Is Bleach Better than Kingdom?


  • Total voters
    179


(Feel free to use it to edit some more if y'all want.)​


So using a Qin 6 level person is fine, as long as they're your LT.? is that the logic you're using to justify your stance?

Riboku using a vastly inferior general in Houken for his strategies is a negative on Riboku, because the vastly inferior general is not Riboku's LT. However, Ouki using the vastly superior general Tou to take out leading officers of an army is completely fine.

Tou didn't save Ouki?? Bro really missed Bayou huh. Moubu & Tou are the primary reason Ouki was able to make his escape instead of dying in an army surrounded. Who knows how many other times, Ouki used Tou or got bailed out. We've only had 1 campaign of Ouki-Tou, in which Ouki used Tou to slay the head-commanding officer of the opposing army + then Tou comes in to rescue him.

you keep stating the samething over and over with "Riboku is cornered needed Houken to be saved", yet fail to point to a single relevant example of where that happened.

Duke Hyou vs Riboku? Nope, Houken was already there, Riboku didn't need any saving. If Houken wasn't there, Riboku either would've just fell back and made Duke pursure him into the Ryuudou more or would've changed the strategem. You keep making it seem like Riboku had no other way out.

Against Gekishin?? Nope, the entire plan was to low-diff Gekishin by overwhelming him with himself + Houken + Keisha.
Coalition?? Nope, mans didn't do jackshit except delay a retreat.
WZI? Nope, mans didn't do jackshit except delay Riboku's retreat.

So I ask, where is the "Houken saved Riboku" coming from? Give me the specific scenario where Riboku is cornered and saved by Houken. Where Houken coming in is not part of Riboku's plan. Where Riboku isn't luring mfs in by using Houken. The term "saved" implies that one is in risk of losing their life or battle...and in none of the situations that's the case.


PS: There is no such thing called "Riboku army" idk where you came up with that. He has his handful of vassals, that's about it. The entire army of Zhao was Riboku's army, that's what it means to be Chief of Military, a position higher than a mere general or Great General.
Ouki having Tou is not the same as Riboku having houken for multiple reasons.

Houken is not Riboku's lieutenant.
Houken is a separate 3GH.
Riboku is not 'luring' his opponents to where houken is, that's not what's happening, but it's the opposite, houken is luring in his opponents using Riboku unintentionally, Since it's always like this.
-Riboku executes his plan.
-Thinks he has the enemy general beat with his plan
-his plan fails miserably
-he's under attack.
-houken interferes and saves him.
Unless his plan failing is part of his plan, then he's being saved by houken.
We saw how against kanki he was clowned so many times by kanki even though he had an overwhelming advantage, and since there was no houken, he nearly died if not for plot armor.
If that's how Ouki is using Tou then yeah, I'd say the same for Ouki aswell, but that was not the case. But mogou even though he's the boss of Ousen and Kanki he's still called mediocre and they're called geniuses. Because 'directing' houken by just having him there, isnt a skill even heki can do the same. mogou atleast had them as vice-generals, Houken is a different general so it's even worse for riboku.


A perfect example is:
heki is a general of an army and shin is also present. Heki devises a plan to defeat the enemy, his plan fails and gets countered and his HQ is in danger, shin wakes up from his sleep and moves to kill the enemy general that's attacking heki.
Who's the impressive one here? Heki or shin? Cause this is the fucking same shit that happens between Riboku and Houken.

Just like Renpa >>> Mogou even though the latter 'won', Ouki, Duke or even Gekishin > Riboku even though the latter 'won'.
 
Ouki having Tou is not the same as Riboku having houken for multiple reasons.

Houken is not Riboku's lieutenant.
Houken is a separate 3GH.
Riboku is not 'luring' his opponents to where houken is, that's not what's happening, but it's the opposite, houken is luring in his opponents using Riboku unintentionally, Since it's always like this.
-Riboku executes his plan.
-Thinks he has the enemy general beat with his plan
-his plan fails miserably
-he's under attack.
-houken interferes and saves him.
Unless his plan failing is part of his plan, then he's being saved by houken.
We saw how against kanki he was clowned so many times by kanki even though he had an overwhelming advantage, and since there was no houken, he nearly died if not for plot armor.
If that's how Ouki is using Tou then yeah, I'd say the same for Ouki aswell, but that was not the case. But mogou even though he's the boss of Ousen and Kanki he's still called mediocre and they're called geniuses. Because 'directing' houken by just having him there, isnt a skill even heki can do the same. mogou atleast had them as vice-generals, Houken is a different general so it's even worse for riboku.


A perfect example is:
heki is a general of an army and shin is also present. Heki devises a plan to defeat the enemy, his plan fails and gets countered and his HQ is in danger, shin wakes up from his sleep and moves to kill the enemy general that's attacking heki.
Who's the impressive one here? Heki or shin? Cause this is the fucking same shit that happens between Riboku and Houken.

Just like Renpa >>> Mogou even though the latter 'won', Ouki, Duke or even Gekishin > Riboku even though the latter 'won'.
- Houken is still a subordinate to Riboku, you nitpicking over titles instead of actual capability and prowess of the underlings is just weird to me.

- He is luring people in. He used Houken to lure out Ouki. He then devised a strategy where Gekishin got lured into him, with him having Houken ready to come fuck Geksihin up.

- You keep equating somebody countering Riboku once as "Fucked up his plans"... like no... Every strategist in Kingdom has plans on plans on plans if their initial one fails, they then go to the 2nd.

- He was clowned against Kanki because Hara was at his worst writing then lol. This has been broken down already, the enemy general is purposely dumbed down because Kanki's gimmick cannot work on any normal non-PIS Keisha level+ general. It just doesn't. "He nearly died if not for plot armor"... and he was in that situation because of Plot induced stupidity... but you ignore that, cool.

- Mougou doesn't strategize on behalf of Ousen/Kanki and he doesn't use them as part of his strategies in a battle. So very bad example.

- Except you're being very disingenuous in saying "just having him there", no he's not just having him there, he's making entire strategies around him. "Houken is a different general", cool... he's still Riboku's underling. Your argument seems to be just keep arguing semantics of the titles they hold.

Your example:
-> Except that's not what happens with Riboku-Houken. I broke down every single scenario and none of the times that is what happened with Houken-Riboku, absolutely none.


Do you see how you had to create a whole headcannon scenario for your argument? That should tell you, you don't have much of a solid premise.

Bro you brought up Gekishin -> countered that with panels, you had no counter to that except just making general statements about Riboku.
Broke down all the Riboku-Houken engagements for you -> you had no counter to them, except continuing to make general statements about Riboku.
Gave you examples of other generals within the manga -> you had no counter to them, other than making general statements about how that wasn't the case.

My brotha, you asked Lee not to argue headcanon but manga, yes? I asked you multiple times to give me examples of where Riboku was saved by Houken, you didn't give any. I asked you of specific scenarios, you didn't give any. In reply to the specific in-manga scenarios of Riboku + other generals, you've simply replied with restating of general statements about how you feel about Riboku... Not what the manga is showing, not with in-manga examples.

Even though you brought up Mougou-Kanki/Ousen, you didn't give a specific comparable example to the point you're making about Riboku-Houken. The single example that you've given is something you just made up about Heki-Shin.

And to top it all off my brotha, and i'm not tryna be mean here or rude... but you have just made top 10/top5/top1 dumbest statement in the fandom with "Gekishin > Riboku"......Like bro what??? Even the mfs that hate Riboku with their soul on here and ignore context and panels for him, will never make a statement like "Gekishin > Riboku".... Bruh you gotta reread/revaluate your takes because this ain't it. And we all here have very different takes on where people rank... but this is just ..... bloody insane.
Post automatically merged:

In that order? Pretty good lol. I would say Shoumou and Rinko are too high and Bananji and Jiaga are too low.
Tell him the truth Lee, it's a L list.

@SakazOuki This shameful behavior of yours is disgusting to watch. Smh.
:josad:
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
Too soon to say. At the risk of further being labeled a Bananji hater, no comment. Lol

Tell him the truth Lee, it's a L list.

@SakazOuki This shameful behavior of yours is disgusting to watch. Smh.
It’s not that bad of a list is it? I’d put Gakushou and Jyoukaryuu there instead of Rinko, and maybe Chougaryuu belongs in there but otherwise not that bad right?
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
The greatest Bananji hater under the heavens. Did you accept that Prime Gyou'un gets mid diffed by enraged Goatji?
You are not a true Zhao fanboy unless you tickle your pickle to Gyou’Un Sama at least once daily

Nah I said in the past I’m not opposed to Bananji being proven stronger than Shukai Plains Gyou’Un. His feat against Ousen’s HQ at the end of the battle was hype as hell and Riboku seems to really value Bananji a lot.

If I had to speculate on how he compares to Shibashou’s guys, I’d say

Jiaga/Bananji
Kansaro/Gakushou/old Jyoukaryuu

:jordanmf:
 
It’s not that bad of a list is it? I’d put Gakushou and Jyoukaryuu there instead of Rinko, and maybe Chougaryuu belongs in there but otherwise not that bad right?
Nah it's reasonable. I was just teasing him cause of the Bananji thing.

I'm not high on Gakushou and Jyoukaryuu, I think Rinko would handle em both (individually ofc). Jyoukaryuu just came off as Akou-esque caliber to me taking on Shin with help & having a "stalemate" for few clashes, rather than anything special. Gakushou then faced a tired out Aisen? (maybe I'm wrong I don't remember much outside of that related to him)

Idk I'm holding my judgement on the Seika commanders like Fuuon/Gakushou until we see them in a scenario where they aren't taking on an opponent who's facing tremendous numbers and fairly tired out before facing them.
 
RIP @Owl Ki i just actually read the spoilers lol. Futei saying Zhao easily killed Kanki is pure meme. This guy man lmfao.
He's not wrong.

Kan Ki had his last stand, but all in all, it was easy work. They buried over 90% of his forces in a day and he spent the rest of the arc running, trying to stall for time, and then dying in a failed ambush.

Everything after Gishi Plains was just clean up.

Shibashou is lucky that Kanki ain't around anymore:watchout:
Kan Ki is the weakest 6GG/3GH and died 0-1 versus 6GG/3GH types after talking that shit while knowingly walking into a trap.

Feel free to lionise that man, but he would've been food to SBS. Definition of easy work.

dawg, he cooked you pages ago. Let it go.
Post automatically merged:

SBS
Renpa
Houken
Gyou'Un
Kaishibou
Gakuhaku
Rinko
Shoumu
Ji Aga
Bananji

Thoughts
:pepecafe:

No one will surpass Hou Ken from a purely martial perspective.

Not Mou Bu, not Shin, not SBS - no one.

Hou Ken was and shall remain the pinnacle of martial might and ability.
 
Other than Ousen only though of Gian at ch 770. They all assume Riboku didnt aware of Hango. Huh Well, Kanki should be the one understand that. Kochou already said that "Riboku should understand the important of 2 Cities that can replace Kantan as Capital, those are Hango & Gian".

When i read 770, i directly think that Hango will be a partly similar with Kansaro&Jiaga-Taigen prev Campaign.

Qin Army Numbers at ch 771 is a little weird to me. 250k soldier of Ousen army while 208k/210k are Taigen+Shin. Then ousen-Yotanwa-Ouhon only worth 40/42k much, so it might be inaccurate translation or Riboku's messenger didnt count the Whole Qin exact Campaign. So which part was missing by him?

Well, i take a guess
Since Shin is practically Late by Ousen's Lieutenants, so Shin faction werent count in 250k Report to Riboku. So the total number in fact is:
- 400k = 250k (include 50k Shin-Roumou (while the unharmed 150k was not seen from Roumou) + 200k Ousen-Yotanwa-Ouhon) #+ 150k unseen-unharmed Taigen army
- around 450k: no report from Roumou
Thus, the number lives in 250k to 450k.
I lean towards 400-450k but get the biggest casualty in Qin history. Well, if Qin Army are 250k, i think It doesnt fit with the theme of 'the biggest casualty'

I'm going with the match-up, about whatever how it happen is in my boundary.
- Youtanwa vs SBS / SSJ with Mountain army (both are in a connection from Shukai Plains)
- Ten + Garou vs Kansaro
- Shin vs Jiaga / SBS
- Ouhon vs Bananji (again)
- Kyoukai vs Gaku shou
- Kyourei vs fuuon
 
- Houken is still a subordinate to Riboku, you nitpicking over titles instead of actual capability and prowess of the underlings is just weird to me.

- He is luring people in. He used Houken to lure out Ouki. He then devised a strategy where Gekishin got lured into him, with him having Houken ready to come fuck Geksihin up.

- You keep equating somebody countering Riboku once as "Fucked up his plans"... like no... Every strategist in Kingdom has plans on plans on plans if their initial one fails, they then go to the 2nd.

- He was clowned against Kanki because Hara was at his worst writing then lol. This has been broken down already, the enemy general is purposely dumbed down because Kanki's gimmick cannot work on any normal non-PIS Keisha level+ general. It just doesn't. "He nearly died if not for plot armor"... and he was in that situation because of Plot induced stupidity... but you ignore that, cool.

- Mougou doesn't strategize on behalf of Ousen/Kanki and he doesn't use them as part of his strategies in a battle. So very bad example.

- Except you're being very disingenuous in saying "just having him there", no he's not just having him there, he's making entire strategies around him. "Houken is a different general", cool... he's still Riboku's underling. Your argument seems to be just keep arguing semantics of the titles they hold.

Your example:
-> Except that's not what happens with Riboku-Houken. I broke down every single scenario and none of the times that is what happened with Houken-Riboku, absolutely none.


Do you see how you had to create a whole headcannon scenario for your argument? That should tell you, you don't have much of a solid premise.

Bro you brought up Gekishin -> countered that with panels, you had no counter to that except just making general statements about Riboku.
Broke down all the Riboku-Houken engagements for you -> you had no counter to them, except continuing to make general statements about Riboku.
Gave you examples of other generals within the manga -> you had no counter to them, other than making general statements about how that wasn't the case.

My brotha, you asked Lee not to argue headcanon but manga, yes? I asked you multiple times to give me examples of where Riboku was saved by Houken, you didn't give any. I asked you of specific scenarios, you didn't give any. In reply to the specific in-manga scenarios of Riboku + other generals, you've simply replied with restating of general statements about how you feel about Riboku... Not what the manga is showing, not with in-manga examples.

Even though you brought up Mougou-Kanki/Ousen, you didn't give a specific comparable example to the point you're making about Riboku-Houken. The single example that you've given is something you just made up about Heki-Shin.

And to top it all off my brotha, and i'm not tryna be mean here or rude... but you have just made top 10/top5/top1 dumbest statement in the fandom with "Gekishin > Riboku"......Like bro what??? Even the mfs that hate Riboku with their soul on here and ignore context and panels for him, will never make a statement like "Gekishin > Riboku".... Bruh you gotta reread/revaluate your takes because this ain't it. And we all here have very different takes on where people rank... but this is just ..... bloody insane.
Post automatically merged:


Tell him the truth Lee, it's a L list.

@SakazOuki This shameful behavior of yours is disgusting to watch. Smh.
:josad:
He isn't a subordinate at all, that's your headcanon. He is a seperate general. This is a fact, no matter how many times you repeat it, the manga says otherwise. Houken is not an underling. He is one of the 3GH

With Ouki, moubo's stupidity actually lured him in, ouki specifically asked him not to go beyond a certain point, oh and the bugatti horses + numeric advantage + 2 different 3GH were needed to best ouki, riboku alone would not be enough, his master plan was seen through by ouki easily, and just because his orders were disobeyed he 'lost'. Basically pis.

But with the Duke or gekishin, nowhere was it even implied that he intended for each of them to reach his HQ, his original plan was trash and he was on the backfoot, houken did save his ass on both occasions. Deal with it or show me any sort of hint that he intended for his HQ to be under attack, only then I will concede that he 'lured' both generals.

You brought up panels? Those panels showed exactly what I said,
-Riboku devised his plan
-Gekishen saw through it
-Gekishen swarms Riboku's HQ
-Gekishen has stronger and more troops, he clearly has the advantage.
-houken appears to save the day, and no this isn't Riboku's plan all along, if you claim it is, prove it within the manga, not headcanon.
As you can see clearly, right up to Houken interfering, gekishin > Riboku. Blame hara for the underwhelming showings of riboku.

Riboku gets clowned hard by kanki..
"Hara is a terrible writer", "pis" etc.
But needing houken in every W he 'had' is not bad writing? The only W he got without houken is against kanki and he actually looked worse than kanki by a mile.
The rest are all losses, how he was nothing special against citizens of sai, and how he immediately ran away before the mountain tribe, the so called no.1 genuis couldn't come up with anything at all and just fled, we've seen other generals in worse situation and they manage to make a comeback, while riboku can only get a W when he has a huge advantage and has another 3GH general alongside him. That is terrible writing imo, and this is what I'm arguing in the first place. But you 3 jumped straight up to defend Riboku blindly cause of pure fanboyism, which is clear from you other posts.

Dude, I gave you examples of how houken saved Riboku, but you're denying it due to headcanon. Show me where it is shown that Riboku planned to lure gekishen to attack his HQ and to have houken slay him. That's pure headcanon, what was shown is Gekishen outsmarted Riboku and figured out his hiding spot and was clearly having the upper hand in numbers and strength of troops, as shown by the actual manga. So yes, houken saved Riboku there.

The shin and heki example is how Riboku and houken are, Riboku is not directing houken against gekishin or the duke or against Ousen. When his HQ is about to fall, houken on his own according pops up to save him, that's why the moment houken was killed, Riboku could do nothing but run away as fast as he could.

Gekishin outclassed Riboku strategically, but he lost to houken's might. As per manga. This is what any person who's eyes are not covered by Riboku's load can see.
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
No one will surpass Hou Ken from a purely martial perspective.

Not Mou Bu, not Shin, not SBS - no one.

Hou Ken was and shall remain the pinnacle of martial might and ability.
Yeah but you can be the peak of martial arts and be weaker than some GG

Ouki and people as strong as him + weight > or >= Houken martial might

SBS can be stronger than Houken in an all out battle even if he would be weaker than him martially. For that obviously SBS would need a solid drive like defending Seika or something like that.
 
Top