The Turks have it worse under Erdogan than the Britons after Brexit.


What's that supposed to mean ?

I think it has more to do with the fact that Erdogan's "reelection" was foreseeable, while the Brexit vote went against polls.
True but different starting points for the respective populace.
UK losers of society had/have a higher living standard than huge majority of Turkey in the recent years and specially pre-Erdogan era.
But relatively speaking Turkish people, at least economically speaking, are still doing better than pre-Erdogan era, of course not as well as 2000s and 2010s, whereas Brexit overall has not much upside, except autonomy, but admittedly, maybe that was the point...

Nevertheless, I would argue Brexit did nothing for most people who put their hopes on it, it was the UK version of Trump, the economically disadvantaged people acting out to give the establishment the finger, at least that´s how they perceived what they were doing.
In both cases, it was not fighting the symptoms though.
In Turkey´s case, there is no guarantee that the alternative to Erdogan would do any better, and like Harashima said, the world in total is developing towards "strong people", to use an euphemism, and in that context it´s not the worst scenario to have someone who has shown his presence internationally vs the opposition who, giving them the benefit of the doubt, really have no experience to go through next difficult years, or worst cast scenario, would completely open up Turkey to outside interference and influence.
If Erdogan can get the inflation under control which of course is a big IF, there is a lot of potential for the upside in the next decade with all the big projects that are going on, especially in regards to being an arms and energy provider (both own reserves + pipelines from other pvodiers). And this has happened all under Erdogan, and there are a lot of people who do not believe in the opposition since their leaders have kept Turkey as a close to third world country for 80 years after Turkey´s founding.
And a lot of those people do not mind the decrease of human rights and the push towards more authority for him, and the country being more religious and conservative, just the truth.
Hence multilayered imo.
 
I’m not sure Gülen was behind anything in 2016. Erdogan is paranoid.
Post automatically merged:

The economy has already been collapsing for years
Thats the story in Turkey at the coup night Erdogan said Gülen is behind it. It makes sense because their relationship was became bad at the time.

There is also a possibility/theory that Erdo did the coup himself to get rid of the Gülenists. The biggest reason people think like this is how they did the coup. They put few soldiers and tank at airports and big places. Thats not how you do coup. At least not we have seen in 80 and 97 coups.

Economy was showing bad signs since 2012. It was getting worse but kinda managable goverment can control that. After the we refused to send Brunson to the US. Now after that economy started to collapse and goverment couldnt control that anymore.
 
Damn you just prove my point, i Can see how tolerant and accepting the left is by ur behaviour, the difference between left and right is left actually hurts people, and gets them fired from jobs just because they dont hols the same view as you, stop thinking ur opinions are facts.
The right actively targets marginalized communities and goes out of their way to make their life worst. Yeah, I’m not tolerant of them.

Right wingers have such a fucking victim complex about this and it’s honestly ridiculous.

“The left actually hurts people”. really? Are you fucking serious? Tell me, who supports:
  • Unrestricted access to assault weapons
  • eradicating trans people
  • Mass deportation
  • Mass incarceration
  • Extreme wealth inequality
  • The Police state
  • Curtailing women’s rights
It isn’t the left. The right’s politics are inherently violent. Any opposition they get is deserved.
 
The left is literally responsible for many dozens of genocides and dictatorships.
colonialism and capitalism killed more people
Post automatically merged:

Also America, which is run by right wing capitalists(regardless of party), actively murdered democratically elected socialists and replaced them with fascist dictators in dozens of countries.
 
Thats the story in Turkey at the coup night Erdogan said Gülen is behind it. It makes sense because their relationship was became bad at the time.
Their relationship might be bad. But the link between Gülen and the 2016 coup is yet to be established 7 years after. At this point, it's getting safer to assume that it's mostly or completely fabricated bullshit from Erdogan.

There is also a possibility/theory that Erdo did the coup himself to get rid of the Gülenists. The biggest reason people think like this is how they did the coup. They put few soldiers and tank at airports and big places. Thats not how you do coup. At least not we have seen in 80 and 97 coups.
Poorly prepared and rushed coup

Your first sentence is a conspiracy theory though


colonialism and capitalism killed more people
You might be right but this sounds a bit like what you americans call whataboutism
 
Did you just do a genocide apology?Fucking cunt.
No I'm just putting it into context.

right wing propaganda tends to exaggerate the deaths under socialist countries while conveniently ignoring deaths due to capitalism in order to make socialist countries seem cartoonishly more evil than they were.

Yeah its true the USSR and other socialists countries killed people. But that doesn't compare to what the capitalist did. America literally eradicated the native people of its land and had centuries of brutal enslavement of black people.
 
the opposition who, giving them the benefit of the doubt, really have no experience to go through next difficult years, or worst cast scenario, would completely open up Turkey to outside interference and influence.
I don't really believe in the argument that says "only Erdogan can rule because it's been 20 years, the opposition forgot how to govern".


And this has happened all under Erdogan, and there are a lot of people who do not believe in the opposition since their leaders have kept Turkey as a close to third world country for 80 years after Turkey´s founding.
Erdogan is supposed to be the peacekeeper that brings economic prosperity ?
 
The right actively targets marginalized communities and goes out of their way to make their life worst. Yeah, I’m not tolerant of them.

Right wingers have such a fucking victim complex about this and it’s honestly ridiculous.

“The left actually hurts people”. really? Are you fucking serious? Tell me, who supports:
  • Unrestricted access to assault weapons
  • eradicating trans people
  • Mass deportation
  • Mass incarceration
  • Extreme wealth inequality
  • The Police state
  • Curtailing women’s rights
It isn’t the left. The right’s politics are inherently violent. Any opposition they get is deserved.
All of the things u wrote are actually incorrect, to me it seems u are just a radical left commie who hates everyone, just go dye ur hair blue and u fit right in with twitter lunatics, again im saying ur opinions aren't facts, just because u dont like people having guns, capitalism, and having religous values doesn't make them violent, its just a different opinion, but when u force ur world view on others and threat and destroy peoples lives because of it like some of radical left does that is violence and dangerous, bully behaviour, that us shrouded by your delusion that "its ok cause im opressed and margenelized".
Go to a real fucking country where lgbt is death penalty or woman actually dont have rights before u complain about america
 
No I'm just putting it into context.

right wing propaganda tends to exaggerate the deaths under socialist countries while conveniently ignoring deaths due to capitalism in order to make socialist countries seem cartoonishly more evil than they were.

Yeah its true the USSR and other socialists countries killed people. But that doesn't compare to what the capitalist did. America literally eradicated the native people of its land and had centuries of brutal enslavement of black people.
Exaggerate?You guys literally killed more than Hitler.Ask the Ukrainians how fun it is to live under a socialist regime. Holomodor was pretty much the Ukrainian Holocaust.Capitalism is not an ideology,its a trade system.I havent seen any right winger been an apologists of genocides of any sort."A single death is a tragedy.Many deaths is an statistic"-Stalin.Sounds like you agree with bro Stalin.
Post automatically merged:

All of the things u wrote are actually incorrect, to me it seems u are just a radical left commie who hates everyone, just go dye ur hair blue and u fit right in with twitter lunatics, again im saying ur opinions aren't facts, just because u dont like people having guns, capitalism, and having religous values doesn't make them violent, its just a different opinion, but when u force ur world view on others and threat and destroy peoples lives because of it like some of radical left does that is violence and dangerous, bully behaviour, that us shrouded by your delusion that "its ok cause im opressed and margenelized".
Go to a real fucking country where lgbt is death penalty or woman actually dont have rights before u complain about america
its the old commie strategy of accusing people of being what THEY are.
Post automatically merged:

No I'm just putting it into context.

right wing propaganda tends to exaggerate the deaths under socialist countries while conveniently ignoring deaths due to capitalism in order to make socialist countries seem cartoonishly more evil than they were.

Yeah its true the USSR and other socialists countries killed people. But that doesn't compare to what the capitalist did. America literally eradicated the native people of its land and had centuries of brutal enslavement of black people.
Enslavement has been a thing all over the world since ancient times.It has been eradicated a few hundred years ago,dumbass.
 
Last edited:
Exaggerate?You guys literally killed more than Hitler.Ask the Ukrainians how fun it is to live under a socialism regime. Holomodor was pretty much the Ukrainian Holocaust.
.
how is this something inherent to socialism when capitalist russia is murdering Ukrainian in present day?

The difference between that and Hitler is that the Holocaust is an inherent part of nazi ideology. They want to create an ethnostate and genocide of undesirables is how that is accomplished. Even if the actual call to genocide wasn’t stated at the beginning, the ideology was always rooted in violence.

I don’t see how this is true for socialism. How is starvation an inherent factor of socialism when the goal of socialism is specifically to eliminate things such as hunger?
 
F

Formerly Seth

I will repost here only this time cause those pussies closed the thread.

its like fishman island. my family is ukrainian ethnically, and i grew up in a household speaking ukr and eng even though I was born in america and lived here my whole life. its a culture of hate, because everyone surrounding ukraine wants them dead and gone and has for as long as everyone has been alive. no one there trusts the left because 10 million people were starved to death in an attempted genocide under communism, with no choice to join or die, it was just "these guys are useless and we want the land, we need them to die so we can have the land" so they burned wheat fields and farms and locked people in their houses until they starved to death. so to many ukrainians the nazis were the lesser evil for just giving them the option to join instead of be killed for existing. its sad.

ukraine's best hope at any kind of freedom or unity was Nestor Makhno and he was brutally killed by stalin's communists for actually being left-wing and trying to help and protect poor people unconditionally.
I know a guy who literally doesn't speak to his family about the situation in Ukraine because they only watch TV and believe everything that is said there.

I know few Ukrainians actually.

It's crazy how different their view on the invasion is. Like holy fuck...

I don't mind them at all. My homie came here to Poland and found a better life. Although we can't allow them in left and right.

The % of Nazi ones is too big.
 
I don't really believe in the argument that says "only Erdogan can rule because it's been 20 years, the opposition forgot how to govern".




Erdogan is supposed to be the peacekeeper that brings economic prosperity ?
The people believe it though, apparently.

Why peacekeeper?
As a now arms manufacturer he is interested in conflicts as long as they are not at Turkey's door.
 
Top