Role Madness Fate/ Mafia V.2 [Town Wins]
- Thread starter MangoSenpai
- Start date
Updated reads with explanations.
PROS/CONS
Flower
VERDICT: Some minor concerns, but more reasons to townread than not. Still a strong town lean.
Yoho
VERDICT: Nothing overtly clearing, but still a town lean. Closer to null, could fit in some worlds.
Naomi
VERDICT: Town lean.
Fujishiro
VERDICT: I believe that there are less concrete reasons to townread Fuji than I thought. Null for now.
Michelle
VERDICT: On the nuller side, though I'd be surprised if the amount of attention to detail in some of their reads came from a wolf. They are unpaired enough with people in my direct POE that I'd lean town.
Saber
VERDICT: Saber is now a solid scum read for me.
Mr. Reloaded
VERDICT: Leaning scum. Lack of serious engagement. Humor could be a cover. I'm not seeing much genuine problem-solving.
MUUGEN
VERDICT: Leaning scum.
Ratchet
VERDICT: Leaning scum.
Handium
VERDICT: Null for now. Need to see more engagement to form a solid read. They're not giving me much to work with.
Yo Tan Wa
VERDICT: Null. Need more data.
Stargate18
VERDICT: Null. Needs to be more active. I can't form an opinion based on so little information.
tepig19283
VERDICT: Leaning town. There's a sense of genuine effort there, and I appreciate their attempts to solve. I'll keep watching them, but for now, they seem more likely to be town.
SORT
Flower
Yoho
Naomi
tepig19283
Michelle
Fujishiro
Handium=
Yo Tan Wa
Stargate18
Saber
Mr. Reloaded
MUUGEN
Ratchet
PROS/CONS
Flower
Reasons Flower is Town:
- Her reads so far feel real, and I don't see a reason for her to approach it that way as a wolf.
- The way she's consistently wanted to read people for herself in the wake of people locking them as town has felt villagery.
- Has exhibited a comfortable fluidity to reads.
- Fair amount of mindmelds/some towny micromoments.
- General mixture of healthy caution and strong reads has in all come across as very natural.
- Engagement is consistent.
- In more of a background position early on when lots of pushes on villagers were happening.
- Could be playing a more subtle game, not drawing too much attention.
VERDICT: Some minor concerns, but more reasons to townread than not. Still a strong town lean.
Yoho
Reasons Yoho is Town:
- Yoho, in general, has not done a lot to direct the flow of the game or to actively pocket people, which to me indicates they are not playing with a wolf-agenda.
- Has not done much this game, main pushes have been on villagers. Could be playing a lazy mafia game.
- Wolf range is large enough that realistically they could be fooling me this game.
- Not a lot of concretely clearing things/can make sense in a few worlds.
VERDICT: Nothing overtly clearing, but still a town lean. Closer to null, could fit in some worlds.
Naomi
Reasons Naomi is Town:
- Play aligns more closely with town meta upon review.
- Naomi appears to be one of the hardest pushers currently.
- Actively engaged in discussions and willing to challenge others.
- My read on her in the beginning could be correct. In past town games especially lately, I've usually found her earlier than I did this game.
- Gamestate/my townreads indicate it's likely one where wolves are playing well, and she is one of the most capable people of fooling me.
- Early game push on me felt performative.
VERDICT: Town lean.
Fujishiro
Reasons Fujishiro is Town:
- Claimed to be Miller early on.
- Unusual claim.
- Behavior has been erratic and difficult to read.
VERDICT: I believe that there are less concrete reasons to townread Fuji than I thought. Null for now.
Michelle
Reasons Michelle is Town:
- Has been fairly reasonable in attention to detail throughout the game in a way that's come across as villagery.
- Has been quite active and is driving the discussion.
- TBD.
VERDICT: On the nuller side, though I'd be surprised if the amount of attention to detail in some of their reads came from a wolf. They are unpaired enough with people in my direct POE that I'd lean town.
Saber
Reasons Saber is Town:
- Made a few posts.
- Made a read.
- Unusual reads.
- Seems to be throwing out ideas without a clear, logical progression.
Mr. Reloaded
Reasons Mr. Reloaded is Town:
- Has made some contributions to the discussion, although they've been limited.
- Some jokes land well.
- Posts are often more focused on humor than on actual game analysis. It feels like a distraction.
- Could be using humor as a way to deflect or avoid scrutiny. It's an easy way to avoid serious discussion.
- Seems to be lurking in the background, which is a common wolf strategy. Not taking a strong stance on anything.
VERDICT: Leaning scum. Lack of serious engagement. Humor could be a cover. I'm not seeing much genuine problem-solving.
MUUGEN
Reasons MUUGEN is Town:
- Has been active and engaged in discussions. They're definitely participating.
- Early push on Saber felt forced and opportunistic, like they were trying to get a quick lynch.
- Might be using a "bold" playstyle to mask wolf intentions. The aggressiveness feels a bit calculated.
VERDICT: Leaning scum.
Ratchet
Reasons Ratchet is Town:
- Engages in debates and challenges others' viewpoints. They're not afraid to speak their mind.
- Argumentative style could be a way to create distractions and muddy the waters.
- Behavior seems somewhat inconsistent.
- Might be trying to appear townie by being vocal, but actions don't always align with their words. It feels like a performance at times.
VERDICT: Leaning scum.
Handium
Reasons Handium is Town:
- Has made some contributions, although limited.
- Relatively quiet and has not been a major driving force as of D1. It's hard to get a read on them.
- Could be playing a lurking game.
VERDICT: Null for now. Need to see more engagement to form a solid read. They're not giving me much to work with.
Yo Tan Wa
Reasons Yo Tan Wa is Town:
- None that stand out at the moment.
- Relatively low activity makes it hard to get a read.
- Could be any alignment as of now.
VERDICT: Null. Need more data.
Stargate18
Reasons Stargate18 is Town:
- Has chimed in occasionally, so they're not completely silent.
- Sporadic participation makes it difficult to gauge intentions. They're not consistently engaged.
- Could be any alignment.
VERDICT: Null. Needs to be more active. I can't form an opinion based on so little information.
tepig19283
Reasons tepig19283 is Town:
- Some reads seem to be based on careful observation. They're paying attention to details.
- Has shown some genuine problem-solving. They seem to be thinking things through.
- Asks questions and seems to be trying to understand the game, which is a good sign.
- Could be a wolf playing a more subtle game, trying to appear townie without being too obvious.
VERDICT: Leaning town. There's a sense of genuine effort there, and I appreciate their attempts to solve. I'll keep watching them, but for now, they seem more likely to be town.
SORT
Flower
Yoho
Naomi
tepig19283
Michelle
Fujishiro
Handium=
Yo Tan Wa
Stargate18
Saber
Mr. Reloaded
MUUGEN
Ratchet
?
.
@Alexis2282AE No thoughts, as you were. I love arguing, I don't think I've been inconsistent, and I do think I come across as performative at the best of times. I don't mind the observations is isolation. Actually makes me a bit nervous.... AI really has come a long way. There was an AI bot I came across that basically let you feed your Twitter/X account to it, and it generated an AI version of yourself. Was uncanny...