Questions & Mysteries Did King or Queen screw over the Beast Pirates more?

#2
They both fucked Kaido over but now that I'm really thinking about it King was technically worse

The Alliance have no answer for Smoothie, Snack, and other BMP executives

Assuming Smoothie is as strong as any other YC2 they're definitely fucked. Who else in the alliance was free to take on a commander?

You could make an argument for Jinbei but that would have to come after beating Who's Who (which took him a little while to do)

In that time Smoothie and Snack could easily sweep the rest of the alliance
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#3
Queen- Made thousands of BP fodders join the alliance

King- Prevented the BMPs from reaching Onigashima, which might have been enough to overwhelm the alliance
The bmp came back up after and Marco kicked them down. Learn how to read.
[automerge]1667665573[/automerge]
They both fucked Kaido over but now that I'm really thinking about it King was technically worse

The Alliance have no answer for Smoothie, Snack, and other BMP executives

Assuming Smoothie is as strong as any other YC2 they're definitely fucked. Who else in the alliance was free to take on a commander?

You could make an argument for Jinbei but that would have to come after beating Who's Who (which took him a little while to do)

In that time Smoothie and Snack could easily sweep the rest of the alliance
Another guy who can't read.
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#7
Doesn't matter how much you hate to admit it

It's the truth

If King didn't knock them down the first time Marco wouldn't have a chance to knock them down a second time

:jordanmf:
You just can't read.
If they all came up with meme they would have fought the beast pirates and kaido instantly. And made it a war from the off.

After what King did. Meme and kaido made an alliance and let them come up in peace.
 
#9
They both fucked Kaido over but now that I'm really thinking about it King was technically worse

The Alliance have no answer for Smoothie, Snack, and other BMP executives

Assuming Smoothie is as strong as any other YC2 they're definitely fucked. Who else in the alliance was free to take on a commander?

You could make an argument for Jinbei but that would have to come after beating Who's Who (which took him a little while to do)

In that time Smoothie and Snack could easily sweep the rest of the alliance
Killer and the Scabbards
 
#10
You just can't read.
If they all came up with meme they would have fought the beast pirates and kaido instantly. And made it a war from the off.

After what King did. Meme and kaido made an alliance and let them come up in peace.
Kaido and Big Mom fought anyway

Her showing up with her entire crew would make 0 difference

They'd fight, make up, and that would be the end of it

Kaido claimed he'd kill Big Mom if she came to Wano and didn't do it even when he had the advantage



I think you're the one that needs to learn how to read.
 
#14
Queen was doing just fine with his weapons, it's just surprising that someone managed to mass produce an antidote. He also put his trust in brother Apoo just to save him but he fucked up.
They are fodder regardless and as Mr. Go said, the battle is decided by the top dogs.

King helped Big Mom land in Wano early in the game, her crew would have been good extras but the 2 strongest (BM & Pero) made it to Onigashima, I don't think a couple vets & Smoothie would make a difference really.

So neither contributed to the loss.
 

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
#15
Kaido and Big Mom fought anyway

Her showing up with her entire crew would make 0 difference

They'd fight, make up, and that would be the end of it

Kaido claimed he'd kill Big Mom if she came to Wano and didn't do it even when he had the advantage


I think you're the one that needs to learn how to read.
There is a quite obvious world of difference between Big Mom being dumped in the middle of Kaido‘s territory in chains, alone, surrounded by enemies and Big Mom landing on the mainland with a huge chunk of her crew ready and willing to cause chaos.

The arc doesn’t go anywhere near the same way if King doesn’t intervene. It’s ridiculous to act like he somehow screwed the Beast Pirates when there was two weeks between him knocking them down the waterfall and Onigashima starting.
 
#17
There is a quite obvious world of difference between Big Mom being dumped in the middle of Kaido‘s territory in chains, alone, surrounded by enemies and Big Mom landing on the mainland with a huge chunk of her crew ready and willing to cause chaos.

The arc doesn’t go anywhere near the same way if King doesn’t intervene. It’s ridiculous to act like he somehow screwed the Beast Pirates when there was two weeks between him knocking them down the waterfall and Onigashima starting.
I think the result would eventually be the same

Kaido claimed he was ready and willing to kill Big Mom given the chance yet things didn't go down like that. I have no reason to believe Kaido and Big Mom would truly have "an all out war" when Kaido had the perfect opportunity to kill Big Mom and chose not to

After a bit of fighting things would settle and they'd move on
 

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
#19
I think the result would eventually be the same

Kaido claimed he was ready and willing to kill Big Mom given the chance yet things didn't go down like that. I have no reason to believe Kaido and Big Mom would truly have "an all out war" when Kaido had the perfect opportunity to kill Big Mom and chose not to

After a bit of fighting things would settle and they'd move on
Things are quite obviously different.

If it’s a huge chunk of the Big Mom Pirates that arrive, it’s not a solo Kaido vs Big Mom effort. It’s Kaido vs Big Mom, King vs Smoothie, Queen or Jack are sprinting over to join in, so are the Flying Six.

Kaido vs Big Mom lasted for hours. You think King vs Smoothie is? King’s tearing chunks out of her. She’s dead in minutes, she’s not anywhere near as strong as Marco or Zoro. That’s repeated all over while Kaido and Big Mom are having their hours long fight. Kaido and Big Mom have reason to be somewhat friendly rivals fighting with each other. Their crews don’t. This is not the cheerful friendly Roger Pirates vs Whitebeard Pirates fight, this is two psycho crews going at each other. Even if Kaido and Big Mom agree to a stalemate after a few hours, by then there will have been serious casualties.

Then who knows what the Alliance decide to do in the middle of all this.

It’s a terrible take to say if King doesn’t intervene they just form a happy alliance.
 
Top