Role Madness Elden Ring

[Fujishiro]

what was my hidden ability btw

I told you lol, youd turn into an SK if some conditions were met.

 

[Polar Bear]

Problem for town:

A failure to work together towards a solve with others

Hero ball

A failure to get out of tunnels

And of course inactivity

I don't think more activity does anything to trump the failure brought on by the top 3

 

[Worst]

That’s just a role ability. It should be something which both kills low posters and also incentivizes and rewards people for posting a lot.

hmm feels kinda unfair / not fun, one could just fluff till there's no tomorrow or there might be someone that plays a reasonable amount but can't commit to post 500+ posts a game while others could just abuse it and we kinda know who are the most active postsers they would get those benefits 99% of the time

 

[RippedCal]

Yep vigs should clear out LHF POE slots, people kept targetting Cal after he claimed the passive redirect which in of itself is a problem.

Nobody has even apologized to ripped one for ruining his fun of the game

 

[Worst]

Also Slank Vigs are player controlled. It should be put in the hands of the entire Town to decide.

well just put a 2nd lynch atp xD

 

[Jan]

Also Slank Vigs are player controlled. It should be put in the hands of the entire Town to decide.

Itas in this game would have resulted in a scum win on d3.

 

[Flower]

hmm feels kinda unfair / not fun, one could just fluff till there's no tomorrow or there might be someone that plays a reasonable amount but can't commit to post 500+ posts a game while others could just abuse it and we kinda know who are the most active postsers they would get those benefits 99% of the time

Fluff wouldn’t count. Also why shouldn’t people who dedicate a lot of time to playing get benefits?

 

[Fujishiro]

Problem for town:

A failure to work together towards a solve with others

Hero ball

A failure to get out of tunnels

And of course inactivity

I don't think more activity does anything to trump the failure brought on by the top 3

Town was just a big clash of egos and people trying to be the hero lol.

 

[Polar Bear]

Fluff wouldn’t count. Also why shouldn’t people who dedicate a lot of time to playing get benefits?

Bc thats not the game. What if all scum got the benefits, now you've shifted an already scum sided game even further to scum

 

[Fujishiro]

Fluff wouldn’t count. Also why shouldn’t people who dedicate a lot of time to playing get benefits?

Some people low post and offer much more content in their posts vs high posters.

 

[Polar Bear]

Town was just a big clash of egos and people trying to be the hero lol.

Hero ball run rampant lol

I tried to bring town together but then just faded back to hero ball.

I posted way too much though and started acting like an ass bc of it. Hopefully I won't be doing that again.

 

[The Orca]

Hero ball run rampant lol

I tried to bring town together but then just faded back to hero ball.

I posted way too much though and started acting like an ass bc of it. Hopefully I won't be doing that again.

It was over when they chose to lynch Yoho despite my jumping up and down

 

[Jan]

Fluff wouldn’t count. Also why shouldn’t people who dedicate a lot of time to playing get benefits?

Never reward spamming.
And how do you not count fluff?
Do you hire someone to filter the fluff out?

The only exception is a role where a player can choose to become stronger by hitting certain benchmarks. High posting, low posting, exact posting etc .

But that should never apply to the whole game or you alienate your own player base.

 

[Flower]

Some people low post and offer much more content in their posts vs high posters.

Yeah, that’s not the case here lately.

 

[Worst]

Fluff wouldn’t count. Also why shouldn’t people who dedicate a lot of time to playing get benefits?

cuz i don't think having many posts and dedicating a lot of time playing means u are giving a good contribution to the game...

let's say we are both town you have a 1000 posts but all your reads are wrong you get into bickering with everyone and overall it's a mess while i have 100 posts but all my reads are correct and i'm giving town great inputs and getting the right wagons going why would u get any benefit from essentially just spamming ?

also i don't think it would make someone who has to be subbed out going from that good activity to even top poster ( i wouldn't really put in more time just bc of that benefit whatever it is tbh )

 

[Polar Bear]

It was over when they chose to lynch Yoho despite my jumping up and down

Nah, it was the right call. What was the bigger downfall was forcing a yoho claim I think

 

[York]

I don't care if we punish low posters, but rewarding high posters will be nothing but detrimental to our games

 

[Fujishiro]

Yeah, that’s not the case here lately.

I dont know, Stargate, Jaguar all had decend POEs but were drowned out by the louder voices.

 

[Fujishiro]

It was over when they chose to lynch Yoho despite my jumping up and down

No, keeping Yoho alive after he claimed wouldve led to two back to back nights mate.

 

[The Orca]

Nah, it was the right call. What was the bigger downfall was forcing a yoho claim I think

Never. You don't lynch town that you know should be town. You watch and protect them...hell there was a lightning rod to remove strongman possibility. Mafia was gonna have to be caught to kill him

You DID NOT have to lynch him