch Orca first.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Now, if Ratchet flips Haschwaltch, we got to decide who to vote first, Orca or Red Night. I am hoping that Red Night just dies when Orca dies. Considering The Miracle, the ability keeping Red Night alive, was given to Gerard by Yhwach, it should die when Yhwach does, and since he's already dead, he should just die. So I'd say lynch Orca first.
This is obviously a best case assumption and it's not going to be the case. So what happens after I flip town? Is it just Tyki and then nothing else? Or is there any lingering doubt on anybslot that I can at least serve as a sounding board for before I'm lynched?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top