General & Others Compiling a list of Wano Criticisms

Fujishiro

Cheese for everyone!
And you’re ignoring character-defining panels for the sake of creating a version of Kaido that does not exist.
What do you mean? I’m sorry I didn’t read your entire post because I’m in class rn, I’ll get back to you on it man.
[automerge]1613583182[/automerge]
smiling doesn't mean anything idk what you're trying to say? I have seen boxers smile when they get knocked down
He litteraly said 2 chapters ago he’s having fun.
 

Fujishiro

Cheese for everyone!
my question is what does having fun have to do with anything? you just gonna make headcannon and say he was automatically holding back and not trying because he said fun? its kinda sad when you think about it he has another yonko helping him
If he’s having fun and laughing then logic dictates that he’s not scare or terrorized. The burden of proof is on you mate. Never talked about holding back btw. Seems like these people and arguments live rent free inside your head.
 
It’s the same criticism though. If Kaido can’t take it when the scabbards give him paper cuts, how does he expect to endure it when Shanks cuts his head off? Or when Akainu blows his brains out?

A dude who is already screaming in pain from minor wounds won’t want anything to do with the big bois. He’ll be crying himself all the way to Impel Down.

And it’s also like I said earlier: Akainu gritted his teeth through island shattering blows to the head and stomach, Shanks didn’t flinch when his arm got taken off, Ace got a hole blown clean through his chest but didn’t react to it...,

But Kaido screams in pain when Kinemon cuts his lip??? There’s an inconsistency here. Kaido is too big of a bitch to be craving these large scale wars. His ambition is inconsistent with his actual character. He has the ambition of a warmonger but the demeanor of a coward.

With Big Mom and Teach, screaming in pain makes sense. Teach isn’t a warmonger, he wants to get to the top of the world through dirty pirate schemes, and plus he takes additional damage from his Devil Fruit. Big Mom at heart is a child who has never been disciplined, it is literally woven into her character that she doesn’t know how to deal with pain or adversity,

With Kaido, he’s just a complete failure and there’s no way around it. There is no way for a flashback to justify how inconsistent he is.



How exactly? Lmfao, all we’ve gotten from him since the start of the raid is cliched fanfic dialogue like “muh durability” and “how is this possible?”

Literally nothing about Kaido has improved since the raid began. All we’ve gotten since then is horrible dialogue and him screaming in pain left and right.
I made a thread speculating on this, that Kaido use to be weakling prior to eating his devil fruit, and the reason he sought out so many people to fight, and rise to the top on his strength is because he was looking for validation after being looked down upon during his early years.
 
If he’s having fun and laughing then logic dictates that he’s not scare or terrorized. The burden of proof is on you mate. Never talked about holding back btw. Seems like these people and arguments live rent free inside your head.

Yes, and also has killing intent against the 5
having fun means hes just enjoying the fight and its not boring as he expected it, good thing papazuki woulda blew his face already with a mid diff in his hyrbid
[automerge]1613583857[/automerge]
I made a thread speculating on this, that Kaido use to be weakling prior to eating his devil fruit, and the reason he sought out so many people to fight, and rise to the top on his strength is because he was looking for validation after being looked down upon during his early years.
Well um, you're right lol, thats all he did
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
I made a thread speculating on this, that Kaido use to be weakling prior to eating his devil fruit, and the reason he sought out so many people to fight, and rise to the top on his strength is because he was looking for validation after being looked down upon during his early years.
But wouldnt all the ass whuppings he got make him hardened ?
Instead we got what looks like a guy who hasnt been touched in 20 years since oden who freaks out every single time someone can get past his scales.
 
But wouldnt all the ass whuppings he got make him hardened ?
Instead we got what looks like a guy who hasnt been touched in 20 years since oden who freaks out every single time someone can get past his scales.
Makes sense he freaks out or is surprised tbh.

The number of ***** that bypassed his scales numbered only 4 or 5.

Now all of a sudden all 9 of Oden's underlings and upstart pirates he's whooped the ass of/looked down on are hurting him.
 
I made a thread speculating on this, that Kaido use to be weakling prior to eating his devil fruit, and the reason he sought out so many people to fight, and rise to the top on his strength is because he was looking for validation after being looked down upon during his early years.
:kaidowhat:
Kaido was apprentice in rocks crew.....which is one of the most hostile crews there are.......they were constantly killing each other...normal apprentice can't even survive imo......the fact he was allowed/part of the crew is a testament to his potential..........whitebeard mentioned to oden how everyone were conquerors also...this was before he ate his devil fruit....
 
But wouldnt all the ass whuppings he got make him hardened ?
Instead we got what looks like a guy who hasnt been touched in 20 years since oden who freaks out every single time someone can get past his scales.
Not really if you hadn't experienced pain all that often in almost 40 years. Remember, God's Valley happened 39 years ago, and that's when Kaido got his devil fruit. It's been much longer than 20 years since Kaido has consistently felt pain.
[automerge]1613585251[/automerge]
:kaidowhat:
Kaido was apprentice in rocks crew.....which is one of the most hostile crews there are.......they were constantly killing each other...normal apprentice can't even survive imo......the fact he was allowed/part of the crew is a testament to his potential..........whitebeard mentioned to oden how everyone were conquerors also...this was before he ate his devil fruit....
He probably did have the potential to become a Monster on his own, but was given a free pass to help him become drastically stronger via his Devil Fruit. In my thread I liken the Big Mom/Kaido/Rocks situation to the Alvida/Coby situation in the beginning of the series. Coby is going on to become strong on his own accord, despite being an utter weakling in the beginning of the series. Kaido could have done the same, but was given a helping hand via his Devil Fruit.
 
Last edited:
It’s the same criticism though. If Kaido can’t take it when the scabbards give him paper cuts, how does he expect to endure it when Shanks cuts his head off? Or when Akainu blows his brains out?

A dude who is already screaming in pain from minor wounds won’t want anything to do with the big bois. He’ll be crying himself all the way to Impel Down.

And it’s also like I said earlier: Akainu gritted his teeth through island shattering blows to the head and stomach, Shanks didn’t flinch when his arm got taken off, Ace got a hole blown clean through his chest but didn’t react to it...,

But Kaido screams in pain when Kinemon cuts his lip??? There’s an inconsistency here. Kaido is too big of a bitch to be craving these large scale wars. His ambition is inconsistent with his actual character. He has the ambition of a warmonger but the demeanor of a coward.

With Big Mom and Teach, screaming in pain makes sense. Teach isn’t a warmonger, he wants to get to the top of the world through dirty pirate schemes, and plus he takes additional damage from his Devil Fruit. Big Mom at heart is a child who has never been disciplined, it is literally woven into her character that she doesn’t know how to deal with pain or adversity,

With Kaido, he’s just a complete failure and there’s no way around it. There is no way for a flashback to justify how inconsistent he is.



How exactly? Lmfao, all we’ve gotten from him since the start of the raid is cliched fanfic dialogue like “muh durability” and “how is this possible?”

Literally nothing about Kaido has improved since the raid began. All we’ve gotten since then is horrible dialogue and him screaming in pain left and right.
One time Zoro had a piece of a pain cake and it ruined him, but he literally beat up his buddy to get a shot at eating the whole thing
 
Not really if you hadn't experienced pain all that often in almost 40 years. Remember, God's Valley happened 39 years ago, and that's when Kaido got his devil fruit. It's been much longer than 20 years since Kaido has consistently felt pain.
[automerge]1613585251[/automerge]


He probably did have the potential to become a Monster on his own, but was given a free pass to help him become drastically stronger via his Devil Fruit. In my thread I liken the Big Mom/Kaido/Rocks situation to the Alvida/Coby situation in the beginning of the series. Coby is going on to become strong on his own accord, despite being an utter weakling in the beginning of the series. Kaido could have done the same, but was given a helping hand via his Devil Fruit.
Dude kaido has to be a monster even at a young age just to be in rocks crew...base kaido is ridiculously strong...if anything only taking his dragon form into account....it made him weaker....base kaido baby shaked luffy.
Even without DF he could have mastered adv haki as it so easy to learn....20 years ago wounded base kaido using a no name attack K.O.ed oden...oden easily tanked boro breath.....his df hindered him more I will say....If it wasn't for his hybrid I would say his df is a nerf if anything...

He could have eaten much better df. And most of the top-tiers have df--admirals/ 3 yonkos -BM/WB/BB....you can say the same about them too:kayneshrug: just saying....
 
Last edited:
- Prison becomes training camp and its double standard. Queen lets Luffy train with fodders while he almost kills Kids and Killer from drowning
- No Strawhat cares that Luffy got captured as if they know Luffy has plot convenience and won't be killed. They should gather and rescue Luffy like Enies Lobbies
- Luffy got teacher to counter Kaido out of the blue
- Enma is a bit much. This sword has the same grade with Wado and Susui, but in reality seems to be much better
- Sanji use RS against his will in order to peek women naked
- Tama's hard counter to beast pirate is lame
- BM amnesia is also lame
- The war has no tension
- Gifters/numbers got one shot. I don't feel that the beast pirate is scary
 
- Prison becomes training camp and its double standard. Queen lets Luffy train with fodders while he almost kills Kids and Killer from drowning
- No Strawhat cares that Luffy got captured as if they know Luffy has plot convenience and won't be killed. They should gather and rescue Luffy like Enies Lobbies
- Luffy got teacher to counter Kaido out of the blue
- Enma is a bit much. This sword has the same grade with Wado and Susui, but in reality seems to be much better
- Tama's hard counter to beast pirate is lame
- BM amnesia is also lame
- The war has no tension
- Gifters/numbers got one shot. I don't feel that the beast pirate is scary.
- didn't Queen let them live, same as Luffy? Kidd had broken out and Killer had failed his mission. Those conditions were death. Luffy tried getting out but didn't so it's not the same

- when was Luffy jailed in EL?

- Zoro is much better. First high level fight he's had all timeskip

- Tama was captured and exploited before Luffy saved her so she's more a plot device than a real counter. Now she is allied with three pirates worth 360 million so she's pretty hard to deal with as one would expect. Sugar pulled the same shit and all she had was Booger Man.

- amnesia has been gone for six volumes

- a single Gifter isn't much. An army of them is a problem. Two of them wrecked Sanji in one go
 
Dude kaido has to be a monster even at a young age just to be in rocks crew...base kaido is ridiculously strong...if anything only taking his dragon form into account....it made him weaker....base kaido baby shaked luffy.
Even without DF he could have mastered adv haki as it so easy to learn....20 years ago wounded base kaido using a no name attack K.O.ed oden...oden easily tanked boro breath.....his df hindered him more I will say....If it wasn't for his hybrid I would say his df is a nerf if anything...

He could have eaten much better df. And most of the top-tiers have df--admirals/ 3 yonkos -BM/WB/BB....you can say the same about them too:kayneshrug: just saying....
Well yeah, now Kaido as a fighter is ridiculously strong, and he would be that way with or without his Devil Fruit. But I think 13-15 year old, non devil fruit Kaido was probably weak, or at least weaker than the likes of other strong characters at that age.. He could have gotten stronger on his own, but his devil fruit helped him to achieve that much quicker. That's why I likened his and Big Mom's scenario to Alvida/Coby in my thread. Coby wanted to become stronger, and was inspired by Luffy to do so. Kaido wanted to become stronger, and Big Mom gave him a means to do so. The devil fruit just helped him achieve what he wanted faster.
 
- didn't Queen let them live, same as Luffy? Kidd had broken out and Killer had failed his mission. Those conditions were death. Luffy tried getting out but didn't so it's not the same

- when was Luffy jailed in EL?

- Zoro is much better. First high level fight he's had all timeskip

- Tama was captured and exploited before Luffy saved her so she's more a plot device than a real counter. Now she is allied with three pirates worth 360 million so she's pretty hard to deal with as one would expect. Sugar pulled the same shit and all she had was Booger Man.

- amnesia has been gone for six volumes

- a single Gifter isn't much. An army of them is a problem. Two of them wrecked Sanji in one go
- Queen does not put Kids in fighting arena with teacher to train
- I mean what Strawhats did for Robin in EL
- The plot is too focus on Enma. Two yonkos and scabbards are afraid of sword. No one did this to Wado and Sushui even they have the same grade. Zoro is much better is right but I don't know how you use this against my statement.
- Tama direct counter still lame and plot convenient. Whether she got exploited or not is irrelevant. I prefer the war to has more tension and strawhats & alliance struggle through disadvantage (like what CP0 described). Tama just broke that tension out of the blue.
- amnesia situation is in Wano even it happened 6 volume ago. What is your point?
 

Adam 🍎

Pretty Boy
Well yeah, now Kaido as a fighter is ridiculously strong, and he would be that way with or without his Devil Fruit. But I think 13-15 year old, non devil fruit Kaido was probably weak, or at least weaker than the likes of other strong characters at that age.. He could have gotten stronger on his own, but his devil fruit helped him to achieve that much quicker. That's why I likened his and Big Mom's scenario to Alvida/Coby in my thread. Coby wanted to become stronger, and was inspired by Luffy to do so. Kaido wanted to become stronger, and Big Mom gave him a means to do so. The devil fruit just helped him achieve what he wanted faster.
so basically Blackbeard since we saw BB being an orphan or smth like that
 
Top