Questions & Mysteries God Valley battle

[Juanpiz]

I wonder which Top Tier will be the fraud of God Valley

Where was he?

 

[Sasaki Kojirō]

Rayleigh has nothing to do with WB
Also why would Ray fight Garling when Garling and Navy was fighting Rocks

Kaido was in bad shape, he got saved by Linlin
So he either lost or won barely
[automerge]1695984341[/automerge]

Don't bother with that guy

Imagine thinking A fraud will lead conquerors like Kaido, WB, BM, Shiki... and will be Roger's greatest rival to a point it takes help to beat him in a fight
Someone whom Kaido hypes more

Stop wasting time with such users who are nothing but trolls

Kaido was in bad shape, he got saved by Linlin

It was never even mentioned that Kaido was in a terrible state; the only thing mentioned is that Linlin gave the Devil Fruit to Kaido, whether it was before or after the fight, that is not mentioned...

 

[MarineHQ]

Where was he?

Written out of existence

 

[JoNdule]

I said it was an extreme diff it doesn't matter if Kaidou lost or won he was still about to die or get captured
And yes Rayleigh would fight WB since he's in a rival crew and they're at war with said rival crew.

Yeah. Though Garling could have ran into him afterwards somehow and scarred him then.
Or Oda may even retcon Whitebeard's design a little to fit the timeline, who knows?

Rayleigh wouldn't fight WB
Stop expecting Rayleigh to fight major pirates
He's not that guy. He's a sidekick meant to fight guys like John, Axe, Wang Zhi

 

[Juanpiz]

Died of heart disease during time skip

Why not if PK suffered from an illness too

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Rayleigh wouldn't fight WB
Stop expecting Rayleigh to fight major pirates
He's not that guy. He's a sidekick meant to fight guys like John, Axe, Wang Zhi

Oda went out of his way to make the first person to harm Kizaru (who had just made his debut like two to three chapters before) Rayleigh, so this is dumb as hell.

 

[Juanpiz]

Oda went out of his way to make the first person to harm Kizaru (who had just made his debut like two to three chapters before) Rayleigh, so this is dumb as hell.

Also the reactions from the SHC and other rookies during his introduction ("it must be him", "everyone has heard about him"..)

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

I wonder which Top Tier will be the fraud of God Valley

Could be Garling, Rayleigh or Whitebeard

Rayleigh and Whitebeard don't seem nearly as relevant to the story of God Valley as Roger, Rocks and Garp, so they might get the short end of the stick in the inevitable flashback

Shiki too if he doesn't get notable paneltime

 

[bluefire12]

Other rox pirates vs sea beasts

 

[JoNdule]

Could be Garling, Rayleigh or Whitebeard

Rayleigh and Whitebeard don't seem nearly as relevant to the story of God Valley as Roger, Rocks and Garp, so they might get the short end of the stick in the inevitable flashback

Shiki too if he doesn't get notable paneltime

Not WB, he wasn't even in prime.
Same with Linlin and Shikj

Only Xebec, Ray, Roger, Garp and Garling were in prime back then. They were all around 38-42 which is peak years for 99% of OP characters

 

[ClovenHoofClown]

unrelated to the ongoing convos but if the gorosei and im dont have devil fruits and are actually just demons (or have powers granted to them through existing demons, whether thats through possession, a pact, or something else entirely), i think it would be cool if rox had the devil fruit for whatever the hell im is/isish
i doubt this would happen but itd still be cool, and could justify why rox was be strong enough to fight both garp & roger beyond "had good haki lol" (assuming he didnt have something like an awakened version of bbs fruit, or wasnt just a fraudgod like buggy)