Orojackson was shut down cause the creator, Divvens, was overwhelmingly sick and chose to shut the site down. He gave everyone a 2 month notice. Yeah poor/too strict moderation was the reason for a lot of the chaos and dramas, but it wasn't what ended the site.
They were strict because it went out of control for a while. And I saw it how people becane more toxic over time. It was unavoidable. No blame to mods. Its naturaly for people to become more toxic and its natural to hand out bans.
The toxicity increased when Naruto and Bleach ended as those fans came to the forum. It got out of control because the moderators closed down and banned Zoro v Sanji, Yonko v Admiral and Mingo topics. Those 3 were not only the most toxic discussions, but the undisputed biggest. These topics are way too big to ban and it of course led to many duplicate threads and punishments. Punishments were also dissed out without explanation or evidence aka, lack of communication.
Members have no clue how things are done but we mods should also be aware that our actions can appear very inconsistent without proper communication. I can agree with both Nat and Den Den.