Powers & Abilities Greatest 1 Vs 1 Duel world saw yet

Greatest duel that happened in the known history

  • Total voters
    42
Red Admiral

Red Admiral

‎
#1
#1
after seeing the duel of Roger Vs Whitebeard I'm not sure if it's safe to call this duel the greatest duel ever

I mean we saw some great CoA feats but for all we can guess Roger and Whitebeard held back their power as FUCK ...I doubt if they used even half of their power ... or 25% of it

if they would go all out the island would be dust in 5 min and all of their crew (but few people) would die for sure

so here is the question ... do you think this was the greatest deul the world saw so far?

what is the Greatest 1 Vs 1 Duel world saw yet?


Roger Vs PrimeBeard





Shanks Vs Mihawk





Akainu Vs Kuzan


​
 
Master OF Haki

Master OF Haki

‎
#4
#4
Duel or fight to death? Because there is big difference between them for example Mihawk vs Shanks is a duel (which means that they don't need to go all out or kill each other since there's no animosity between them) so they just wanna know who is better swordsmen amongst them and that is all whole in the other cases it's about taking down the other side and there is no other way for example Akainu vs Kuzan was about getting the position and none of them would give up so that was fight till death (even though Akainu didn't kill his friend at the end) same goes with Roger vs Wh they fight started as death fight even Roger claiming that they both will die but eventually ended up with big party.
 
M

MD Zolo

#5
#5
Difficult to comment on Mihawk vs. Shanks as we only know of it by the description given to us by WB. We didn't see the duel or the consequences of the duel.

So, for now Akainu and Aokiji will be my pick. However, if WB's description holds, Mihawk vs. Shanks is the greatest.

Roger and WB only had a sort of skirmish. There was no lethality to it. However, the other two fights had significance behind them. Mihawk vs. Shanks had WSS title to be taken and Akainu vs. Aokiji had the Fleet Admiral post to be taken.
 
J

Just a member

‎
#6
#6
That Roger vs WB was not a really serious duel, it was more like 2 old pals meeting after a long time, only the first clash was something like a shake of hand for them.

Mihawk and Shanks had a lot of duels and for sure one or more of them were serious ones, aka for the title of wss. Yet young Shanks and Mihawk are well below prime beard and Roger. Most likely even current Shanks and Mihawk at least until further infos are given.

Akainu was beaten by an old dying WB so this by default makes them a step below prime beard and Roger. Yet the duel was pretty much a last blood and this count.

Anyway the answer for me is Roger vs Xebec. It was probably a duel since Garp can not help when there were also WB, Kaido and BM to fight. Sure there were also Rayleigh, Scopper and Bogard but imo Garp had to take one of these guys for himelf. Plus having both Garp and Roger take on a single dude to win would dehype the duo and hype too much Xebec. Then, if this is the case, it is the deadliest duel. 2 top top tiers fighting to the death and also we have the complete destruction of god valley as a side effect.
 
M

MD Zolo

#7
#7
Just a member said:
That Roger vs WB was not a really serious duel, it was more like 2 old pals meeting after a long time, only the first clash was something like a shake of hand for them.

Mihawk and Shanks had a lot of duels and for sure one or more of them were serious ones, aka for the title of wss. Yet young Shanks and Mihawk are well below prime beard and Roger. Most likely even current Shanks and Mihawk at least until further infos are given.

Akainu was beaten by an old dying WB so this by default makes them a step below prime beard and Roger. Yet the duel was pretty much a last blood and this count.

Anyway the answer for me is Roger vs Xebec. It was probably a duel since Garp can not help when there were also WB, Kaido and BM to fight. Sure there were also Rayleigh, Scopper and Bogard but imo Garp had to take one of these guys for himelf. Plus having both Garp and Roger take on a single dude to win would dehype the duo and hype too much Xebec. Then, if this is the case, it is the deadliest duel. 2 top top tiers fighting to the death and also we have the complete destruction of god valley as a side effect.
Click to expand...
Until it can be confirmed that Roger vs. Xebec was 1v1, it can't be part of this discussion.
 
HA001

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
‎
#8
#8
Master OF Haki said:
Duel or fight to death? Because there is big difference between them for example Mihawk vs Shanks is a duel (which means that they don't need to go all out or kill each other since there's no animosity between them) so they just wanna know who is better swordsmen amongst them and that is all whole in the other cases it's about taking down the other side and there is no other way for example Akainu vs Kuzan was about getting the position and none of them would give up so that was fight till death (even though Akainu didn't kill his friend at the end) same goes with Roger vs Wh they fight started as death fight even Roger claiming that they both will die but eventually ended up with big party.
Click to expand...
Wasnt akainu v aokiji stated as a duel ?
 
Master OF Haki

Master OF Haki

‎
#10
#10
HA001 said:
Wasnt akainu v aokiji stated as a duel ?
Click to expand...
Depends on translation I've seen both variants but no mater what the meaning behind the fight/dule is very important since in some cases the oponnents aren't going to kill each other while on the other they are going to surpasse their limits to protect their friends and fight to death.
 
Dettles

Dettles

‎
#12
#12
If we see the place where Whitebeard and Roger fought and it's just a hole that never stops.
But I do see permanently changing the climate of an island, to be hard to beat.
 
Red Admiral

Red Admiral

‎
#14
#14
HA001 said:
To all the people saying shanks and mihawks duels were friendly and what not.
Wb wouldnt bring it up if thats the case.
Click to expand...
in one piece top tiers can fight for few days in a row and none of get a major scar ...

so it wasn't a death fight but it was a long fight

if a swing of Shanks sword can cut heavens
if a swing of Mihawk sword can cut a ice Mt

I can see they change islands to island to do the fight ... no normal island can take the damage


unless they were holding back for some reasons ... but to me it's unlikely ... this is a famous duel for a reason
Post automatically merged:

Buusatan94 said:
Roger vs Whitebeard is most likely the greatest. This is the duel between the two strongest and most legendary pirates has ever seen.
Click to expand...
it's true "if" there were all out ...

Roger Vs Prime beard was too much friendly ...
 
Daisuke Jigen

Daisuke Jigen

‎
#16
#16
Hard to say tbh. If the fight last chapter was the one that made people call Whitebeard the WSM after Roger died, then I have to give it to Akainu and Aokiji, since the island Roger and Whitebeard fought on was nowhere near as damaged as Punk Hazard, and afaik we haven’t seen or heard what happened to the place(s) where Mihawk and Shanks had their duels (other than the vague “shook the Grand Line” comment).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top