General & Others Eustass Kidd

J

Jo_Ndule

#21
Ι have him as YC1 level for now.To be honest I can see him losing to all YC1 dudes.But I think he is going to shine against Kaido.
He's definitely high high tier now
He will improve soon.

Umm so Luffy didn't came cuz he managed to beat Katakuri?

Wrong arc I read I guess.
Lol Did Luffy escape Tottoland because of beating Katakuri?

He escaped because fishmen and germa stalled for strawhats to escape

Start reading the manga
Without germs and fishmen, luffy and co wont escape
 
#22
I don’t know why you’re being up other characters. This is purely comparing Kid to Luffy. Unless you want to say those characters are > Luffy.

I’ll concede the Kaido bit, but still Luffy wasn’t able to do anything to Kaido. Same as Kid.

Kid was captured again because of his choice to stay with his crew mate. Similar to how Luffy was captured on WCI. Does that mean Jinbei>Luffy? No
You mentioned how kid scarred a Yonko commander to hype him while we know that other character effectively defeated one like the Mad monk.

We don't know that, Luffy at least send Kaido to the ground.
For all we know Kidd wasn't able to do anything and was defeated, currently no reason to believe otherwise.

Him escaping was mentioned as feat by you.
I just clarified that is not the case.
 

Fujishiro

Just chilling
#25
You said his only defeat was against Kaido.

Why you getting so worked up?

So the missing was a win or not I just ask.
It is a loss yes, i had it in mind when i made that post but we dont know the context of it so i didnt put it in. But yea you can count that. Still less losses than luffy overall.
And, again mate, kidd was in prison because kaido beat the shit out of him. The same way luffy ended up there, dont belittle him for that.
 
#29
Uh? BM amnesia plot?

Kid was defeated and captured nothing else.
A prisoner in the crude sense of the word.

Kaido want him in crew as he wanted Ashura Douji.
I just don’t get why you are attributing luffy’s escape from WCI due to his strength alone.

he would have died if not for jinbe and the vinsmokes.

kid lost against kaido. Luffy never fought big mom apart from that one punch he threw.
 
#31
Exactly, everyone seem to underestimate Kidd and Law. We all have seen SHs get two years of rigorous training to make them able to take on NW whereas HP and KP went straight to the NW and made name for themselves. Even in Sabaody SHs needed Kuma and Rayleigh to avoid Pacifista and Kizaru but others managed to escape them on their own.
After the TS SHs are on another level but Law and Kidd have also gotten strong by surviving the NW. Both of them can push current Luffy to high-extreme diff.
Nice Thread BTw..!!:cheers:
 
S

Shura

#32
Kid could match Gear 3 with no drawback in Sabaody. Kid also didn't lose his entire crew.

Kid injured a sweet commander during the time skip. While Luffy was learning the basics of Haki. Hell Luffy couldn't injure Cracker post timeskip without Nami.

Kid fought Kaido til the last breath. Luffy was quickly one shotted.

Kid escaped the prison easily. Luffy was easily caught by Queen
I was wondering Kidd could have made g3 equivalent if there were no swords or any metal based weapons surrounding him.....forget Kid....no other SN didn't lose any crew except for SHP....

Luffy injured commander level guy pre-TS (Blackbeard) even before learning the basics of Haki......so what.....

Kid fought Kaido till last breath....wow...Luffy was also fought till last breath until Kaido decided to counterattack....even Kaido subordinates commented that "Luffy pummeled Kaido" while Hawkins didn't say anything like that...so what dou you have to say about that???....also it was Kidd+Killer vs Kaido and Luffy vs Kaido......

Kidd escaped prison easily only to get caught and getting drowned...there is no point of escaping if you can't fight back ....yeah, I know they took Killer as a hostage but again what was the point..

See I like Kidd and place him near Luffy because of his portrayal and he plays a key role like any other SN against Kaidou and Bigmom but lets not exaggerate some petty details to wank out of proportion....
 
#40
He wounded one of Big Mom's generals. And took what he wanted to take, meaning the commander was incapable of stopping him.



The only Big Mom commander with a scar:


There were others who made Cracker reveal himself:


This is the same Cracker that Luffy couldn't do jack shit to while being in G4.

Considering his bounty was only 30 mil or so away from Luffy's after showcasing G4's prowess to the marines, while taking into account that the facts regarding the incident with Kidd aren't accurate (even brulee didn't know the full details)..I'd say Kidd is for sure above Luffy from Dressrosa.


As for the timeline, at best the above incident happened a year ago or infact recently, as we had news about Big Mom's ships being hit by Kidd, it was never stated Urouge recently defeated Snack btw. Just that he defeated snack.
 
Last edited:
Top