Role Madness Elden Ring

[Lord Melkor]

Jan looks townie with his recent posts. More confident on him than Baudib. Flower says they both have good range

 

[Ratchet]

No, self voting is not playing to your wincon if town, ever

Nonsense, if someone's flip is needed for the collective solve to progress it's worth getting said flip.

Town don't need mislynches and especially from the likes of you. We need you solving and playing

I've done both - now what?

 

[Polar Bear]

 

[The Orca]

Probably this:

Doesn't understand the scum case on baudib.

Explains why they don't agree.

Outlines the resolution they would rather pursue for them.

All seems pretty straightforward to me.

Yeah but that isn't why RippedCal. Bad direction again imo. He has been in a stark contrast to OLF where I was on him as scum from the start. His claimed move can be a definite advantage to town and can be tested via other methods. How he is the 2nd wagon/possible lynch is a joke, especially given how the Yoho lynch went down

 

[Lord Melkor]

I am obviously not the only Rot user because i am immune to it and there were more people affected by it during the night than single person could target. Other users may not be town.

 

[Ratchet]

Yeah but that isn't why RippedCal. Bad direction again imo. He has been in a stark contrast to OLF where I was on him as scum from the start. His claimed move can be a definite advantage to town and can be tested via other methods. How he is the 2nd wagon/possible lynch is a joke, especially given how the Yoho lynch went down

The answer to that is "he's the other wagon".

 

[Lord Melkor]

A

Interesting, both wagons are not far from each other

 

[Fujishiro]

VC8 D2

Baudib - 9
RippedCal - 7
Charlie - 1
The Orca - 1
Peroroncino - 1


Worst: Charlie > York > Baudib
Bittersweet: Yoho > Saber > RippedCal > The Orca
Flower: Yo Tan Wa> Charlie > RippedCal > Saber > Ratchet > Ratchet > Ratchet > Flower > RippedCal
RippedCal: Charlie > Baudib
Stargate: Charlie
Peroroncino: Charlie > Baudib
Saber: Charlie > Indigo (Red Night) > Bittersweet > Baudib
Alwaysmind: Jaguark > RippedCal
Ratchet: Saber > Baudib > Flower > Ratchet > RippedCal
Lord Melkor: RippedCal > Baudib > RippedCal
The Orca: Baudib
Polar Bear: York > Bittersweet > Ratchet > Bittersweet > Charlie > Baudib > Bittersweet > Ratchet > Baudib
Charlie: Baudib > Baudib
Baudib: York > RippedCal
York: Baudib
Red Night: Peroroncino
MonochromeYoru: Bittersweet > Baudib
Jan: RippedCal

Duel Votes


Red Night - 13
Charlie - 2

Flower: Red Night
Worst: Red Night
Charlie: Charlie
Baudib: Red Night
Lord Melkor: Red Night
The Orca: Charlie
Ratchet: Red Night
York: Red Night
Peroroncino: Red Night
Bittersweet: Red Night
Saber: Red Night
MonochromeYoru: Red Night
Polar Bear: Red Night
Alwaysmind: Red Night
Jan: Red Night​

 

[The Orca]

The answer to that is "he's the other wagon".

You aren't Jan

 

[Lord Melkor]

@Stargate18 @MonochromeYoru @Red Night why are you not voting among the leading wagons?

 

[Polar Bear]

A

Interesting, both wagons are not far from each other

And yet flower has some defeatist attitude like she can't get her way and its decided lol

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Which of those do you trust to read me well and why?

I trust pretty much everyone to read you better than me. That's why I asked Polar who is the best town read for me

Sure, but that's removing agency from yourself and hoping something else solves it for you.

Yes that's what I do when I'm out of my depth/experience

Should be indicative of something!

Enlighten me please

 

[Polar Bear]

You aren't Jan

Seems like ratchet is answering for baudib1 and jan lately. At least on my skim

 

[MonochromeYoru]

@Stargate18 @MonochromeYoru @Red Night why are you not voting among the leading wagons?

I am?

I am voting Baudib

 

[Jan]

Yeah but that isn't why RippedCal. Bad direction again imo. He has been in a stark contrast to OLF where I was on him as scum from the start. His claimed move can be a definite advantage to town and can be tested via other methods. How he is the 2nd wagon/possible lynch is a joke, especially given how the Yoho lynch went down

a. counter wagon
b. checked his iso and disliked it a lot

Can you give me a quick proper meta defense on what is different about him?

 

[Jan]

Seems like ratchet is answering for baudib1 and jan lately. At least on my skim

Ratchet has played with us for over 10 years.

Or rather played a game that involved both Baudib and me over 10 years ago!

 

[bittersweet]

Look, the last think I need this game is a pedant policing the technicalities of my wording instead of grasping the message, if my correction doesn't work for you then fill in whatever does.

I don't quite get why you're being so seemingly hostile.

But whatever, it's not worth the time or effort to argue over it.

Just gonna wait and see how the current top wagon and duel flips.

 

[The Orca]

a. counter wagon
b. checked his iso and disliked it a lot

Can you give me a quick proper meta defense on what is different about him?

He is actually taking a stance and posting. The first few days as scum he was non-existent and just a body. Here he seems involved and caught up. Then when they did post it was very odd and reads didn't match what I would think was obvious at times. Here he has had some good thoughts and questions and reads are matching mine. Which is weird and I don't think would be so obvious of a match if scum

 

[Jan]

Melkor explained what his rot does.
Seems multiple uses of it on same target gives them negative effects.
I don't think there's gonna be another rot in this game.

We could potentially even catch the rotter by watching the already rotted people.

Yeah, but I doubt that it is the only one thing it does.
You would not make 1 town role to maybe rolecrush with and one other role to heal it. (and even if you think baudib is scum, the claim is likely at least partly true).

My guess is that it stacks up, and if it reaches a threshold, you die or can get executed.

 

[Flower]

Ratchet has played with us for over 10 years.

Or rather played a game that involved both Baudib and me over 10 years ago!

Okay boomers.