General & Others Cross Guild will not do anything, that’s the point

ImmaIvanoM

ImmaIvanoM

‎
#1
#1
To be more specific, Cross guild isn’t allowed to do anything.

if they do something then the gag is no longer a gag.

The gag is that Buggy FAILS upwards. He gets what he wants UNINTENTIONALLY. Buggy never actually has a successful plan. If he did then it wouldn’t be funny anymore. Then buggy would become a competent mastermind rivaling Teach. But he’s not. He a buffoon who gets lucky.


So Cross Guild will NOT actually reach Laugh tale through Buggy’s actual plans or actually fighting anyone for poneglyphs or whatever. If they did any of this then they are no longer a gag organization. Then they would immediately turn into an actual serious organization.

In fact since it’s just Three people, this would automatically make them the most impressive organization in the verse for having reached Laugh tale with just 3 people in like 2 months. That’s ridiculous. Do you see? It undermines the entire verse for 3 people to reach laugh tale in 2 months of EVEN deciding to go to Laugh tale. Unless it a gag. If they reach laugh tale through gag logic then that’s all it is, gags.


So none of that will happen. Cross Guild cannot actually be competent because they competence would mess with the gag that Buggy achieves everything by dumb luck. And yes, this means Crocodile and Mihawk will follow in Buggy’s gag. There will be no master plan from Crocodile that gets them to Laugh tale. Mihawk will not fight anyone to get poneglyphs. No, Buggy is going to get Cross Guild to Laugh tale purely on Gag power incompetence and dumb luck.
 
ImmaIvanoM

ImmaIvanoM

‎
#6
#6
Dragon777 said:
They are connected to Buggy's gag, but that doesn't mean they won't do anything.
Click to expand...
But if they do something then it stops being a gag

Think about it. If 3 people genuinely are capable of reaching laugh tale in just 2 months of even trying to reach it, then what does that say about THE ENTIRE REST OF THE UNIVERSE?

Either entire rest of the verse is extremely incompetent or Cross guild is single handed my the most impressive organization in the verse. Just 3 fucking people too.

Unless of course Cross Guild reaches laugh tale through gag power and dumb luck
 
D

Dragon777

‎
#7
#7
ImmaIvanoM said:
But if they do something then it stops being a gag

Think about it. If 3 people genuinely are capable of reaching laugh tale in just 2 months of even trying to reach it, then what does that say about THE ENTIRE REST OF THE UNIVERSE?

Either entire rest of the verse is extremely incompetent or Cross guild is single handed my the most impressive organization in the verse. Just 3 fucking people too.

Unless of course Cross Guild reaches laugh tale through gag power and dumb luck
Click to expand...
Idk how It will play out but even in the past Buggy did things: he did go to MF, he did partecipate in the war, he did talk to Shanks and so on.

Now, for example, Marine vs CG on some level Is happening for sure and I am sure Buggy Is at least surpassing Shanks' bounty.

Also I don't think they'll remain alone. Weevil Is coming too.
 
Last edited:
ImmaIvanoM

ImmaIvanoM

‎
#9
#9
Dragon777 said:
Idk how It will play out but even in the past Buggy did things: he did go to MF, he did partecipate in the war, he did talk to Shanks and so on.

Now, for example, Marine vs CG in on some level happening for sure and I am sure Buggy Is at least surpassing Shanks' bounty.

Also I don't think they'll remain alone. Weevil Is coming too.
Click to expand...
Going to Marineford isn’t what got Buggy the warlord position. Him lying about being the mastermind of Impel down did.

Marines vs CG won’t happen because Cross guild would lose. And cross guild can’t lose because Buggy has to reach laugh tale.


Cross guild adding more people would matter ONLY IF buggy stopped being the leader. Get it? As long their leader is a gag character, they remain a gag organization
 
D

Dragon777

‎
#10
#10
ImmaIvanoM said:
Going to Marineford isn’t what got Buggy the warlord position. Him lying about being the mastermind of Impel down did.
Click to expand...
Going to MF Is what gave Buggy real world renown, includong being seen talking shit to Shanks himself.

Marines vs CG won’t happen because Cross guild would lose. And cross guild can’t lose because Buggy has to reach laugh tale.
Click to expand...
Yeah, cause It never happened that plot driven situations led the Marine to send only weaker forces, no?

Sengoku will come, or at best an Admiral, and in the end they will mange to go away.

Cross guild adding more people would matter ONLY IF buggy stopped being the leader. Get it? As long their leader is a gag character, they remain a gag organization
Click to expand...
And they are: they are and organization with a King (OPM) leader, and this Is their force since they'll keep getting incredible results thanks to that.
Oda "told" us even in double spread.
 
J

Just a member

‎
#11
#11
Makes sense, yet the people who care for Cross guild do so only because there is Mihawk in it so while it is right that Buggy will do nothing yet get praised to the heavens a possible situation (even likely if Oda decides to make the CG actually do something) is that they get into a fight to get the road poneglyphs/somebody who can read them/whatever they could need to get there and deliver Mihawk to Zoro and Mihawk and Croco get some good fights and much needed feats (for Mihawk) and Buggy get the credit as the captain (the joke is safe and Mihawk and Croco win as well). Or at least I hope so, otherwise Mihawk only (real) fight in the whole manga will be just Zoro. I hope Oda can do better than that but honestly I'm not expecting it (so yeah, probably the CG will do nothing even if if Oda wants it could without much problems).
 
ImmaIvanoM

ImmaIvanoM

‎
#14
#14
Dragon777 said:
Going to MF Is what gave Buggy real world renown, includong being seen talking shit to Shanks himself.



Yeah, cause It never happened that plot driven situations led the Marine to send only weaker forces, no?

Sengoku will come, or at best an Admiral, and in the end they will mange to go away.



And they are: they are and organization with a King (OPM) leader, and this Is their force since they'll keep getting incredible results thanks to that.
Oda "told" us even in double spread.
Click to expand...
They already sent weaker forces, remember… there was a vice admiral and a bunch of battleships around the island before Crocodile arrived.

The marines sent these guys when they believed buggy was just a “mere warlord”… now they believe Buggy IS STRONGER THAN MIHAWK… Or at least comparable enough for Mihawk to let Buggy be his leader… The marines believe there’s essentially two Yonko level people on that island

So if Sengoku Plus ONE other admiral arrive with 30 battle ships to fight TWO Yonko, yes, Cross guild would lose… so this ain’t happening

Also Oda has shown with Kizaru that he’s not going to waste admirals on anyone, not even Luffy… The admirals will be defeated when the plot wants them to be… And even Luffy failed to defeat Kizaru in egghead just because of plot

Also don’t use other series to talk about OP… we know Oda’s writing philosophy is unique to him… why do you think we One piece fans regularly talk about “plot” so much when this isn’t a thing in other stories
 
Albino 👑

Albino 👑

‎
#15
#15
MarineHQ said:
Agreed. That way we're getting Zoro vs Mihawk
Click to expand...
100%
Have the captains sit out of the games and just let their crews shine type shit. Have zoro vs mihawk being the last round or at least a round zoro has to win in order for them to stay in the game

People expect too much from cross guild if they genuinely expect them to be able to clash head on with any emperor crew. Like they themselves said they don’t plan on trying to get to the one piece through dominance but scheming and out smarting the other emperors. Exactly what foxy was doing but this time on a bigger scale
 
gz89

gz89

‎
#16
#16
Albino 👑 said:
100%
Have the captains sit out of the games and just let their crews shine type shit. Have zoro vs mihawk being the last round or at least a round zoro has to win in order for them to stay in the game

People expect too much from cross guild if they genuinely expect them to be able to clash head on with any emperor crew. Like they themselves said they don’t plan on trying to get to the one piece through dominance but scheming and out smarting the other emperors. Exactly what foxy was doing but this time on a bigger scale
Click to expand...
Will you bet your account on this davy back dumb theory? If you are in lets do it right now.
 
Albino 👑

Albino 👑

‎
#19
#19
gz89 said:
Will you bet your account on this davy back dumb theory? If you are in let’s do it right now.
Click to expand...
I really don’t care that much man
If it makes you feel better I guess. I do think there will be another Davy back fight
Shiroyru said:
How would CG not also get negged in a Davy Back Fight?
Click to expand...
Same way the foxy pirates didn’t get neg diffed despite being fodder to the strawhats it a straight up fight
 
Shiroyru

Shiroyru

‎
#20
#20
Albino 👑 said:
I really don’t care that much man
If it makes you feel better I guess. I do think there will be another Davy back fight

Same way the foxy pirates didn’t get neg diffed despite being fodder to the strawhats it a straight up fight
Click to expand...
Weren’t the Foxy Pirates cheating? I don’t see Mihawk and Croc cheating
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top