Is Bleach Better than Kingdom?


  • Total voters
    25
No Bananji ?

I feel like Banana is meant to be a little bit above SSJ

Hara has a trope for the best commanders of GG

The strongest is martial oriented
The second strongest is brain oriented
They're equal in station, but not in utility.

SSJ is a fixer. General is just one of many hats he wears.

BNJ has more utility, but value's a matter of perspective.
 
Ok and?

You guys actually believe the likes of Heavenly Kings are capable of challenging 6GG on equal terms? Because I don't.
Who said they expected him to match a 6gg on equal terms?
Make up another random argument and act like you said something.
He had every advantage known to man and still couldn't do shit.
most HK's are a step away from that level and with one of these advantages can have an equal chance of winning let alone all 3.
Give Kyou En multiple strong generals and 4 times the numbers and let's see what Tou can do.
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
They're equal in station, but not in utility.

SSJ is a fixer. General is just one of many hats he wears.

BNJ has more utility, but value's a matter of perspective.
I don’t disagree at all

but seeing what Hara is doing with his commanders i fell there is a pattern

For the first generals : Akou, Gyou'Un, Rokuomi, Bananji, Kaishibou, Kansaro, Raido, Bajio

for the second generals : SSJ, Maron, Chou Ga Ryuu, Gakushou, Denrimi, Ryuu Koku
 
No Bananji ?

I feel like Banana is meant to be a little bit above SSJ

Hara has a trope for the best commanders of GG

The strongest is martial oriented
The second strongest is brain oriented
Sure, it's a pattern, but it's not a rule.

Shunsuijuu was stated to be Riboku's right hand man and he was put as CiC by Riboku in multiple battles - Ryouyou, siege of Atsuyo, battle agaist Mouten etc. Bananji is good, but he was never given the same level of responsibility.

Shouheikun's top vassal is also Kaioku, not any of his martial commanders like Hyou Shiga. So it's clear there are some exceptions to this rule.

Who said they expected him to match a 6gg on equal terms?
Make up another random argument and act like you said something.
He had every advantage known to man and still couldn't do shit.
Yotanwa not only barely survived this battle, but she suffered huge casualties. So this whole arguement that he 'couldn't do shit' is ridiculus. He did exceptionally well with his plan to use the tunels to destroy suplies and he clearly surprised her with his encirclement.

But his feats go way beyond that.
>In Hango he was stalling Bajio + Shunmen + Tajifu.
>In the current arc he is doing work against Yotanwa army after Yotanwa and Danto were taken down by the arrows. Again, Yotanwa army still has multiple powerful warriors.
>In Gian Arc he came up with the plan to poison the well in Sekirei which allowed Zhao to regain control of the region - he was basically the 2nd most impressive Zhao commander in this arc only after Riboku.

most HK's are a step away from that level and with one of these advantages can have an equal chance of winning let alone all 3.
Give Kyou En multiple strong generals and 4 times the numbers and let's see what Tou can do.
Renpa and his 4 Heavenly Kings together couldn't even defeat two stars of Han as per canon, so this is ridiculus wank.

Full Renpa Army was also stated to be inferior to full Ouki Army, so HK's have no potrayal to back this up.
 
Last edited:
Heavenly Kings level generals are capable of fighting legendary GGs like Qin Six Great Generals and Zhao Three Great Heavens on equal ground, I mean Kyou'En literally proved that.
It's the opposite. In Sanyou Kyouen was dealt pretty handidly by Ousen and at the end of the battle even Renpa believed Kyouen is incapable of dealing with Ousen Army on his own.



As for any battles Kyouen had in the past against the goats, there's no proof they were on equal ground. I suspect they were a bit similar to what we've seen with SSJ vs Yotanwa where one side has some sort of advatange.

Kyou En one shots YTW with an arrow, then low diffs her mountain monkeys
:milaugh:

Shields carried by Ousen's guards are enough to stop Kyouen's arrows.

 
Shunsuijuu was stated to be Riboku's right hand man and he was put as CiC by Riboku in multiple battles - Ryouyou, siege of Atsuyo, battle agaist Mouten etc. Bananji is good, but he was never given the same level of responsibility.
I don’t think the story is telling us that SSJ is higher ranked than Banana

SSJ has indeed a different purpose compared to Banana but I don’t think there is any ranking between them

Full Renpa Army was also stated to be inferior to full Ouki Army
Where ? I don’t remember that
 
I don’t disagree at all

but seeing what Hara is doing with his commanders i fell there is a pattern

For the first generals : Akou, Gyou'Un, Rokuomi, Bananji, Kaishibou, Kansaro, Raido, Bajio

for the second generals : SSJ, Maron, Chou Ga Ryuu, Gakushou, Denrimi, Ryuu Koku
I don't think it's that clear-cut.

Kai Shi Bou is martial orientated and the leader of the 4HK, but Rin Ko was canonically the superior fighter, and Kyou En the superior general by resume.

I also think you'll find there's a lot of people out there that think Ryuu Koku is the superior general to ROM. I'm not one of them, but I think there's a significant number of them out there.

CGR was also never implied to be inferior to Gyou'un either, and it's reasonable to consider the scale and circumstances of Shukai didn't actually lend to him showing off his strengths.

Ma Ron was not the #2 behind Rai Do, that was Koku'Ou.
 
Ma Ron was not the #2 behind Rai Do, that was Koku'Ou.
?
I don’t remember this
You’re maybe right but I didn’t remember that at all

and frankly Maron impressed me more than Koku Ou, he was quite more useful than her in my book iirc


CGR was also never implied to be inferior to Gyou'un either, and it's reasonable to consider the scale and circumstances of Shukai didn't actually lend to him showing off his strengths.
Didn’t Gyou Un the explicit right hand while CGR was « only » the left hand of RSJ ?

And narrative wise Gyou Un was a more important player than CGR


I also think you'll find there's a lot of people out there that think Ryuu Koku is the superior general to ROM. I'm not one of them, but I think there's a significant number of them out there.
Rokuomi is clearly and without discussion the first general under Tou

Narratively, importance wise etc etc

Rokuomi is THE man under Tou
 
I don’t think the story is telling us that SSJ is higher ranked than Banana

SSJ has indeed a different purpose compared to Banana but I don’t think there is any ranking between them
Shunsuijuu being stated to be the right hand man of Riboku puts him above Bananji in hierarchy (every GG only has one right-hand man). Whether or not that makes him superior commander to Bananji is not definitive, but it's at least an arguement to support it.



Where ? I don’t remember that
During the conquest of Han it was stated Ouki Army was the strongest in the old era.

 
Shunsuijuu was stated to be Riboku's right hand man and he was put as CiC by Riboku in multiple battles
I don’t think the story is telling us that SSJ is higher ranked than Banana

SSJ has indeed a different purpose compared to Banana but I don’t think there is any ranking between them
Mou Ten referred to SSJ as RBK's RHM during the Gi'an arc. We learned during Hango, BNJ was entrusted with Bu'an in RBK's absence. SSJ was in command during Shintei.

Text boxes have only ever identified him as a deputy alongside BNJ, iirc. That's surely more authoritative.


I don't think who takes lead is necessarily indicative of seniority. Ou Ki served as deputy to Kyou at Bayou. Gen Pou took control from Kai Shi Bou, his leader, at Sanyou. CGR was the brains of the Zhao Left Wing at Shukai.

Yotanwa not only barely survived this battle, but she suffered huge casualties. So this whole arguement that he 'couldn't do shit' is ridiculus. He did exceptionally well with his plan to use the tunels to destroy suplies and he clearly surprised her with his encirclement.
SSJ made more than a few good decisions and made significant contributions, but he was in the passenger seat the moment Rozo showed up and took command.

I asked if you were suggesting SSJ stood on equal terms with YTW at Ryouyou, your answer would appear to be yes, incorrectly.

But his feats go way beyond that.
>In Hango he was stalling Bajio + Shunmen + Tajifu.
You should revisit Hango.




Renpa and his 4 Heavenly Kings together couldn't even defeat two stars of Han as per canon, so this is ridiculus wank.
Literally zero context btw.

Full Renpa Army was also stated to be inferior to full Ouki Army, so HK's have no potrayal to back this up.
Bruh, what is up with you?



It's the opposite. In Sanyou Kyouen was dealt pretty handidly by Ousen and at the end of the battle even Renpa believed Kyouen is incapable of dealing with Ousen Army on his own.
You are in dire need of revisiting Sanyou.
 
Shunsuijuu being stated to be the right hand man of Riboku puts him above Bananji in hierarchy (every GG only has one right-hand man). Whether or not that makes him superior commander to Bananji is not definitive, but it's at least an arguement to support it.




During the conquest of Han it was stated Ouki Army was the strongest in the old era.

Didn’t the HK said to be miles ahead of Ouki vassals ?

‘can’t find the chap where the quote is made
 
Top